Swans Geelong match thread

[erica]

From Gieschen. Source: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsartic...4/default.aspx

"Another incident discussed was the 50m penalty awarded against Swan Sam Reid for over-running the mark following a Corey Enright grab on centre wing in the fourth quarter.

The penalty resulted in Enright kicking a goal from 40m to give the Cats the lead.

However, Gieschen said it was a wrong decision.

He said Enright had moved off the mark and Reid had every right to pressure his opponent.

"Because the umpire hadn't called play-on, the Sydney player was not obliged to cross," Gieschen said.

"The correct thing in that situation would have been for our umpire to call [play] on immediately Enright went around his mark."

Gieschen admitted it was a harsh penalty and said he called the Swans to apologise.

"We can't apologise [for] every error because we make a number of errors every week, but certainly in some games there are big errors we need to get on the front foot and call the club about," he said."

[Nico]

From Gieschen. Source: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsartic...4/default.aspx

"Another incident discussed was the 50m penalty awarded against Swan Sam Reid for over-running the mark following a Corey Enright grab on centre wing in the fourth quarter.

The penalty resulted in Enright kicking a goal from 40m to give the Cats the lead.

However, Gieschen said it was a wrong decision.

He said Enright had moved off the mark and Reid had every right to pressure his opponent.

"Because the umpire hadn't called play-on, the Sydney player was not obliged to cross," Gieschen said.

"The correct thing in that situation would have been for our umpire to call [play] on immediately Enright went around his mark."

Gieschen admitted it was a harsh penalty and said he called the Swans to apologise.

"We can't apologise [for] every error because we make a number of errors every week, but certainly in some games there are big errors we need to get on the front foot and call the club about," he said."

I heard that interview but having said the above he didn't mention anything about this being a common occurence. You see it so often that a player runs around in what looks like a ploy to draw the player over the mark. Umpires should be made to reset the mark. Surely one of the other 2 umpires could intervene.

[ShockOfHair]

One of Johnson's best games IMO. Smithy was back to his best too.

Very true on both of those. Johnson went through a stage for several games this year where he seemed to have a compulsory brain fade once or twice a game. He played faultlessly against Geelong and his kick to Everitt, who was caught behind his opponent, was perfect.

Apology from the Geish. Better frame it.

Did anyone hear his explanation for the Goodes play-on call?

[Nico]

Very true on both of those. Johnson went through a stage for several games this year where he seemed to have a compulsory brain fade once or twice a game. He played faultlessly against Geelong and his kick to Everitt, who was caught behind his opponent, was perfect.

Apology from the Geish. Better frame it.

Did anyone hear his explanation for the Goodes play-on call?

Heard that one. He said when he initially took the mark he turned and took 2 steps. That is when the umpire called play on and not for the feigned hand pass.

[BillyRayCypress]

Heard that one. He said when he initially took the mark he turned and took 2 steps. That is when the umpire called play on and not for the feigned hand pass.

He could take 2 steps providing he doesn't leave his line which he didn't from memory. So the feigned hand pass was not play on either.

Apology would have been wonderful if we had lost by 4 points. I'm sure he wouldn't have been admitting they stuffed up then.

[chalbilto]

Heard that one. He said when he initially took the mark he turned and took 2 steps. That is when the umpire called play on and not for the feigned hand pass.

Did he actually take 2 steps over the mark? Can someone elaborate if he did?

[bennyfabulous]

Heard that one. He said when he initially took the mark he turned and took 2 steps. That is when the umpire called play on and not for the feigned hand pass.

Thats just a convenient excuse so that they didnt have to admit 2 BIG errors in the one game. If this rule was strictly enforced, every player that takes a mark on the run towards goal, has to be called to have played on because its physically impossible to stop the instant you take a mark.

Giesch should be a politician, he lies incredibly well with a straight face!

[Velour&Ruffles]

Heard that one. He said when he initially took the mark he turned and took 2 steps. That is when the umpire called play on and not for the feigned hand pass.

He was walking back from the man on the mark. You are allowed to do it. In fact, it is impossible to move back from the man on the mark without doing it. I've heard some tish in my time but this is as steaming as any.

[crackedactor]

Did anyone noticed AJ?

Thought Teddy was good, really good and got a few doubtful frees paid against him early in the second.
The whole back line was fantastic. I have to praise Shaw for providing run but there were times when his man got loose and it was costly. But I though AJ was sensational as well.

Loved the ruck combo just pivotal for us doing so well in the first quarter and a goal in the third. Both boys were fabulous tonight.

Jack is sensational! Jettstar just the best! Armstrong was wonderful, his delivery is great.

The Umpiring sucked BIG TIME!!!!!!

I just want to know why we start a game with a wonderful game plan to run the ball and kick to point and then in the remaining three quarters just bomb the ball to packs.

Lots more I could say but just took an Endone so off to bed!!

Only thread that has praised Alex Johnston. I seriously thought he was BOG. His touches and punches and putting his body on the line to block his opponent was fantastic. Not one mention in the press. Also all these from just a 20 yr old!!
I also agree that Jetta is becoming a star. Did not do a lot but that tackle on Selwood was the tackle of the season, and after that did you notice that when a Geelong player had the ball and saw it was Jetta approaching that they instantly kicked the ball and did not bother trying to find a target!!
Pyke is now becoming an asset, he is really understanding how to play the game. Smart guy.

[GongSwan]

Pyke is just now getting up to the speed of AFL level footy, such is the gap between our ressies comp and top level. From this point we can hope to see a steady improvement from Myke and even better contributions, clearly an asset to the team and when Mummy gets to be fit, Myke may wel be kept in to play a role forward more than the ruck

[Panttz]

Agreed, I love the way Pyke goes about it and some of his taps are very sharp. I think he definitely has a spot in the side while Mummy is getting back to his best form.

It will be interesting to see what happens when Mummy is 100% in 3-5 weeks time, considering how the rucking is going over at North with Goldstein.

[Mel]

Only thread that has praised Alex Johnston. I seriously thought he was BOG. His touches and punches and putting his body on the line to block his opponent was fantastic. Not one mention in the press. Also all these from just a 20 yr old!!
I also agree that Jetta is becoming a star. Did not do a lot but that tackle on Selwood was the tackle of the season, and after that did you notice that when a Geelong player had the ball and saw it was Jetta approaching that they instantly kicked the ball and did not bother trying to find a target!!
Pyke is now becoming an asset, he is really understanding how to play the game. Smart guy.

AHEM!!!

I also want to put in a quick word for AJ. He ws really good last night. Seemed to be everywhere in the back line and for a 20 year old, he plays with such poise and calmness. Love him

[ugg]

[Nico]

Still reckon it warranted a 50 metre penalty. Enright knocked the ball away after he marked the footy, then he knocked it away on the ground and you see him look towards the umpire to see if he got away with it.

[Lucky Knickers]

Becoming more and more comfortable with that trade every week.