OTC

[wolftone57]

You think the Hawks player didn't hear the Umpie? Wrong! He picks the ball up looks over that side and decides to kick. There has been plenty of time it was not a split second. He thought he could get away with it and did.

[GongSwan]

Roos did mention that he wasn't going to put down ANZ as they had some great wins there.

360 degrees did not even mention those two decisions let alone show footage of them.

I just watched 360 and Robbo near had a coronary over the Puopolo one, but no mention of the 50

[SPC]

Well, they must have been very clear cut. The Geisch has just said on Its your Call, both decisions were wwwrrrooonngggg (yes it did hurt him on the way out) by the umpires involved. Makes the score look a little better if you change it by 12points!

[stellation]

Well, they must have been very clear cut. The Geisch has just said on Its your Call, both decisions were wwwrrrooonngggg (yes it did hurt him on the way out) by the umpires involved. Makes the score look a little better if you change it by 12points!

Wowzers!

[ugg]

Do you have a link?

[SydAFLFan]

Posted in other thread but as requested, http://bigpondvideo.com/AFL/484419/I...20Your%20Call/

[Beerman]

Gerrard to Mike and Roosy

'I guess one thing we learned from Saturday nights game, the swans should play all their games at the SCG'

Mike agrees
Roosy laughs

All agree scg is great place to watch footy

Interesting.....

I couldn't believe the noise given that half the stands were down. Fantastic atmosphere. I can wait until the new stands are complete and we can pack in 1.5x that number.

Compare that to the snooze-fest at ANZ in round one which had 40k+ (admittedly quality of opposition and importance of the game was a little different).

[Dirtyburt]

I couldn't believe the noise given that half the stands were down. Fantastic atmosphere. I can wait until the new stands are complete and we can pack in 1.5x that number.

Compare that to the snooze-fest at ANZ in round one which had 40k+ (admittedly quality of opposition and importance of the game was a little different).

Truly fantastic atmosphere, I also look forward to the 'cauldron' being back to full capacity. The scg is one of the great footy venues.

The other place... Well....

[Industrial Fan]

Last time we had a ROTTEN decision against the spirit and sense of the game when it mattered the most was the one against Leo 2006 out in Perth. We lost the game on that, the ump giving it was thrown out of the rest of the finals series as well as GF contention, and we went on to win the next game and play in the GF.

Based on that scenario, a bad (read horribbllle) decision against us went on to spur the boys into tooth and claw play, so we just may beat Geelong after all......And that ladies and gentlemen is how I see it today. Ask me again next week.

Not meaning to be the stickler, but that was in 2005 and it was closely followed by Goodes being tripped in our F50.

And so... that actually spurred us on to win the GF (along with a couple of other pieces falling our way)