Bob Skilton Medal 2012

[ScottH]

CLUB CHAMPION = Joey
RISING STAR = AJ?
MOST IMPROVED = Jetta
BEST CLUBMAN = Jude
PLAYERS' PLAYER = Ted

[longmile]

I think you're spot on there but Joey and Ted are easily interchangeable- i.e. one of them will win one and the other will win the other prize. And Pyke may give Jetta a run for most improved- but Jetta will probably snatch it!
What's the criteria for most improved? Do you have to be a debutant? Didn't AJ win it last year?

[swansrob]

I think you're spot on there but Joey and Ted are easily interchangeable- i.e. one of them will win one and the other will win the other prize. And Pyke may give Jetta a run for most improved- but Jetta will probably snatch it!
What's the criteria for most improved? Do you have to be a debutant? Didn't AJ win it last year?

I think Reid won Rising Star last year?
I might be wrong, but didn't Pyke win Most Improved in 2010?

[liz]

I think they use the same criteria for RS as the AFL rising star award (possibly with more flexibility over age). If so, Parker is possibly the only player eligible. (Well, other than Harry, whose one game against GSW probably won't be enough...)

Most improved: Jetta
BS medal: JPK
Clubman: Moore

[ScottH]

I think they use the same criteria for RS as the AFL rising star award (possibly with more flexibility over age). If so, Parker is possibly the only player eligible. (Well, other than Harry, whose one game against GSW probably won't be enough...)

I was wondering that.
That's why I picked AJ. The lesser amount of career games, but the most played this year.
Followed by Parker, Everitt, and TDL.
Then there is Armstrong, Morton, Walsh, and Cunningham.

[TakeTheSaucepan]

What's the criteria for most improved? Do you have to be a debutant? Didn't AJ win it last year?

Nick Smith won it last year

[Primmy]

CLUB CHAMPION = Joey Or Kizz
RISING STAR = AJ or Parkes
MOST IMPROVED = Ted or Pykey
BEST CLUBMAN = Doggy
PLAYERS' PLAYER = Ted
FINALS = Joey

[Lucky Knickers]

SKILTS: Ted
Rising Star: Parker based on criteria Liz pointed out. To come back from the jaw, the collar bone and a punch from your Dad deserves some sort of award.
Most Improved: Jetta
Best Clubman: Gazza
Players Player: Ted
Finals: Ted

[Swansinger]

BS=Kennedy , then Jack , then Ted , then ROK
MI = Jetta - easy choice - with Mattner 2nd
Finals = just about anyone

[swansrob]

SKILTS: Ted
Rising Star: Parker based on criteria Liz pointed out. To come back from the jaw, the collar bone and a punch from your Dad deserves some sort of award.
Most Improved: Jetta
Best Clubman: Gazza
Players Player: Ted
Finals: Ted

Gazza for Best Clubman is a pretty good bet, actually.

[ugg]

Bob Skilton Medal 2012

Who's your pick for our B&F?

Will it be the favourite Josh P. Kennedy or will Teddy Richards be the first backman to win it since Schaubs in 2000?
Will ROK make it three medallions in the past week?
Or will past winners Kieren Jack or Jarrad McVeigh claim their 2nd Bobby tonight?

Other awards up for grabs tonight are:
Rising Star
Most Improved
Best Clubman
Players' Player

[Plugger1300]

B&F - tie Ted and Rok
Rising Star - AJ
Most Improved - Jetta
Best Clubman - Gary Rohan/McGylnn
Players Player - Moore

[DamY]

Why don't you ask Triple B, he just won tickets over twitter :@

[Lucky Knickers]

SKILTS: Ted
Rising Star: Parker based on criteria Liz pointed out. To come back from the jaw, the collar bone and a punch from your Dad deserves some sort of award.
Most Improved: Jetta
Best Clubman: Gazza
Players Player: Ted
Revised Finals: Ryan

Just amending my Finals players to ROK.

[Swansinger]

Yep , LK , agreed - ROK for best over the three Finals.