Changes for Rnd 3 V GWS

[chalbilto]

I'd be exceptionally suprised if they brought in Brandon Jack. I would argue that Mitchell, Cunningham, Hewett and Jones may well be in front of him in the queue. He didn't make the 'best' list in ressies last week despite having the 4th best stats (as measured by Dream Team points).

I really hope we pick Mitchell though, just so we can't avoid your ad nauseum repeating of the same theory time and time again

Mcglynn as sub is my call with no other changes - but as Ugg says, they may prefer for Mcglynn to get another full game in the ressies, and then you'd expect Cunningham is likely to be next in line.

So do I, but not necessarily to debunk Matt80 theory (for to be quite frank I switch off at his repetitive rants and tend to ignore them) but because I like Tom Mitchell as he is a gun and hopefully he will show everyone his talent.

[mcs]

So do I, but not necessarily to debunk Matt80 theory (for to be quite frank I switch off at his repetitive rants and tend to ignore them) but because I like Tom Mitchell as he is a gun and hopefully he will show everyone his talent.

For that reason too - but imagine the peace and quiet on RWO if he is chosen - it would be a double win!

[Jewels]

Tackles are important. Was Buddy playing TFL when he saved the game against the Bombers? It would have been a quiet return drive to Canberra if Buddy had not made that tackle. It was the key play in that comeback 4th quarter.

The AFL community has been frothing at the mouth about Kurt and Buddy's combined 16 tackles against Port. The amazing thing is that Kurt and Buddy only kicked 4 goals between them, which is a modest goal scoring return.

Which AFL community would that be? I've watched AFL360 every night this week, OTC on Monday and I subscribe to both the Hun and Age and there has barely been any talk about our game and the only mention I can recall about Buddy and Tipps work, was Robbo making a reference to it in passing with (I think) King and McLure.
I used to think your posts were funny and quirky, but now you're just plain tiresome.

[Flying South]

My gut tells me that McGlynn and Mitchell have to be in our best 22 somewhere. The only other players I see at this stage who could demand selection any time soon are Zak Jones, maybe BJ and possibly Naismith. Indeed if Zak Jones is looking at a new start we would be well advised to give him a few starts and get him in the shop window so to speak, form permitting.

Goodes is shot, it's just a matter of how his demise is handled. That leaves who we drop. I rate Laidler and I like Towers' honest play but they strike me as being the players who are really playing for their spot every week.

It's a great position to be in

I think most agree that we have a bit if depth and that players like McGlynn, Mitchell, Jones could easily fit into the team. I would add Robinson, Naismith and Aliir to that. I have said this before, but why do we need to have a best 22. Why can't we have a senior squad of 25 or 26 players that are rotated regularly through the team. Example, why can't Jones play this week and Shaw plays back in ressies for a week. Why can't Mitchell play this week and Bird play ressies for a week. It gives those so called 'fringe' players a run, keeps everyone competitive and covers in case of injuries. As long as team balance is maintained. No point rotated Robinson through for a defender. Players may not like it too much, but the club comes first, not the individual. As many have said, no one should have a walk up start in the team. The only why I see it not working is we don't have that quality depth we think we do.

[dimelb]

My perceptive on the Goodes situation is sort of excitement, in a strange way. Over the last couple of years Adam has built into the season. Previously he had extra slow pre seasons. This one was not too bad for him but he is getting older and losing pace and touch. If he can get through, say 5 games uninjured and slowly get back into the top 22 even on a part time bases, then he will be a great asset for end of season games. His leadership and experience will be invaluable.

I'm not sure whether you meant perspective or perception, but whichever it is I agree!

[Flying South]

Won't be Mitchell. It think it will be McGlynn.

Longmire does not play Mitchell, Bird, Kennedy, and Parker in the same team.

If McGlynn is not ready then Brandon Jack will come into the subs vest. I don't mind Brandon as sub. He can come on late in the game and apply forward chasing pressure and nail 3-4 big tackles.

You make these statements like you know straight from Horse that he doesn't play those 4 together. Did he tell you this?

How many chances should BJ be given before someone else gets a shot? Someone like Robinson. He was on par with Lloyd when playing in reserves together. He deserves a crack before BJ.

[barry]

It's a good walk from Central station. You get to experience the culture and beauty of the Surry Hills terraces. You walk past vibrant bars, beautiful people and some odd ones.

It's uphill to the ground, but is pleasantly down hill on the way back.

Are u seriously trying to sell an uphill 20 minute walk in the rain as "easy to get to".?

25k will prove once and for all that the location of this ground hurts attendances.

[Xie Shan]

Are u seriously trying to sell an uphill 20 minute walk in the rain as "easy to get to".?

25k will prove once and for all that the location of this ground hurts attendances.

It will be better when the light rail is built, it should markedly improve how people get to the Moore Park precinct from the CBD. This was probably in the forefront of the club's mind when they signed the new agreement with the SCG.

[barry]

It will be better when the light rail is built, it should markedly improve how people get to the Moore Park precinct from the CBD. This was probably in the forefront of the club's mind when they signed the new agreement with the SCG.

Agree. Light rail will be awesome. When is it being built again?

[Matt80]

Which AFL community would that be? I've watched AFL360 every night this week, OTC on Monday and I subscribe to both the Hun and Age and there has barely been any talk about our game and the only mention I can recall about Buddy and Tipps work, was Robbo making a reference to it in passing with (I think) King and McLure.
I used to think your posts were funny and quirky, but now you're just plain tiresome.

AFL.com referred to Tippett and Franklin as "tackling machines" in an article. It's okay if you find my posts tiresome. My wife says to me "Matt I need five minutes silence".

I must say Jewels that I really enjoy your posts. You write very well.

[Big Al]

*yawns*

[Cant turn right]

Agree. Light rail will be awesome. When is it being built again?

Work is underway, they have started demolishing a block of apartments on Bourke St to make room for it.

[Meg]

Agree. Light rail will be awesome. When is it being built again?

Stage 3: Deliver a new CBD and south east service
Overhaul of CBD bus network to integrate with light rail and better connect commuters
Completion of light rail connecting Circular Quay, the CBD and the south east including Moore Park and the University of NSW, and the pedestrianisation of George Street between Bathurst and Hunter - with the system open and operational in 2019.

http://www.sydneylightrail.transport.nsw.gov.au/projects/sydney-light-rail

[Matt80]

You make these statements like you know straight from Horse that he doesn't play those 4 together. Did he tell you this?

How many chances should BJ be given before someone else gets a shot? Someone like Robinson. He was on par with Lloyd when playing in reserves together. He deserves a crack before BJ.

Selection comes out in 30 minutes. Let's see. There has not been more than three slower inside midfield extractors played since round four last year.

[barry]

Pity the nimbies canned the eastern suburbs train line.