GWS v Swans

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ludwig
    Veterans List
    • Apr 2007
    • 9359

    I think the Fyfe decision was inconsistent, but the common sense decision. Most similar incidents got a week or a fine, but few got off. The general rule has been is that if you go past the ball and make head high contact of any sort, you are are going to at least cop a fine. But the fans want to see the best player win the Brownlow, and that's Nat Fyfe this year. If he does miss out, it will be due to his Mitchell injury and related drop off in form. Would be ironic if Mitchell beat him for the Brownlow this year. The Swans also got one of these favourable decisions with Barry Hall's tummy tap, which was also orchestrated by the AFL so the top players get to play in the GF.

    Generally speaking, the Hodge penalty of 2 weeks was consistent with similar incidents with head high contact where the player involved wasn't seriously injured. Brown on Parker also looked very bad and Brown would have gotten more time had Parker been concussed. So both incidents were judged the same as far as the penalty goes, Hodge getting an extra week due to a poor record.

    Dermott Brereton, true to form, said Wingard dropping his head contributed to the impact. I'm surprised he didn't call for Wingard to charged for staging.

    Comment

    • CureTheSane
      Carpe Noctem
      • Jan 2003
      • 5032

      I'm OK with Fyfe.

      However Hodge had intent to me.
      Maybe not intent to do exactly what happened, but his intent was to whack the Wingard, and he did.

      My analogy of the AFL would be to doing the wrong thing while driving... "yeah, he was speeding when he had the car accident, but it was only minor low impact bumper damage. For us to throw the book at him, he really needs to have seriously injured someone, otherwise it's not so bad"
      The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

      Comment

      • Wardy
        The old Boiler!
        • Sep 2003
        • 6676

        I'm hopeful that Hawks play WC in the first week of finals and they smash the crap out of each other! (I know I shouldn't wish such things but I want someone to give Hodge what's coming to him)
        I used to be indecisive, but now I'm not so sure..................
        Chickens drink - but they don't pee!
        AGE IS ONLY IMPORTANT FOR TWO THINGS - WINE & CHEESE!

        Comment

        • Mug Punter
          On the Rookie List
          • Nov 2009
          • 3325

          Originally posted by Wardy
          I'm hopeful that Hawks play WC in the first week of finals and they smash the crap out of each other! (I know I shouldn't wish such things but I want someone to give Hodge what's coming to him)
          I see no problem wishing for this

          Comment

          • Ludwig
            Veterans List
            • Apr 2007
            • 9359

            Originally posted by Wardy
            I'm hopeful that Hawks play WC in the first week of finals and they smash the crap out of each other! (I know I shouldn't wish such things but I want someone to give Hodge what's coming to him)
            I'm hoping that Dermott Brereton and Eddie McGuire are the commentators for the game and they smash the crap out of each other.

            Comment

            • Bloodthirsty
              On the Rookie List
              • May 2013
              • 607

              Originally posted by Ludwig
              I'm hoping that Dermott Brereton and Eddie McGuire are the commentators for the game and they smash the crap out of each other.
              Smashing the crap out of Eddie is a full-time, long-term contract job. It requires a team of hundreds of employees working overtime. When an employee reaches retirement age, he hands over the job to his sons, and his sons' sons. It is a generational committment, requiring infinite man-hours and highly-skilled engineers, overseeing each stage. Documentary series such as "World's Greatest Feats" and "Wonders of Engineering" would feature this process.

              Such is the amount of crap in Eddie.
              "Take me down to the Paradise City where the grass is green and the Swans win pretty."

              Comment

              • Hotpotato
                Senior Player
                • Jun 2014
                • 2293

                Hope The Swans can pull a huge rabbit out the hat this year, but If NicNat stays intact, West Coast will go all the way... Not a very good price at $4.00 , but worth $25 of my hard earned.
                But Go Swannies ... You can do it as well ... But against the odds.

                Comment

                • Wardy
                  The old Boiler!
                  • Sep 2003
                  • 6676

                  Originally posted by Hotpotato
                  Hope The Swans can pull a huge rabbit out the hat this year, but If NicNat stays intact, West Coast will go all the way... Not a very good price at $4.00 , but worth $25 of my hard earned.
                  But Go Swannies ... You can do it as well ... But against the odds.
                  We've done it before - we can do it again (although it may require us to play "ugly" footy!!!) Would be rather funny if it was Swans v West Coast in the granny - 10th anniversary of our historic win and all!!
                  I used to be indecisive, but now I'm not so sure..................
                  Chickens drink - but they don't pee!
                  AGE IS ONLY IMPORTANT FOR TWO THINGS - WINE & CHEESE!

                  Comment

                  • YvonneH
                    Senior Player
                    • Sep 2011
                    • 1141

                    If we don't win the GF then I hope West Coast does (I see them as the only team that can beat Hawthorn at the moment, but that can change). For that matter any team other than Hawthorn gets my support.

                    Comment

                    • CureTheSane
                      Carpe Noctem
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 5032

                      Freo for me
                      The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                      Comment

                      • dimelb
                        pr. dim-melb; m not f
                        • Jun 2003
                        • 6889

                        I'd prefer Bulldogs, but I'd be happy with Freo if we can't.
                        He reminds him of the guys, close-set, slow, and never rattled, who were play-makers on the team. (John Updike, seeing Josh Kennedy in a crystal ball)

                        Comment

                        • Nico
                          Veterans List
                          • Jan 2003
                          • 11358

                          If the Dogs were playing a GF at Ethihad they would be red hot favs.
                          http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

                          Comment

                          • AnnieH
                            RWOs Black Sheep
                            • Aug 2006
                            • 11332

                            If we don't win it, I'd like to see Freo win it.
                            Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
                            Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.

                            Comment

                            • YvonneH
                              Senior Player
                              • Sep 2011
                              • 1141

                              I said on a previous post that I would prefer WC to win (only on the premise that I think they are the only team that can beat Hawks at the moment.) My preference would be Freo because they have not won one yet.

                              Comment

                              • barry
                                Veterans List
                                • Jan 2003
                                • 8499

                                Originally posted by YvonneH
                                I said on a previous post that I would prefer WC to win (only on the premise that I think they are the only team that can beat Hawks at the moment.) My preference would be Freo because they have not won one yet.
                                This is how it will play out for the top 4.

                                1st week

                                WC will beat Hawks at Subi in a torrid affair.
                                Swans will upset Freo who are starting to struggle after a good start. Tippet and Buddy kick 5 each.

                                2nd week.
                                Hawks have a real ding-dong game with the tigers. Many sore players, but Hawks win.
                                Freo beat whoever.

                                3rd week.
                                Swans rampage over broken Hawks on a glorious night at ANZ.

                                GF.
                                Freo v Swans.

                                Post finals.
                                Ban lifted, Dangerfield to Swans.

                                Comment

                                Working...