Round 1 Team V Collingwood

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ernie koala
    Senior Player
    • May 2007
    • 3251

    Round 1 Team V Collingwood

    My guess of the team line up, based on what I've seen in the NAB Cup.....

    FB : Smith Grundy Rampe
    HB : Laidler Richards Jones
    C : Jack Kennedy Hannebery
    HF : Heeney Franklin Cunningham
    FF : Papley Tippett Towers
    Fol : Sinclair Parker Mitchell
    Int : Mills, Talia, Lloyd, Hewitt

    Emg : Rose, Dawson, Nankervis

    Without the 4 or 5 injured players, we do look a little thin.
    I don't like having Towers in the team, but B Jack and Robinson have shown even less this year.
    I suspect Horse will pick him over Rose...Personally I'd like it the other way around.
    Nankervis, as back up ruck, is a worry. Let's hope we don't have to call on him any time soon...
    Personally I'd prefer Derrickx, at least he throws his weight around.
    Papley is the bolter, Horse may prefer Rose, both have looked lively, though I think Papley has been more involved.
    If they do upgrade Papley , then I assume Newman stays a rookie?

    Others thoughts?
    Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MT
  • ugg
    Can you feel it?
    Site Admin
    • Jan 2003
    • 15970

    #2
    I'm not sure Talia plays if Teddy is passed fit for Round 1. He would have to knock out one of Jones or Mills to make the back 7. I think we would be quite comfortable with Ted, Reg and Rampe as the 3 talls and Laidler to help out if required. Collingwood look to be running with Cloke as the main target, the resting ruck, Moore as the third tall and a bevy of medium/smalls like Fasolo, Varcoe and Blair as well as Swan spending more time forward.

    I would have picked Robinson in his place but Robbo went off injured after 1 quarter in today's NEAFL practice game and not sure what's wrong with him.

    Dawson if he has another strong game next week in the NEAFL practice match could be a bolter for round 1, not only does he provide something different with his long kicking but can also play back, forward or as he showed today in the midfield if required. But with Mills, Papley and Hewett in line to all debut I'm not sure Longmire will want to have a 4th debutant in the same team.
    Last edited by ugg; 12 March 2016, 10:09 PM.
    Reserves live updates (Twitter)
    Reserves WIKI -
    Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

    Comment

    • 111431
      Regular in the Side
      • Sep 2010
      • 698

      #3
      You wouldn't swap Newman for Jones ?

      Comment

      • ernie koala
        Senior Player
        • May 2007
        • 3251

        #4
        Originally posted by 111431
        You wouldn't swap Newman for Jones ?
        No, I think Jones will get the nod at this stage...

        Personally, I love the way he plays and suspect, injuries aside, he'll lock down a spot in defence this year.
        Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MT

        Comment

        • troyjones2525
          Swans Fanatic!
          • Mar 2008
          • 2908

          #5
          Originally posted by ernie koala
          My guess of the team line up, based on what I've seen in the NAB Cup.....

          FB : Smith Grundy Rampe
          HB : Laidler Richards Jones
          C : Jack Kennedy Hannebery
          HF : Heeney Franklin Cunningham
          FF : Papley Tippett Towers
          Fol : Sinclair Parker Mitchell
          Int : Mills, Talia, Lloyd, Hewitt

          Emg : Rose, Dawson, Nankervis

          Without the 4 or 5 injured players, we do look a little thin.
          I don't like having Towers in the team, but B Jack and Robinson have shown even less this year.
          I suspect Horse will pick him over Rose...Personally I'd like it the other way around.
          Nankervis, as back up ruck, is a worry. Let's hope we don't have to call on him any time soon...
          Personally I'd prefer Derrickx, at least he throws his weight around.
          Papley is the bolter, Horse may prefer Rose, both have looked lively, though I think Papley has been more involved.
          If they do upgrade Papley , then I assume Newman stays a rookie?

          Others thoughts?
          That's pretty much the lineup I would go with in round 1 considering a few of the injuries we have. It would be nice to a have a fit Sam Reid in the side against the pies with his versatility but we can only put out there who we have fit and ready to go so no point in dreaming!

          In saying that it's pretty exciting to see possibly 3 debutantes in the side and really does show that we don't have this old experienced list as the media and opposition supporters think we do!

          Comment

          • troyjones2525
            Swans Fanatic!
            • Mar 2008
            • 2908

            #6
            Originally posted by ugg
            I'm not sure Talia plays if Teddy is passed fit for Round 1. He would have to knock out one of Jones or Mills to make the back 7. I think we would be quite comfortable with Ted, Reg and Rampe as the 3 talls and Laidler to help out if required. Collingwood look to be running with Cloke as the main target, the resting ruck, Moore as the third tall and a bevy of medium/smalls like Fasolo, Varcoe and Blair as well as Swan spending more time forward.

            I would have picked Robinson in his place but Robbo went off injured after 1 quarter in today's NEAFL practice game and not sure what's wrong with him.

            Dawson if he has another strong game next week in the NEAFL practice match could be a bolter for round 1, not only does he provide something different with his long kicking but can also play back, forward or as he showed today in the midfield if required. But with Mills, Papley and Hewett in line to all debut I'm not sure Longmire will want to have a 4th debutant in the same team.
            Ugg, sounds like you may have witnessed this NEAFL practice match. Any chance of a detailed report for us Swans starved fans in the South??? Apologies if you already have in another thread.

            Comment

            • Untamed Snark
              Senior Player
              • Feb 2011
              • 1375

              #7
              Speaking of round 1, is there a Red & White footy tips this season?
              Chillin' with the strange Quarks

              Comment

              • liz
                Veteran
                Site Admin
                • Jan 2003
                • 16778

                #8
                Originally posted by Untamed Snark
                Speaking of round 1, is there a Red & White footy tips this season?
                Looking through the Competitions forum, I can't see evidence of one last year. Was there one?

                Regardless, it would be great to have a volunteer to organise one for 2016 and to post details on the Competitions forum.

                Comment

                • ugg
                  Can you feel it?
                  Site Admin
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 15970

                  #9
                  Originally posted by troyjones2525
                  Ugg, sounds like you may have witnessed this NEAFL practice match. Any chance of a detailed report for us Swans starved fans in the South??? Apologies if you already have in another thread.
                  I was waiting for the official report myself but that doesn't look like it will ever materialise

                  To be honest it was hard to gain too much for it was a bad ground to view the game from with no elevation and the only shaded area was under the roof of the GWS offices behind one of the goals

                  We started well probably shaded them in possessions and territory in the first quarter. They were marginally cleaner with the ball and the scores were roughly the same at quarter time. Both teams lost a major midfielder during this time - Robinson for us and Hopper for them

                  However for the next three quarters it was all one way traffic with GWS trapping the ball in our defensive half. Due to inaccuracy on their part, particularly in the last quarter, and a lack of quality in moving the ball out of our half (our kick in strategy seems to be solely consisting of Aliir booting it as far as he can to one wing) they had repeat inside fifty entries that overworked our exposed defenders

                  Individually:
                  Dawson was clearly our best on the day. He started as a CHF and where he demonstrated he had some marking ability in him. Spent some time in the midfield during the middle stretches of the game (including attending a few centre bounces) and eventually switched to defence in the latter part of the third he provided some much needed class there with his long kicking

                  Jack was our best midfielder. He ended up with two goals, one of which was a determined solo effort that saw him evade two tacklers in close quarters before snapping truly. He worked really hard all day which was no mean feat given the lack of support and the hot conditions

                  Xavier had a good battle with Patton, and acquitted himself well given how often the ball was being pinged back in his direction. Aliir had Matthew Flynn for most of the day, who was their second ruckman. Outpointed a few times when caught out of position.

                  Galloway rotated with Derickx in the ruck and both fell away after a bright start against the mammoth Dawson Simpson in the ruck. One of the coaches was continually shouting at Galloway about his starting position at throw ins

                  Marsh played inside midfield alongside Jack and Academy player Jake Veale. Struggled to win his own ball but one of our better distributors on the day.

                  O'Riordan started at HF and finished at HB. Very good kicking skills for someone new to the game but some poor decision making let him down. For example kicking across the defensive 50 to a clear one on one contest

                  Hiscox playing an outside role didn't get many touches or chances to show his speed. Didn't see much of Melican at all.

                  Final score from memory was 5.4 34 13.21 99
                  Jack kicked two Derickx one Academy player Tom Chichester one and Hiscox one
                  Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                  Reserves WIKI -
                  Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                  Comment

                  • dimelb
                    pr. dim-melb; m not f
                    • Jun 2003
                    • 6889

                    #10
                    Thanks ugg, always appreciated.
                    He reminds him of the guys, close-set, slow, and never rattled, who were play-makers on the team. (John Updike, seeing Josh Kennedy in a crystal ball)

                    Comment

                    • 707
                      Veterans List
                      • Aug 2009
                      • 6204

                      #11
                      Thanks Ugg, pleasing to see that Dawson showed up against what is a fairly strong side. Hoping that given the cameos we saw from him in the senior preseason games that he can develop quickly and get a senior call up. We need a player with his skill set. He may be a draft bolter!

                      As far as the team for R1 goes, I think the opening post just about nailed it. Papley must be a chance given his energetic and effective preseason games, probably vying with BJ for that small forward spot. Ted if ready will play rather than Talia. Mills will be about the 6/7th player picked! and Jones will definitely play.

                      Comment

                      • Doctor
                        Bay 29
                        • Sep 2003
                        • 2757

                        #12
                        Originally posted by liz
                        Looking through the Competitions forum, I can't see evidence of one last year. Was there one?

                        Regardless, it would be great to have a volunteer to organise one for 2016 and to post details on the Competitions forum.
                        I'm already in Footy Tips so I guess I could do it with Snarky? What do you think US? We can share the password or something.
                        Today's a draft of your epitaph

                        Comment

                        • troyjones2525
                          Swans Fanatic!
                          • Mar 2008
                          • 2908

                          #13
                          Looks like Teddy Richards won't play as he isn't playing reserves this weekend according to the swans website.

                          Comment

                          • ugg
                            Can you feel it?
                            Site Admin
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 15970

                            #14
                            Originally posted by troyjones2525
                            Looks like Teddy Richards won't play as he isn't playing reserves this weekend according to the swans website.
                            Link? I don't see a team list
                            Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                            Reserves WIKI -
                            Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                            Comment

                            • troyjones2525
                              Swans Fanatic!
                              • Mar 2008
                              • 2908

                              #15
                              Swans granted permission to play. Richards wasn't mentioned.

                              Comment

                              Working...