Changes for Rnd 6 V Brisbane.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Scottee
    Senior Player
    • Aug 2003
    • 1585

    #61
    Originally posted by Mug Punter
    With respect Ludwig I don't think Aliir is anywhere close to senior selection.

    He was deadest ordinary on Saturday and I was below Rhyce and AJ and he was absolutely doing there head in. He is a perfect physical specimen and he is athletically and physique wise ready for AFL football but he just seems to have no positional sense at all. His kicking is OK without being sensational.

    Maybe I saw him on an off day but from what I saw there is no way you could reward him on that.

    It really does highlight how critically exposed we are in the KPD area, especially when we can't call on Mr Versatility Reid. If Laidler is also out then we'd definitely bring in Jones and probably Towers. Rampe would take the second tall and we'd probably bring McVeigh down back for some experience.

    I'd be hoping very much we have him back for the Tigers but it gives Rampe an opportunity to show his wares in a more senior position and he's been a real unsung hero for us this year in my book

    - - - Updated - - -



    Not the craziest idea I've heard....
    Thanks for the insights Mug. It's hard to pick up position sense from video.

    Re the potential replacement, people seem to forget our up and coming quiet achiever who is both versatile and KPD size, Abe Davis, who was one of our best in the ressies. Must be a chance.

    Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk
    We have them where we want them, everything is going according to plan!

    Comment

    • barry
      Veterans List
      • Jan 2003
      • 8499

      #62
      Did X play defense for his senior game(s) last year ?

      Comment

      • Mel_C
        Veterans List
        • Jan 2003
        • 4470

        #63
        Originally posted by barry
        Did X play defense for his senior game(s) last year ?
        Yes I remember him playing in defense in the Eagles game in Perth. I think both Ted and Grundy were missing from that game. He started off shaky but then was ok.

        With regards to Ted's injury I remember during the game the commentators mention that Kennedy had injured Ted after earlier knocking out Laidler. Then at half time I remember seeing the doctor in the rooms checking out Ted's eye and cheek bone. It's a shame he is injured now that he has found form and confidence.

        Comment

        • Swansongster
          Senior Player
          • Sep 2008
          • 1264

          #64
          Originally posted by snajik
          And thankfully we've seen the back of Corporal Punishment.
          Can't wait until we give Hawthorn a Colonel Oscopy.

          Comment

          • aardvark
            Veterans List
            • Mar 2010
            • 5685

            #65
            Sounds like Gary Rohan might get a run this week.

            HCF Injury Update - Rd 6, 2016 - sydneyswans.com.au

            Comment

            • chalbilto
              Senior Player
              • Oct 2007
              • 1139

              #66
              Great news about Rohan. I expect that he will play in the NEAFL before a call up to the firsts.

              Comment

              • WolfGang
                Pushing for Selection
                • Nov 2005
                • 68

                #67
                I would just play Xav Richards until Ted comes back in the side.

                Even if its 2 to 3 weeks - if it is 3 weeks - at the end of 3 weeks - a clearer view of Xav Richards can be made.

                Comment

                • Ludwig
                  Veterans List
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 9359

                  #68
                  To get a realistic appraisal of the Brisbane side we'll be facing, Tom Cutler, Josh Green and Ryan Bastinac will all miss due to injury. Allen Christensen will have a concussion test. Dayne Beams is still not available. It's not taking Brisbane lightly, only that a weak side will be even weaker when they play us. The point being that we needn't worry too much about changes this week as far as victory is concerned. This year's Swans haven't really played a poor quarter; a very different story from last year. Thanks to the youngsters, who are out to impress and hold their spots, this year's team does not show any signs of becoming complacent. Maybe it's Kirk's influence, as some have suggested.

                  Bringing in inexperienced players, or even playing Rohan without a NEAFL game, doesn't risk much.

                  I'm not bothered if we play XR or Aliir, but at least one should be given a go this week.

                  Sam Reid remains on 2 weeks. At this rate Michael Talia will be back before Reid. No mention of Dawson, who missed the past 2 ressies' games; must be a groin complaint, they never seem to list those.

                  Interesting to note that all 6 players on our injury list are either defenders or ones that play either forward or defence.
                  Last edited by Ludwig; 26 April 2016, 06:01 PM.

                  Comment

                  • barry
                    Veterans List
                    • Jan 2003
                    • 8499

                    #69
                    Id go as far to say that if grundy qent down with an ijury early in the game, brisbane would beat us. Our weakness is defense and its even weaker now.
                    Danger game. Its at the gabba and they beat the suns who i rate

                    Comment

                    • Faunac8
                      Senior Player
                      • Mar 2014
                      • 1548

                      #70
                      Originally posted by barry
                      Id go as far to say that if grundy qent down with an ijury early in the game, brisbane would beat us. Our weakness is defense and its even weaker now.
                      Danger game. Its at the gabba and they beat the suns who i rate
                      If this injury was to actually occur our team is still flexible enough to cover his loss. The ball needs to get down to our backline for a start and our midfield would hold the fort and starve the opposition of possession. Failing that I would be confident that we have more than enough scoring power to still outscore Brisbane comfortably. I rate Grundy but his absence shouldn't impact on the Swans performance against teams in the bottom half of the ladder.

                      Comment

                      • Mug Punter
                        On the Rookie List
                        • Nov 2009
                        • 3325

                        #71
                        Originally posted by Scottee
                        Thanks for the insights Mug. It's hard to pick up position sense from video.

                        Re the potential replacement, people seem to forget our up and coming quiet achiever who is both versatile and KPD size, Abe Davis, who was one of our best in the ressies. Must be a chance.

                        Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk
                        I thought Abe was mainly playing up forward, at least he seemed to on Saturday.

                        At the risk of sounding like a Ressies basher I thought he looked a but "heavy", perhaps even carrying a bit of extra padding, certainly not the physique of a senior AFL footballer

                        Comment

                        • Mug Punter
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Nov 2009
                          • 3325

                          #72
                          Originally posted by barry
                          Id go as far to say that if grundy qent down with an ijury early in the game, brisbane would beat us. Our weakness is defense and its even weaker now.
                          Danger game. Its at the gabba and they beat the suns who i rate
                          I don't know about that but I do agree the Lions are not to be taken lightly. And we are certainly very vulnerable at the back if Red goes down but then again most clubs would struggle if they had their top three KPDs out I guess.

                          It will be interesting to see how we address the KPD issue at season end if Ted does retire as I think he will. Reid could well be placed permanently down back and I wouldn't also be surprised to see us trade our first round draft pick next year for an up and coming backman much like what we did to get Ted in the first place.

                          Comment

                          • Luke Shannon
                            Suspended by the MRP
                            • Apr 2016
                            • 119

                            #73
                            Originally posted by chalbilto
                            Great news about Rohan. I expect that he will play in the NEAFL before a call up to the firsts.
                            I think Rohan would need at least two NEAFL games before coming into the seniors.

                            A forward line of Franklin, Tipett / Sinclair Heeney, Rohan and Papley is very exciting.

                            I think Robinson would be the most likely out for Rohnan.

                            Rohan also gives the flexibility to play in the backline. His 2014 preliminary final game was the greatest game played by a half back flanker according to Wayne Carey.

                            As for Sam Reid, I think if he was listed as 2 weeks it would end up being 4 weeks. Those Reid boys take longer than other players.

                            Comment

                            • Scottee
                              Senior Player
                              • Aug 2003
                              • 1585

                              #74
                              Originally posted by Mug Punter
                              I thought Abe was mainly playing up forward, at least he seemed to on Saturday.

                              At the risk of sounding like a Ressies basher I thought he looked a but "heavy", perhaps even carrying a bit of extra padding, certainly not the physique of a senior AFL footballer
                              Abe was recruited as a KPP who could play both forward or back. He is the same height as Reg and just a few kilos lighter and has also been played on the wing and in the midfield so has no problems with his tank. Plays in a fairly low key mnner but is very effective. He could easily be a Reg replacement in a few years IMHO.

                              He was third highest possession winner in the last ressies game I think and seems to be fully fit after a slow start to the season.Must be a chance.

                              Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk
                              We have them where we want them, everything is going according to plan!

                              Comment

                              • Mug Punter
                                On the Rookie List
                                • Nov 2009
                                • 3325

                                #75
                                Originally posted by Scottee
                                Abe was recruited as a KPP who could play both forward or back. He is the same height as Reg and just a few kilos lighter and has also been played on the wing and in the midfield so has no problems with his tank. Plays in a fairly low key mnner but is very effective. He could easily be a Reg replacement in a few years IMHO.

                                He was third highest possession winner in the last ressies game I think and seems to be fully fit after a slow start to the season.Must be a chance.

                                Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk
                                I see Abe as a long term prospect but it may not be this year he gets his chance but I'd probably go for him over Aliir if we blood another rookie

                                - - - Updated - - -

                                Originally posted by Luke Shannon
                                I think Rohan would need at least two NEAFL games before coming into the seniors.

                                A forward line of Franklin, Tipett / Sinclair Heeney, Rohan and Papley is very exciting.

                                I think Robinson would be the most likely out for Rohnan.

                                Rohan also gives the flexibility to play in the backline. His 2014 preliminary final game was the greatest game played by a half back flanker according to Wayne Carey.

                                As for Sam Reid, I think if he was listed as 2 weeks it would end up being 4 weeks. Those Reid boys take longer than other players.
                                Rohan faces a fight to regain his spot on the list. I know he had the horrific injury he has come back from but for mine he owes the club big time and whilst he was not alone in our 2014 GF disgrace he was one of the worst.

                                I know he is under contract until 2017 but of we are looking at freeing up some space and getting some 2017 draft picks or looking for a make-weight in a KPD trade then Gary has trade bait written all over him

                                Comment

                                Working...