Rnd.12 Match Day Thread. GWS V Sydney. 4.40pm at Spotless.

[Ludwig]

Tippett hamstring behind the knee
Rohan Hamstring
Reid hurt his calf in the ressies.

Great night!

I heard the pressie, but odd about Tippett since they iced the medial side below the knee, so hard to see how that's a hamstring. He was also pointing to that spot when discussing the injury with the doc.

Rohan's injury was described as a corkie that bled into the hamstring, so may not be that serious, although doubt he will be playing next week.

Am sick of Reid and his soft tissue injuries. I think he's a good player, but seems to hardly ever play. I think we need to bring Abe Davis in to give us another forward option. It doesn't seem like we are likely to see much of Reid this year.

I thought it was going to be a development year for us, and in the end it probably will be. I'm okay with that.

[Nico]

Whatever you think of the rest of his game he didn't look soft when he tried to tackle a rampaging Mummy in the first quarter. He may have been brushed aside but he didn't hesitate when it was his turn to go.

Unfortunately for HC, he was in the wrong place. That was about all he did all game. You don't win a flag with a soft rooster like him in the team. He had 11 stats which says he went where the footy wasn't. None in the 3rd quarter. Worst player in the 22. Towers supposedly got left out because he didn't go hard enough at a contest, yet Cunningham gets away with it every week.

[0918330512]

Dont blame the umps.
I count 5 mcveigh kicks to giants players. Could have been the difference. Horse moved him forward so his turnovers weren't so costly

Oh FFS, I have to call BS here! Statistically we lost by 7 goals. You count 5 errors by Macca. Still two goals short. And you're assuming that every Macca error resulted in a GW$ goal. They. Did. Not.

Seriously, if Macca seems a little slower of foot this year, I don't think it's necessarily because he's too old. I suspect it's because he spends every week with Barry on his back!

[The Big Cat]

I heard the pressie, but odd about Tippett since they iced the medial side below the knee, so hard to see how that's a hamstring. He was also pointing to that spot when discussing the injury with the doc.

The hamstring is in fact 3 muscles. Two of them attach to the inside of the Tibia just below the knee and the other bigger one attaches to the outside of the Fibia just below the knee, just where Kurt was pointing. A00408F01T.jpg

[Burra]

The dumbest player we have.

At least he has a crack!

[Ludwig]

The hamstring is in fact 3 muscles. Two of them attach to the inside of the Tibia just below the knee and the other bigger one attaches to the outside of the Fibia just below the knee, just where Kurt was pointing. [ATTACH=CONFIG]1519[/ATTACH]

Yes. It seems that it's a hamstring tendon injury, which is not good at all. Could be season over for KT.

[goswannies]

The hamstring is in fact 3 muscles. Two of them attach to the inside of the Tibia just below the knee and the other bigger one attaches to the outside of the Fibia just below the knee, just where Kurt was pointing. [ATTACH=CONFIG]1519[/ATTACH]

Fibula, not fibia.

The common unjury would be a strain of the biceps femoris muscle at or just above the muculo-tendonous junction. Worse would be a rupture of the tendon itself ... or an avulsion or fracture avulsion (pulling away the bone that the tendon attached to) of the biceps femoris.

With the severe injuries, there is almost no way he would walk unaided. But a severe muscle strain would also be fairly lengthy recovery too.

[Nico]

Oh FFS, I have to call BS here! Statistically we lost by 7 goals. You count 5 errors by Macca. Still two goals short. And you're assuming that every Macca error resulted in a GW$ goal. They. Did. Not.

Seriously, if Macca seems a little slower of foot this year, I don't think it's necessarily because he's too old. I suspect it's because he spends every week with Barry on his back!

Barry has a point on McVeigh. As I see it he is getting the ball just as much as last year, so it is not age or fitness; he is slaughtering it way too much by foot. For whatever reason he is now chip kicking sideways and to a contest or a small man who is either outnumbered or out of position. Or he turns back into play and tries to hand pass. He has certainly slowed down and gets himself into trouble. Trouble is other players seem to be following suit, often inexperienced players. If he is now doing this rubbish at this stage of his career we are way better off with him up forward. We need penetration off half back not stuff ups through the mid filed.

[The Big Cat]

With the severe injuries, there is almost no way he would walk unaided. But a severe muscle strain would also be fairly lengthy recovery too.

I don't think he would have pulled the tendon off the bone otherwise the docs wouldn't have been prodding around in the general area of the soreness. The muscle would have been half rolled up his leg.A00408F04.jpg

[0918330512]

Barry has a point on McVeigh. As I see it he is getting the ball just as much as last year, so it is not age or fitness; he is slaughtering it way too much by foot. For whatever reason he is now chip kicking sideways and to a contest or a small man who is either outnumbered or out of position. Or he turns back into play and tries to hand pass. He has certainly slowed down and gets himself into trouble. Trouble is other players seem to be following suit, often inexperienced players. If he is now doing this rubbish at this stage of his career we are way better off with him up forward. We need penetration off half back not stuff ups through the mid filed.

I agree his (Macca's) form isn't great. It's just Barry's form is far worse. He whines more than a Richmond supporter when their season ends in disappointment. Barry just doesn't let up. It's tiresome. Statistically Macca wasn't our worst tonight. If you listen to Barry harping on, you'd think Macca had the stats of Paul Chambers' first few matches. [Yawn]

[goswannies]

I don't think he would have pulled the tendon off the bone otherwise the docs wouldn't have been prodding around in the general area of the soreness. The muscle would have been half rolled up his leg.[ATTACH=CONFIG]1520[/ATTACH]

That was my point. With Tippett walking around unaided after the game, it's more likely to be a low/mid- grade strain of the distal tendon or muscle. No guarantee, but more likely.

[barry]

I agree his (Macca's) form isn't great. It's just Barry's form is far worse. He whines more than a Richmond supporter when their season ends in disappointment. Barry just doesn't let up. It's tiresome. Statistically Macca wasn't our worst tonight. If you listen to Barry harping on, you'd think Macca had the stats of Paul Chambers' first few matches. [Yawn]

You cant handle the truth.


Sent from my GT-N7105 using Tapatalk

[barry]

Play of the day was the guy who won $100,000 kicking it into the tyres at 3/4 time.

[Matt79]

Play of the day was the guy who won $100,000 kicking it into the tyres at 3/4 time.

LOL...I reckon! My Mrs and I just looked at each other prior to him having the kick and said, "As if he will get that!"....amazing kick!

[Velour&Ruffles]

GWS were very good.

Umpiring was really bad, but didn't impact the result of the game by a long shot.

Agree with this. The umpiring was quite possibly the worst, most inconsistent, most frustrating I have ever seen. It made the game enraging to watch. Rules seemed to apply for one side but not the other. But we still lost it all by ourselves