My guess is Jones and McVeigh in, Towers and one of Florent \ Hayward out. Hayward only if he needs a rest though.
Changes Round 15 V Melbourne
Collapse
X
-
-
Jones is an automatic in. After that there's a logjam of players jostling to come in over the next 2-3 weeks: McVeigh, Aliir, Dawson, Robinson, Cunningham. I'm just not sure who makes way. The obvious candidates are Towers and Florent. After that ...Comment
-
Whilst I also think towers should be omitted his not that bad in the ruck. He has pinch hit there in the ressies and he actually has quite a decent vertical leap. Physically he is undersized yes but he's "expendable" as far as injury. Better than risking buddy and Reid in the ruckComment
-
We brought in melican for the tall essendon forward line. Therefore against Melbourne, he will make way for Jones.
Towers is our in and under tagger. Stats don't matter when you are pressuring and tackling. He'll only be replaced like for like... And that ain't McVeigh who is the exact opposite.
Newman could get Hayward a rest. Unlikely though.
Florentine 50/50 to stay.
- - - Updated - - -
Florent. Damn autocorrect.Comment
-
Comment
-
They don't show the countless missed tackles.
The constant coughing up of the ball due to bad decision making and panicking.
If he was masquerading as an 'in and under tagger', it was unrecognisable.
He's got to go.Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MTComment
-
Since Mitchel left, who else is doing the hard in and under stuff ?Comment
-
Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MTComment
-
The ins will be Jones & McVeigh. No doubt at all.
Outs will probably be Florent and Marsh, unless Rohan is to spend more time forward and they leave out Towers or Hawyard (rest). I tend to think that Towers is in at least until Cunningham returns.Today's a draft of your epitaphComment
-
Comment
-
I like Melican to stay in that way Reid can Stay forward and not have to swing back as much.
Melbourne had their best tall defender Macdonald kick 5 including the winner cos WC had no tall fwds putting pressure on.
If we stay tall they will have to keep MacDonald in defenceComment
-
Koala, there is nothing to be gained by death-riding our bottom-4,fringe players and blaming them for outcomes. They arent world beaters, and nobody should expect them to be. They get given specific roles and judged on those roles.
McVeigh would be an "interesting" selection, especially with Jones coming back in. In my opinion adding two smalls into the defense would be too disruptive.
Newman only gets a call up if Hayward is getting tired. Otherwise I think Newman will have to wait until we have a less critical game (eg against lions).Comment
-
What is all this about Newman getting a call up and Marsh getting dropped, barry and Doctor? Which game were you watching? Can I presume you respectively mean Dawson and Melican?All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
Comment