Most talented list

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mark26
    Senior Player
    • Jan 2017
    • 1535

    #46
    Originally posted by liz
    Don't really agree with that. Reid is - and has been for many seasons - an automatic selection in the 22 and predominantly as a forward. In 2017 he was often moved back for the final few minutes of each quarter for tactical reasons, nothing to do with how he was going up forward.

    As a forward he's performed to a pretty decent level over the stretch of his career, without ever threatening to become a star of the competition. The main knock on him has been his ability to get injured at inopportune times. I don't see how the presence or absence of Tippett really impacts on his role at all. If the coaches want yet another tall in the forward line, they'll just select Sinclair as well. If they don't, Sinclair will play in the NEAFL.
    I also rate Reid. I'd prefer him forward, but agree with Liz in that he has been used as a shore up against attack in the final minutes of each quarter. I think it's a solid coaching strategy actually. When he has had to play in the backline, I don't think he's been a total disaster either. Let's not forget he's also a premiership player for us.

    Comment

    • Ludwig
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2007
      • 9359

      #47
      Hopefully Aliir has the preseason to earn his way into our starting back six. That should obviate the need to use Reid defensively in the closing minutes of quarters, or perhaps we could swap Reid and Aliir at these times, as Sam reads the flight of the ball better than Aliir. I like the idea of the swap as it can shake up opposition defenses without us losing anything at our defensive end.

      Comment

      • CureTheSane
        Carpe Noctem
        • Jan 2003
        • 5032

        #48
        Originally posted by liz
        Don't really agree with that. Reid is - and has been for many seasons - an automatic selection in the 22 and predominantly as a forward. In 2017 he was often moved back for the final few minutes of each quarter for tactical reasons, nothing to do with how he was going up forward.

        As a forward he's performed to a pretty decent level over the stretch of his career, without ever threatening to become a star of the competition. The main knock on him has been his ability to get injured at inopportune times. I don't see how the presence or absence of Tippett really impacts on his role at all. If the coaches want yet another tall in the forward line, they'll just select Sinclair as well. If they don't, Sinclair will play in the NEAFL.
        I guess I should have thrown a few 'IMO's' in there.
        Tippet is irrelevant to Reids role.
        But he is very relevant to Reid attracting extra attention due to the fact that Swans fans have lost one of the whipping boys.
        Tippo leaving will also have an impact on Towers and McVeigh. Possibly Jack and Smith.
        They'll all get a bit more critique if they under perform.

        Unlikely to have much of an effect on Foote who it seems most have already completely given up on....
        The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

        Comment

        Working...