Anyone OUT?
Changes Round 21 Demons v Swans
Collapse
X
-
I'm not a punter, but tempted by those oddsThe difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.Comment
-
We made the mistake of not bringing Reid straight back into a grand final in 2014 (or 2016, can't recall exactly).
Pray we don't make that mistake again.Comment
-
-
Yes - Dees have an in-form midfield, and the best ruck in the league. We don't. Also, our best player doesn't train either, so I wouldn't read too much into Gawn walking laps.
We will be smashed. 30+ points.Comment
-
We’ve got a good record against Melbourne, but if their midfield gets in top, as is likely, it could get ugly.
They are weak in defence and on the outside.
Going in fearing the worst but hoping for the best.Comment
-
Odds are spot on
Doesn't mean we can't win though
But in my opinion they have priced the game correctlyComment
-
Reid comes back.
We lose.
Chorus of "why did the Swans bring back half done players"
Repeat with Hanners etc.
To be honest there have been times where I've advocated playing players who were not fully fit, and I was wrong.
Generally it was done out of sentiment in a final.
But no longer.
I now see the merit in the argument others have had that you only ever play fully fit and match ready players.
Reid - seaosn
Hanners - only play him if we need to build his value, otherwise why would we play him based on recent form?The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.Comment
-
I think it has to be a case by case basis. If we stuck to that, Buddy would be sitting in the stands at the moment.Reid comes back.
We lose.
Chorus of "why did the Swans bring back half done players"
Repeat with Hanners etc.
To be honest there have been times where I've advocated playing players who were not fully fit, and I was wrong.
Generally it was done out of sentiment in a final.
But no longer.
I now see the merit in the argument others have had that you only ever play fully fit and match ready players.
Reid - seaosn
Hanners - only play him if we need to build his value, otherwise why would we play him based on recent form?Bloods
"Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob SkiltonComment
-
The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.Comment
-
Not really sure how injured Buddy actually is. He just kicked 6.4 (and set up the Ronke & Kennedy goals with his insanely good field kicking) and pretty much won a game by himself against a fairly decent opponent.Comment
-
I reckon look at the team and whether it would be better with / without Hanners, Reid etc. Plus whether they can last a whole game.
I reckon Reid would have gone better than Xavier in the 2016 GF and broken Hanners is still better than our worst.Comment

Comment