Team changes 1st elimination final v GWS

[barry]

I read somewhere that Reid will be playing NEAFL next weekend. So it we beat the Giants he might well come into the side.

With Reid back, we can be a threat

[liz]

I read somewhere that Reid will be playing NEAFL next weekend. So it we beat the Giants he might well come into the side.

If he makes it past quarter time. I won't be holding my breath.

[Markwebbos]

Hannebery fit to face Giants - sydneyswans.com.au

"Key forward Sam Reid is continuing to near a return to AFL and is expected to line up for the Swans first NEAFL final in a fortnight."

[Sandrevan]

Ins: Franklin, Parker
out: Fox, Newman

I want to keep Dawson in and Robbo has been playing his role well.

Rohan - he would come in for McCartin but I can't see it happening.

Hannebery - I doubt they'll omit him.

[707]

We'll tag a couple of their key playmakers, was it Robbo who shut down Whitfield last time, if so Robbo won't be dropped.

[dejavoodoo44]

We'll tag a couple of their key playmakers, was it Robbo who shut down Whitfield last time, if so Robbo won't be dropped.

Robbo and Handbrake Harry Cunningham shared time on Whitfield, if I remember rightly. Possibly Cunningham spent a little bit more time on him.

[royboy42]

I think newman and fox are our two weakest players. Fox goes missing and newman struggles under pressure. I wouldnt bother with rohan.

Would like to see hanneberry dropped but it wouldnt be a good look. Mind you he played a stellar game against the dees a few weeks ago

At the MCG? He was awful.

[Flying South]

What is the match up for him?

Cameron? Himmelberg? Lobb?

Keeping him in is more of a risk, we need to match their pace.

Grundy's experience will be invaluable. Aliirs inexperience is more of a risk. Especially after last week. Confidence should not be questioned in finals football.

[crackedactor]

At the MCG? He was awful.

I hate to say it but I bet they pick Rohan for sure. The problem with that is he may play a decent game in the small SCG, but if the Swans go further, he will be picked to play at the WACA or MCG and will be have no idea how to play the ground and will be lost like a man stuck in the middle of the Sahara desert! Just on thesubject of awful at the MCG.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[barry]

I hate to say it but I bet they pick Rohan for sure. The problem with that is he may play a decent game in the small SCG, but if the Swans go further, he will be picked to play at the WACA or MCG and will be have no idea how to play the ground and will be lost like a man stuck in the middle of the Sahara desert! Just on thesubject of awful at the MCG.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Thats what we all fear, but we also have a tiny bit of hope he'll have a finals series for the ages.

[chalbilto]

Obviously I am going against the consensus of posters by declaring that I would love to see Rohan in the team. He will never be a stats accumulator but he does have that X factor where he can do something with his pace. I would love to see him play deep in attack using his speed coming to the attacking player out of the square. Buddy could be use a decoy. He is a good mark and a very good long kick.

[Melbourne_Blood]

Obviously I am going against the consensus of posters by declaring that I would love to see Rohan in the team. He will never be a stats accumulator but he does have that X factor where he can do something with his pace. I would love to see him play deep in attack using his speed coming to the attacking player out of the square. Buddy could be use a decoy. He is a good mark and a very good long kick.

Hmm it’s a an interesting point. We need some X factor , he has finals experience and maybe we do need to roll the dice. Nick Davis was never super consistent for us but in one final he made himself a Swans legend for life.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[waswan]

I reckon we need a Hail Mary againsy GWS, Reid in Roham in we need to change up our fwd line otherwise they shut buddy doen too easy by himself

Got lucky with Davis being out last time

[707]

I reckon we need a Hail Mary againsy GWS, Reid in Roham in we need to change up our fwd line otherwise they shut buddy doen too easy by himself

Got lucky with Davis being out last time

and Dopey Greene!

[ernie koala]

For mine we need more pace to go with GWS....

IN: Franklin, Parker, O'Riordan, Rohan

OUT : Fox, Hannebery, Newman, Grundy

I only include Grundy on this list because I can't see a match up for him.