#AFLFinals 2ndEF Swans vs Giants, SCG, Sat 8 Sep 4:20pm @sydneyswans #AFLSwansGiants

[Foreign Legion]

In retrospect I think the trades for Tippett and Franklin have been a major recruiting mistake. Tippett was a flop and unfortunately we are too predictable and one dimensional with Franklin. I think we would be a better side with Mitchell rather than Franklin. We simply lost too much middle ranking depth to have Tippett and Franklin.

Ok then if we can reverse time 4-5 years we are set...bloody stupid comment when we won 15 in a row last year.

[crackedactor]

Umpires allowing that Greene foot fend off speaks volumes about the quality of umpiring these days. It's @@@@!

According to the AFL rules it's allowed when playing the Sydney Swans. Just like sliding into opponents legs like in the 2016 GF.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[U.S. Swan]

Somebody needs to grab Toby Greene’s leg and drive it into the turf full force the next time he goes Karate Kid… the dude should be suspended 2 games every time he does it.

[Foreign Legion]

How the #### is it right for someone to stick his foot out (complete with stops no less) to stop an opponent during a marking contest?!

I’d love to see an opponent put their foot out in the same marking contest and make contact with a Toby Greene’s exposed areas.

Greene has form on and off the field - hope he gets cleaned up soon.

[stevoswan]

It just shows you where the umpires heads are at when they're umpiring the Swans.....to even let Green get away with it.

[crackedactor]

Ok then if we can reverse time 4-5 years we are set...bloody stupid comment when we won 15 in a row last year.

Great forward coaching stevie Johnson. What a coach you are!!!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Melbourne_Blood]

Anyone else watching fox? Notice hanners crying when coming off ? That tells me he’s gone , getting smashed in an elimination doesn’t normally get the tears going , looks like a man who knows he’s played his last game for the swans .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Foreign Legion]

Sinclair worn out at the end of a bloody long year - he deserves kudos for his effort. Cameron in the 2's was B.O.G. again - he may be a permanent fixture next year. Melican back will be handy. Reid/Rohan I think are almost finished due to injury.

[dejavoodoo44]

Thank you Luke.....how Green gets away with repeatedly kicking people when going for marks is beyond me.

Yes, I recall that he was suspended for that last year, but apparently, it's okay today.

[Foreign Legion]

Great forward coaching stevie Johnson. What a coach you are!!!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I did not mention Johnson in my comment?

[Merdo5555]

Ok then if we can reverse time 4-5 years we are set...bloody stupid comment when we won 15 in a row last year.

But we didnt win the premiership and in the end thats all that matters and when will we win the next one?

[Melbourne_Blood]

Sinclair worn out at the end of a bloody long year - he deserves kudos for his effort. Cameron in the 2's was B.O.G. again - he may be a permanent fixture next year. Melican back will be handy. Reid/Rohan I think are almost finished due to injury.

Would be good to see Sinclair played deep forward next year , good mark good kick and a foil for bud. How we fit both Naismith and Cameron I don’t know but maybe Cameron offers more ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[dejavoodoo44]

Somebody needs to grab Toby Greene’s leg and drive it into the turf full force the next time he goes Karate Kid… the dude should be suspended 2 games every time he does it.

Toby Greene: the man who was born to be punched.

[Foreign Legion]

But we didnt win the premiership and in the end thats all that matters and when will we win the next one?

Ok. I am not sure I follow your logic. If we don't win the flag our recruiting 5 years ago is flawed so lets get back a slow midfielder? Is that it?

[U.S. Swan]

Sinclair was the Swan's player of the year, imo. NOBODY expected him to fill in for Naismith the way he did. Top marks!