I agree re Ronkes form, however most of those you mentioned don’t play as small forwards necessarily , Heeney , Parker and JPK play medium -tall if anything. McVeigh more of a slow flanker. None of those offer the pace or pressure we need to support a 3 pronged tall forward line . So hopefully Ronke gets back in sooner rather than later.
Team Selection R1 v Bulldogs
Collapse
X
-
-
I take your point. Who was performing the role prior to Ronke? Could we potentially look at one of our young recruits such as McInerney or Stoddart filling this role?I agree re Ronkes form, however most of those you mentioned don’t play as small forwards necessarily , Heeney , Parker and JPK play medium -tall if anything. McVeigh more of a slow flanker. None of those offer the pace or pressure we need to support a 3 pronged tall forward line . So hopefully Ronke gets back in sooner rather than later.Comment
-
Comment
-
Umpires: Shaun Ryan (25), Robert O'Gorman (10), Nick Brown (13)Comment
-
If the backline lines up as listed..... Mills Grundy Melican, McVeigh ,Rampe, Lloyd ....Not one quick player among them....
It worries me, such a slow, tall team we've picked.
The Dogs will try to exploit this with run and carry and lots of pressure.Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MTComment
-
If our midfield get the ball at the centre clearance and kick it fast into forward line 6 vs 6 we will very very very hard to beat
Massive advantage our forward line
Great challenge for our midfield to dominate"be tough, only when it gets tough"

Comment
-
Rampe is quick , but the others are all slow or slowish yes .
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
As people have mentioned above, I'm surprised that we have gone so tall. Up front, it seems that Buddy, Reid, Sinclair and Blakey, could be one tall marking target too many. And while it's nice to see Buddy in the squad, I wonder if he's something of a provisional selection. That is, he doesn't quite get up, then Ronke comes in and adds a bit more crumbing skills. If he does play, then maybe Blakey has to wait a little bit longer for his debut; despite his impressive preseason form.
Also surprised that Melican is in the backline, as I think that O'Riordan has had better recent form and provides more escape velocity. Possibly another late change?Comment
-
"Zippy" is not a term I'd associate with Lloyd, or Rampe for that matter.
Rampe has elite endurance. Neither has explosive pace.
We've gone in to this match with Grundy, Melican, Rampe, and potentially Aliir, as tall options in defence..
Against a relatively small Dogs forward line.
The only way this situation works for us is if the Dogs just bomb it into their forwards all night...Highly unlikely.Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MTComment

Comment