Changes for Round 15 against Melbourne in Cairns

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MattW
    Veterans List
    • May 2011
    • 4220

    Team List Changes for Round 15 against Melbourne in Cairns

    OUT: Bell, Melican, Sinclair
    IN: Stephens, Brand, McLean

    Rest had, let's get games into Dylan. Bell looked off it today.

    Lewis had the turning circle of an ocean liner today. Brand's height will be useful.

    Callum is giving us nothing at ground level. Let's lean into Aliir in the ruck, McCartin back, McLean to play full forward, releasing Hayward to play up the ground more and Reid to relieve Aliir.
  • Aaron
    Regular in the Side
    • Jan 2009
    • 805

    #2
    I think Melican performed well and deserves to keep his position. He may be a little slow in turning ( as we saw Dixon played his tricks on him), his disposal efficiency was 100% and scored 12.4 AFL Player rating points, 7th highest on the field today and was the 3rd highest of the Swans(just behind Dawson and McCartin). I think the bottom five today were Hayward, Bell, McInerney, Florent and to a lesser extent Clark.

    Comment

    • Markwebbos
      Veterans List
      • Jul 2016
      • 7186

      #3
      Originally posted by MattW
      OUT: Bell, Melican, Sinclair
      IN: Stephens, Brand, McLean

      Rest had, let's get games into Dylan. Bell looked off it today.

      Lewis had the turning circle of an ocean liner today. Brand's height will be useful.

      Callum is giving us nothing at ground level. Let's lean into Aliir in the ruck, McCartin back, McLean to play full forward, releasing Hayward to play up the ground more and Reid to relieve Aliir.
      Don't mind those changes. Although I'm still very keen to see Gould in. Horse was asked about his non-selection during his post-match presser and said he was close and we might see him play this year.

      Comment

      • MattW
        Veterans List
        • May 2011
        • 4220

        #4
        Originally posted by Markwebbos
        Don't mind those changes. Although I'm still very keen to see Gould in. Horse was asked about his non-selection during his post-match presser and said he was close and we might see him play this year.
        He seemed a bit guarded to me. Underwhelmed even.

        Comment

        • The Big Cat
          On the veteran's list
          • Apr 2006
          • 2356

          #5
          Originally posted by MattW
          He seemed a bit guarded to me. Underwhelmed even.
          I think he was making the point that he has to be taught how to play AFL footy. Gould played a few senior games last year, but the SANFL remains a big step down from the AFL.
          Those who have the greatest power to hurt us are those we love.

          Comment

          • Captain
            Captain of the Side
            • Feb 2004
            • 3602

            #6
            In: Stephens, Gould
            Out: Clarke, Bell

            Comment

            • Mountain Man
              Regular in the Side
              • Feb 2008
              • 908

              #7
              I have been wondering where the right place is to play Gould - replaces Bell as pressure forward/mid?

              Gould might get a game soon, and the Melbourne forward are not as terrifying as recent weeks (IMHO), but not sure what rearrangement happens to bring him in as a defender.

              Comment

              • barracuda
                Regular in the Side
                • Jun 2016
                • 551

                #8
                Originally posted by Mountain Man
                I have been wondering where the right place is to play Gould - replaces Bell as pressure forward/mid?

                Gould might get a game soon, and the Melbourne forward are not as terrifying as recent weeks (IMHO), but not sure what rearrangement happens to bring him in as a defender.
                Given he only ever plays in the backline during trial games, that is a pretty risky move for his first game!

                Comment

                • Ludwig
                  Veterans List
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 9359

                  #9
                  OUT: Bell, Clarke, Sinclair
                  IN: Amartey, Gould, Ling

                  Mostly based on players I would like to see in the side. I don't have strong feelings about selection going into this part of the season, except that I would like to see players who we have not already decided to delist get a look in before the season runs out.

                  Comment

                  • troyjones2525
                    Swans Fanatic!
                    • Mar 2008
                    • 2908

                    #10
                    Originally posted by barracuda
                    Given he only ever plays in the backline during trial games, that is a pretty risky move for his first game!
                    Barra you seem to have seen a lot of the trial games and have a bit of inside info. Has Gould been that bad? You haven't seemed to positive about him in a lot of your reports so I'm interested to hear how he's tracking.

                    He played well in the seniors in the SANFL last year and I know it's a level down, but it's still a strong league! Are they trying to turn him into something he's not, a lock down defender? I wanted us to draft him because I liked his run and kicking out of defence and I'm hoping Horse and Co. aren't stifling that because he can't shut down a player as well as they'd like!

                    I get that defender's need to be able to defend but there is also a case to have a strong attacking defender in your side as pretty much all the best sides have them!

                    Sent from my SM-G977B using Tapatalk

                    Comment

                    • barracuda
                      Regular in the Side
                      • Jun 2016
                      • 551

                      #11
                      Originally posted by troyjones2525
                      Barra you seem to have seen a lot of the trial games and have a bit of inside info. Has Gould been that bad? You haven't seemed to positive about him in a lot of your reports so I'm interested to hear how he's tracking.

                      He played well in the seniors in the SANFL last year and I know it's a level down, but it's still a strong league! Are they trying to turn him into something he's not, a lock down defender? I wanted us to draft him because I liked his run and kicking out of defence and I'm hoping Horse and Co. aren't stifling that because he can't shut down a player as well as they'd like!

                      I get that defender's need to be able to defend but there is also a case to have a strong attacking defender in your side as pretty much all the best sides have them!

                      Sent from my SM-G977B using Tapatalk
                      I think he has been losing one on one contests too much. But given where the season is at they should give him a taste

                      Comment

                      • Blood Fever
                        Veterans List
                        • Apr 2007
                        • 4050

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Mountain Man
                        I have been wondering where the right place is to play Gould - replaces Bell as pressure forward/mid?

                        Gould might get a game soon, and the Melbourne forward are not as terrifying as recent weeks (IMHO), but not sure what rearrangement happens to bring him in as a defender.
                        Think we're guessing a fair bit for the next few weeks. With 5 day turnaround, I reckon there will be a fair bit of "managing " going on.

                        Comment

                        • Mark26
                          Senior Player
                          • Jan 2017
                          • 1535

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Ludwig
                          OUT: Bell, Clarke, Sinclair
                          IN: Amartey, Gould, Ling

                          Mostly based on players I would like to see in the side. I don't have strong feelings about selection going into this part of the season, except that I would like to see players who we have not already decided to delist get a look in before the season runs out.
                          +1

                          Comment

                          • Ralph Dawg
                            Senior Player
                            • Apr 2018
                            • 1729

                            #14
                            McInerney needs to improve his disposal. He can run but so could Jack Hiscox. He's as bad as Clarke but at least Clarke has a physical presence.

                            Thurlow has gone missing again. I doubt he can play consistent footy, which is a shame because he can look good when playing well.

                            Florent, Rowbottom and Blakey were all MIA yesterday. It's been a while since Florent has had a game worth talking about. At least Blakey has improved since his dropping and Rowbottom has been great all year.

                            Ins Stephens McLean Florent
                            Out McInerney Thurlow Gould (Cunningham and Dawson play in midfield / forward)

                            Comment

                            • AB Swannie
                              Senior Player
                              • Mar 2017
                              • 1579

                              #15
                              I'd like to see Gould play as well just out of curiosity. I wonder if he has been a bit of a victim of there being no real reserves games. Perhaps 12 v 12 and 15 v 15 games mean that there is a lot more space for forwards and suits quicker more nimble players.

                              Comment

                              Working...