Best 22 2021

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheBloods
    Suspended by the MRP
    • Feb 2020
    • 2047

    Originally posted by Ruck'n'Roll
    Dead right 'Bloods - same thing happened last year, the team was far better performed with Kennedy's presence than without (see last years equivalent of this thread).
    It's not just his disposal count, his presence improves the aggregate performance of the midfielders

    JPK may only have a couple of years left, I have no idea how his body and mind are holding up - but older players careers usually ended by a diminution of speed and/or frequent soft tissue injuries, and neither apply to JPK. So he's our best option as a "mid field bull" - and I am likewise unsure where the next one is coming from.
    Hewett seemed to possibly be on the right trajectory (moving beyond tagging) before injury, while Mills and Heeney are apparently needed elsewhere. Not to worry though, even if these options don't pan out such such kids seem to be drafted ready-to-play so we could get one in the next draft or two and they'd still be ready for our 2023 grand final team.

    Pet Peeve of the week - Why do we call a player a "Mid field bull"? What was wrong with the term "ruck rover"?
    Indeed. It makes me nervous that we will run Parker into the ground once JPK retires. We must find another midfield superstar ready to play and dominate by round 1 of our first year without JPK. While Hewett is a good player, I doubt he is that superstar.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Originally posted by Mountain Man
    I still have hopes for Warner - 19 years old, 2 games last year, 1.81cm and 80 kg.

    This time last year the goss was about Longmire having a word to him about his aggression. I noticed him on Wednesday training, and he retains that feel.
    Looked terrible at the highest level in his few appearances last year.

    Comment

    • Ruck'n'Roll
      Ego alta, ergo ictus
      • Nov 2003
      • 3990

      Warner

      Originally posted by Mountain Man
      I still have hopes for Warner - 19 years old, 2 games last year, 1.81cm and 80 kg.
      This time last year the goss was about Longmire having a word to him about his aggression. I noticed him on Wednesday training, and he retains that feel.
      Was the word in question "increase" or "control" your aggression?
      I too have hopes for the lad - not everyone in the midfield can or needs to be an A grader. Much better to have a posse of 8 players capable of running though the midfield, than having just 4 attending 90% of the centre bounces, as Horse has tended to allow happen.

      Back to Warner, wasn't there some comments after his first two games about him needing to develop his tank?
      Last preseason and through to his debut, some RWOers were pumping up the kid on these boards, then after his second quietish game in the firsts, there was an unseemly hush as some jumped ship.
      I know it's a feature of a difficult and for many, extremely disappointing, year - but still it can be a bit OTT sometimes. I prefer to do my frenzied barracking at the game, it's apparently good for the blood pressure overall.


      Originally posted by TheBloods
      Looked terrible at the highest level in his few appearances last year.
      Agreed, but then McInerney and Naismith both had awfully bad first games.
      Last edited by Ruck'n'Roll; 11 January 2021, 10:58 AM.

      Comment

      • The Runner
        Regular in the Side
        • May 2017
        • 718

        Originally posted by TheBloods
        Indeed. It makes me nervous that we will run Parker into the ground once JPK retires. We must find another midfield superstar ready to play and dominate by round 1 of our first year without JPK. While Hewett is a good player, I doubt he is that superstar.

        - - - Updated - - -



        Looked terrible at the highest level in his few appearances last year.
        Warner looked ok and like he has a future. Strong body, does all the 1% they make a midfield great. Kind of player a coach loves.
        He's style of play means it's year 3-4 that we'll see him start to really stand out. Similar to Hewett.

        Comment

        • Markwebbos
          Veterans List
          • Jul 2016
          • 7186

          Originally posted by Ruck'n'Roll
          Wouldn't that make him more than 3½ metres tall?.
          Mountain Man listed him as 1.81cm which I could see being an issue.

          Comment

          • Meg
            Go Swannies!
            Site Admin
            • Aug 2011
            • 4828

            Originally posted by Markwebbos
            Mountain Man listed him as 1.81cm which I could see being an issue.
            Nah, competitive advantage, can scurry through the legs of opposing players and very hard to tackle!

            Comment

            • Mountain Man
              Regular in the Side
              • Feb 2008
              • 910

              Thank you Meg - I might try to make an error in future; instead of just making one

              Comment

              • liz
                Veteran
                Site Admin
                • Jan 2003
                • 16787

                Originally posted by Meg
                Nah, competitive advantage, can scurry through the legs of opposing players and very hard to tackle!
                May not be much of a ball carrier though. Or tackler. Kicking might lack penetration. And not ideal for manning the mark.

                Comment

                • O'Reilly Boy
                  Warming the Bench
                  • Feb 2014
                  • 474

                  Originally posted by Meg
                  Nah, competitive advantage, can scurry through the legs of opposing players and very hard to tackle!
                  Worked for Ben McG

                  Comment

                  • Ralph Dawg
                    Senior Player
                    • Apr 2018
                    • 1729

                    I'm hoping that the best 22 at the end of the year looks a bit different to the best 22 at the start.

                    We have a few players who will be best 22 R1 who either have a low ceiling that they have reached (or approaching) or are on a decline.

                    If players like JMac, Gould, Ling, McLean and to a lesser extent, Gulden, Campbell and McDonald have not surpassed by season's end, then we won't be threatening anytime soon.

                    Comment

                    • Ruck'n'Roll
                      Ego alta, ergo ictus
                      • Nov 2003
                      • 3990

                      Feel like offering your low-ceiling list for discussion?

                      Comment

                      • Ralph Dawg
                        Senior Player
                        • Apr 2018
                        • 1729

                        Originally posted by Ruck'n'Roll
                        Feel like offering your low-ceiling list for discussion?
                        Low ceiling is a bit harsh. I should've expressed it in terms of potential to improve. For the team to improve, we need improvement in the individual positions within the team. This occurs either by the incumbents improving or those on the fringe improving such that they become the better players.

                        Hope that Gould can move past Melican. He's alot more talented and has a higher ceiling.

                        I like Clarke, an honest hard worker. But if he never plays another game because JMac, Gulden and Campbell move ahead convincingly, it means our team is improving.

                        Hayward has stagnated the last 2 seasons and does not threaten enough. Eventually McDonald will play KPF for us but it would be great if he is good enough to play Hayward's medium role initially.
                        McLean for Reid / Sinclair.

                        Cunningham is a great player but if Ling could play well enough to beat him for the small lockdown / running defender, that would be massive for us. I think Ling had massive potential that had been stymied by injury.

                        Comment

                        • Captain
                          Captain of the Side
                          • Feb 2004
                          • 3602

                          Originally posted by Ralph Dawg
                          Cunningham is a great player but if Ling could play well enough to beat him for the small lockdown / running defender, that would be massive for us. I think Ling had massive potential that had been stymied by injury.
                          Cunningham is miles ahead of Ling at the moment. Can't see this changing for a long time (if ever).

                          Comment

                          • Ruck'n'Roll
                            Ego alta, ergo ictus
                            • Nov 2003
                            • 3990

                            Agree Dawg, Melican isn't the most talented player, but he's extremely solid unit, and as such I think our best option against monster forwards.
                            No idea about Gould, yet to see him play.
                            I'm not sure about Hayward stagnating, he played some excellent games last year - down back, and then as a defensive forward
                            You didn't mention him, but Florent likewise, I was worried about him, but when I looked a bit harder I realised he was playing a defensive role, and doing it very well.

                            Comment

                            • Ralph Dawg
                              Senior Player
                              • Apr 2018
                              • 1729

                              Originally posted by Captain
                              Cunningham is miles ahead of Ling at the moment. Can't see this changing for a long time (if ever).
                              Agree with this for R1. But no doubt Ling has talent and even if he is pushing Harry by season's end, that would be a good result moving forward.

                              Comment

                              • Ralph Dawg
                                Senior Player
                                • Apr 2018
                                • 1729

                                Originally posted by Ruck'n'Roll
                                Agree Dawg, Melican isn't the most talented player, but he's extremely solid unit, and as such I think our best option against monster forwards.
                                No idea about Gould, yet to see him play.
                                I'm not sure about Hayward stagnating, he played some excellent games last year - down back, and then as a defensive forward
                                You didn't mention him, but Florent likewise, I was worried about him, but when I looked a bit harder I realised he was playing a defensive role, and doing it very well.
                                Hayward looked ok playing back and stopped Haynes from generating rebound in the GWS game. However we need him presenting as a viable goal kicking option, not just doing defensive roles.

                                Don't really need him in defence - only played there because of our injuries last season and he was out of form.

                                Too short to he KPF.

                                Lacks leg speed to be small forward.

                                Lacks tank to play in midfield.

                                Only viable position is medium forward / 3rd tall. IMO, McDonald will prove to be a better option very soon.

                                Comment

                                Working...