Can you change that 22? Assuming RB is good to go again, it's tough to drop one for anyone except Bud (if fit)
Round 2 v Adelaide at the SCG
Collapse
X
-
-
As much as McLean did a good job yesterday, if Bud is ready to go it is a straight swap. If Rowbottom is deemed unfit, I'd get Stephens into the side. Not a like for like but just get the best talent into the team.Comment
-
Comment
-
Doesn't sound to me like Buddy has had sufficient build up the be ready next week. It wouldn't worry me if he's held out for another week or two.
Likewise I guess the reference to Rowbottom being out would be if his knee doesn't come up too well. He'd be a huge loss but I'd rather we rest him if injured as it's a long season, he's young, and he's integral to our success.Comment
-
That to me appears to be the most reasonable change to make per say. As Captain says though, hope we don't seek to become too Buddy centric, especially in early weeks where he will still be building up fitness."You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
-
An idea on how to proceed .. The Blood’s views on Rowbottom are shared by no one. Nevertheless they are allowed to have that opinion. It doesnt have to make sense to us. TB if you must - keep on taking your shots at him if you think he is that much of a problem. You are right that hes not the only target of your ire. Let us do our best to ignore the opinions on RB that we can not change and respond to your other opinions which at least contribute to the discussions.
Sound good everyone ??Comment
-
Buddy played a half today.. get him in the side next week. He'll be better for the hit out before we play Richmond in Round 3 in a top of the table clashComment
-
An idea on how to proceed .. The Blood’s views on Rowbottom are shared by no one. Nevertheless they are allowed to have that opinion. It doesnt have to make sense to us. TB if you must - keep on taking your shots at him if you think he is that much of a problem. You are right that hes not the only target of your ire. Let us do our best to ignore the opinions on RB that we can not change and respond to your other opinions which at least contribute to the discussions.
Sound good everyone ??
I strongly disagree with TheBloods' player assessments, but defend his right to express his opinion.
I think it's been very civil of us on RWO to have dealt with this without the admonition of the moderators.Comment
-
I dont disagree with all of them. Like his excitement in Warner. I agree that he is a talent. High praise of Cal Mills i agree with too. Just let the RB criticism be i sayComment
-
I should have said some of his player assessments. I don't mind a little banter, even a lot of banter, as long as we keep it civilised. We just need to keep the conversation from escalating to ad hominem attacks.Comment
-
Comment
-
The one clear change that I would make is Franklin for McLean.
Franklin is an upgrade to McLean and will improve the team.
Sam Reid can be the utility that gives you some value forward, ruck or defence.
I would like to get Stephen’s and McInerney back into the team in the short term. The team will really be elite at outside run and distribution with these guys in the team.Comment
Comment