Worried after today that Braeden Campbell may get this weeks nomination and send us into another round of anti Northern Academy hysteria
Academy uproar rears again
Collapse
X
-
That lad is a star. Who cares what people say. Fantastic composure, positioning, reading the play and outstanding kick.Comment
-
Comment
-
I heard a commentator say Warner and McDonald went to the same high school, though a year apart.Comment
-
AFL Draft, Pick 4: Logan McDonald says the following: "McDonald said he can’t wait to head to Sydney where he will join his WA mate Chad Warner.""Unbelievable!" -- Nick Davis leaves his mark on the 2005 semi finalComment
-
Spot on. I was watching on draft night and could not believe he got through that far. Was no other club watching what he was doing for the last 10 years? Every level he was promoted to, he rose to. He should have been a top 10 and I am stunned that he fell that deep. Other clubs can whinge about our Academy all they want (and I don't think they are any more to be fair, I think it's confected Victorian News Corp media fodder) but them letting him fall that deep in the draft is on them, not us.I have some sneaky sympathy about access to the top end talent - ie I'm not sure (purely on the basis of draft equity, ignoring the fact the competition is far from a level playing field in other aspects) we should have been able to draft both Campbell and McDonald. But the fact we got Gulden at 32, and thus kept next year's draft currency intact, is purely down to the other clubs. I was staggered he lasted to 32.
Predictably, one of the first questions Horse was asked in his post-game interview was about the benefits the club has reaped from the academy system. His immediate answer was (paraphrased) " I should think so. It costs us a lot."
I'm also surprised by how little the football commentators seem to understand about how the academies are set up. Dermot commented during the broadcast that it was amazing that a player could be identified at age 10 as a potentially elite footy player. But of course that's not how it works. One hundred or so boys join the academy each year. Around 30 or so (maybe fewer this year) last beyond age 15. Of those, half a dozen might make it as far as the U18 Allies team in the National Championships. And one or two might then make it onto an AFL list. (More probably should, than have, but hopefully that will gradually change.)
Dermot has worked with the Giants so I am surprised he, of all commentators, isn't more knowledgeable.Today's a draft of your epitaphComment
-
If McDonald or Chad wins next week it’s going to bring all hellfire down on us and I’ll love it.
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment
-
That would be amazing haha!
Fully deserved for young Campbell - I thought he was excellent on the weekend, and showed a great glimpse of his huge upside."You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
But won’t Wicks be nominated this week? He didn’t play 10 last year did he? That would be 3 academy products in a row Wow Wee"I'll acknowledge there are more talented teams in the competition but I won't acknowledge that there is a better team in the competition" Paul Roos March 2005Comment

Comment