Bob Skilton Medal

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheBloods
    Suspended by the MRP
    • Feb 2020
    • 2047

    #31
    Florent the most over rated player on our list

    Comment

    • longmile
      Crumber
      • Apr 2011
      • 3362

      #32
      Originally posted by TheBloods
      Florent the most over rated player on our list
      Agreed

      Rough on Hewett, Cunningham, Rampe, McCartin and Kennedy

      Comment

      • Ludwig
        Veterans List
        • Apr 2007
        • 9359

        #33
        Originally posted by TheBloods
        Florent the most over rated player on our list
        I guess you mean Florent is the most overrated by the coaches.

        Alternatively, he's the most underrated by RWO. But he has plenty of competition there.

        Comment

        • longmile
          Crumber
          • Apr 2011
          • 3362

          #34
          Originally posted by Ludwig
          I guess you mean Florent is the most overrated by the coaches.

          Alternatively, he's the most underrated by RWO. But he has plenty of competition there.
          Look he's not bad. But I disagree. Has good games but is so inconsistent. Whilst his upside is clearly his workrate, his disposal is poor and he often goes missing or makes poor decisions or inside 50s. I think he is fairly rated on here, we just want more out of him.

          Comment

          • TheBloods
            Suspended by the MRP
            • Feb 2020
            • 2047

            #35
            Originally posted by Ludwig
            I guess you mean Florent is the most overrated by the coaches.

            Alternatively, he's the most underrated by RWO. But he has plenty of competition there.
            Yes by the coaches. No F ing way was he better than Harry Joey or MCCartin or even Hewett ! Just BS

            Comment

            • Bexl
              Regular in the Side
              • Jan 2003
              • 817

              #36
              Well done to Gulden winning AFLPA best first year player award.

              Comment

              • i'm-uninformed2
                Reefer Madness
                • Oct 2003
                • 4653

                #37
                My issue with Florent is not what he is, but what he could be and isn’t.
                'Delicious' is a fun word to say

                Comment

                • giant
                  Veterans List
                  • Mar 2005
                  • 4731

                  #38
                  Originally posted by Bexl
                  I find it a bit concerning the first and third in The Best and Fairest well clearly deserved are not currently signed to the club
                  I suspect that makes a lot of us.

                  Congrats to Lukey, fantastic player and clubman, very richly deserved in a difficult year. His acceptance speech didn't sound like a bloke heading anywhere but back to the SCG next year - let's hope that's how it works out!

                  Comment

                  • TheBloods
                    Suspended by the MRP
                    • Feb 2020
                    • 2047

                    #39
                    Originally posted by i'm-uninformed2
                    My issue with Florent is not what he is, but what he could be and isn’t.
                    My issue with him is what he is , a garbage user of the ball and dumb as rocks ! Lucky he is quick or he would be a total liability

                    Comment

                    • dejavoodoo44
                      Veterans List
                      • Apr 2015
                      • 8494

                      #40
                      Originally posted by Ludwig
                      The big surprise for me in was Florent getting in the top 10.

                      Congrats to Colin for winning best clubman.
                      The fact that he played every game would have boosted his tally. And there were a few good games amongst them. Parker, Dawson and Papley were the other three who played every game.

                      - - - Updated - - -

                      Originally posted by goswannies
                      I was saying that to goswannette as we watched. But then I thought back to Tom Mitchell telling AnnieH at the B&F the year that he left that he was going nowhere. I guess (devil’s advocate) what might we expect them to say during their speeches? They have both said they want to stay at various times, but wanting to and getting the deals done are two different things.
                      Perhaps he was a little bit scared of Annie?

                      Comment

                      • dejavoodoo44
                        Veterans List
                        • Apr 2015
                        • 8494

                        #41
                        Originally posted by liz
                        Neither of them sounded like they want to go elsewhere...

                        The top 10, for anyone who missed it:

                        Parker
                        Lloyd
                        Dawson
                        Papley
                        Mills
                        Hickey
                        Heeney
                        McInerney
                        Florent
                        Franklin

                        It would be good if they published the full scores (and places beyond 10). As someone commented earlier in the week, there were probably players filling the 11-15 spots who wouldn't have been out of place in the top 10.
                        I think we were all pretty successful in our predictions. Not close enough to claim amazing psychic powers, but with a degree of accuracy that demonstrates we've been paying attention.

                        Comment

                        • NeonBible
                          Warming the Bench
                          • Mar 2021
                          • 280

                          #42
                          Originally posted by TheBloods
                          My issue with him is what he is , a garbage user of the ball and dumb as rocks ! Lucky he is quick or he would be a total liability
                          TB, this is where you get yourself into trouble! We have been over this!! It is not the message but in the delivery!

                          I believe many would agree with you that Florent's ball use and decision making can be frustrating, and a major weakness of his that he needs to improve on.. but "garbage" and "dumb as rocks" are inflammatory and quite denigrating.. it is jarring to hear such terms on an online forum meant for discussing footy...

                          I believe you mean well but from now on.. for your sake more than anyone else's just to stop rubbing people the wrong way.. re-read your comments before you post, and think.. is there a more gentle way I can put this? I think we would all appreciate it and enjoy your contributions a lot more

                          Comment

                          • NeonBible
                            Warming the Bench
                            • Mar 2021
                            • 280

                            #43
                            Congratulations to captain Luke!! I think it was last week i said that watching him this year i was starting to get the same feeling i got watching Paul Kelly.. who morphed into a wonderful leader and a brilliant player before our eyes! Parks is now one Skilton Medal away from Kelly!! And he is just 28! Would not count him winning another at least in his career!

                            Fantastic to also see so many others recognised - Lloyd & Dawson for magnificent consistent seasons.. i know Dawson played up the ground later in the season, but i couldn't help but notice both our half backs polled so well in the eyes of the coaches.. very indicative of how highly they rate our rebounding drive from defence!

                            Well deserved awards for Juzzy, Colin and young Errol (who won double tonight being recognised by the AFLPA!)

                            What a fantastic showing for our boys this year!! To cap off a fantastic season!

                            Comment

                            • dejavoodoo44
                              Veterans List
                              • Apr 2015
                              • 8494

                              #44
                              Originally posted by Bexl
                              Well done to Gulden winning AFLPA best first year player award.
                              And the voting was pretty comprehensive.

                              Errol Gulden (299)
                              Nikolas Cox (139)
                              Riley Thilthorpe (56)
                              Tom Powell (27)
                              Tom Highmore (26)

                              Cue another dose of outrage, about us getting him as an academy selection at pick 32.

                              Comment

                              • MattW
                                Veterans List
                                • May 2011
                                • 4195

                                #45
                                Originally posted by dejavoodoo44
                                And the voting was pretty comprehensive.

                                Errol Gulden (299)
                                Nikolas Cox (139)
                                Riley Thilthorpe (56)
                                Tom Powell (27)
                                Tom Highmore (26)

                                Cue another dose of outrage, about us getting him as an academy selection at pick 32.
                                Whatevs. The other teams had their chance.

                                Comment

                                Working...