Round 11 v Richmond Tigers @ SCG
Collapse
X
-
I read them and came to the same conclusion....and I'm still hearing whinging. How mature is it to be always complaining about others demeanour ...and judging them on it? Move on and let the debate take it's natural course. It's a forum.....for everyone.Comment
-
Different players R&R. I’m happy for both to play upfront, as they are both major goal threats but can see that occasionally Paps can play midfield due to his speed and ability to get a free for high tackle. Your point otherwise is a good one- but if we need additional help at centre bounces etc I’d rather play Paps there. Just my opinion!
Furthermore, Heeney is a great mark and usually a more reliable kick for goal.Comment
-
Brian Taylor has the maturity of a 15 year old schoolboy. Cannot for the life of me see how Channel 7 sees him as an asset. If I'm watching a game and he's commentating, I turn the volume down.It's also a shame that Channel 7 had Brian Taylor, relentlessly gibbering on about how it should've been 50. Even after Daisy Pearce explained to him, that no, fifties are usually paid for time wasting and you can't waste time after the siren, he still made his ill informed case. It reminded me of the women of Australia trying to get Morrison to listen. And he was like that for most of the game. He generally piped up about controversial decisions or the high free kick count, when we got a free, but was remarkably silent, when a soft or non-existent free was paid to Richmond. Utterly insufferable.Comment
-
Brian Taylor started his career at Richmond, though he's better known for his time at Collingwood. It certainly sounded like he was barracking for them.
When his nephew received a free kick late in the game, in Richmond's defence, for a head high tackle we got an "eek - lots of free kicks", despite it being an obvious and clear cut free. Club ties seem stronger to him than family ones - not that either should affect how he calls a game.Comment
-
Didn't we deny him access to our rooms a few years ago when he wanted to do one of his riveting and insightful Roaming Brian segments? He spat the dummy over that and doesn't seem to have liked us since. Speaking for myself, the feeling's mutual. He never grew up and is an embarrassment.Brian Taylor started his career at Richmond, though he's better known for his time at Collingwood. It certainly sounded like he was barracking for them.
When his nephew received a free kick late in the game, in Richmond's defence, for a head high tackle we got an "eek - lots of free kicks", despite it being an obvious and clear cut free. Club ties seem stronger to him than family ones - not that either should affect how he calls a game.Comment
-
He's just a part of the football industry. They are so focussed on maintaining their click count that they focus on writing/commentating in an ingratiating manner on any story/club that results in the greatest number of clicks. Parochialism is also an important part of that, look how far it took the former PM. I'm not sure such self editing is even conscious now, it's just such an ingrained patter of behaviour/mode of thinking. The corollary is that actual journalism/research is a non payer, and is therefore becoming extinct.Brian Taylor started his career at Richmond, though he's better known for his time at Collingwood. It certainly sounded like he was barracking for them.
When his nephew received a free kick late in the game, in Richmond's defence, for a head high tackle we got an "eek - lots of free kicks", despite it being an obvious and clear cut free. Club ties seem stronger to him than family ones - not that either should affect how he calls a game.
I think there's also a possibility that the umpires are similarly affected by this zietgeist, which might explain why the Swans have been on the wrong side of the free kick count for decades.Comment
-
We’ve had a fair dig at Cotchin in defending Franklin tonightHe ate more cheese, than time allowedComment
-
I don't know why the preoccupation with the commentators. Makes no difference to the result. I just treat it as background noise. Imagine broadcasting a game without commentary. A radio broadcast without game callers would be a hoot.Comment
-
What would you rather hear, the game commentary or the loud music at the SCG? One could be the foreground noise and the other background noise.Comment
-
Comment


Comment