Rnd 9 - Pre Match List - vs Fremantle at SCG at 1:45 PM, Saturday 13 May 2023

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Roadrunner
    Senior Player
    • Jan 2018
    • 1480

    #16
    Originally posted by Captain
    Francis surely must go. Isn’t up to it.

    Stephens and Hickey in for Sheather and Francis. Gus Sheldrick as the sun.

    Cunningham butchers the ball but is important defensively so must stay.
    Francis, like any new player, needs a run of games to assess and get used to a new team. What’s the point of chopping and changing from week to week? This year we ain’t challenging, though of course we want to win every game. We have McLean who can play ok but we all know his limitations and he has been given a decent go- though hopefully can still improve.

    Like I said before, what was the point in trading him in if he’s playing VFL? He’s a very good mark, which is something we need. Let’s play him for a few games, same with Gus. And if Paddy needs to retire, who do you suggest could play there? The Pelican is coming back from another injury and it’s only a matter of a game or two (sadly) before he’s injured again. At this stage we have no one else I can think of.

    Comment

    • Captain
      Captain of the Side
      • Feb 2004
      • 3602

      #17
      Originally posted by Roadrunner
      Francis, like any new player, needs a run of games to assess and get used to a new team. What’s the point of chopping and changing from week to week? This year we ain’t challenging, though of course we want to win every game. We have McLean who can play ok but we all know his limitations and he has been given a decent go- though hopefully can still improve.

      Like I said before, what was the point in trading him in if he’s playing VFL? He’s a very good mark, which is something we need. Let’s play him for a few games, same with Gus. And if Paddy needs to retire, who do you suggest could play there? The Pelican is coming back from another injury and it’s only a matter of a game or two (sadly) before he’s injured again. At this stage we have no one else I can think of.
      I see it as not much different to us brining in Lewis Taylor, sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't.

      We have Hickey to come back and I would rather drop Francis than McLean. If McLean is given a good run as a pure forward with no ruck, I think he will perform well.

      Comment

      • waswan
        Senior Player
        • Oct 2015
        • 2047

        #18
        If Buddy is a given to play this year plus a resting ruckmen plus 2 high marking smalls in Heeney and Will, plus a developing young tall in Logan im not sure why Francis is in that fwd line.

        Our tall defensive stocks are decimated, if he plays back there he releases one of Ollie, Blakey or Campbell.

        That all seems very obvious to me.

        Comment

        • Kafka's Ghost
          Regular in the Side
          • Sep 2017
          • 903

          #19
          Originally posted by Captain
          I see it as not much different to us brining in Lewis Taylor, sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't.

          We have Hickey to come back and I would rather drop Francis than McLean. If McLean is given a good run as a pure forward with no ruck, I think he will perform well.
          McLean is a far better kick.


          Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

          Comment

          • Roadrunner
            Senior Player
            • Jan 2018
            • 1480

            #20
            Originally posted by Kafka's Ghost
            McLean is a far better kick.


            Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
            Ok- so are you saying that McLean should move to defence? I think we need a tall there in Ramps absence, so it could be him or Francis. If big Tom is ready to come in, Ladhams plays 2nd ruck and relieves McLean to go back. My preference is to persevere with Francis for a few games though.

            Comment

            • waswan
              Senior Player
              • Oct 2015
              • 2047

              #21
              Wow just read Robbo in The Tackle
              Heeney is 7.7 from 21 shots on Goal

              Comment

              • Kafka's Ghost
                Regular in the Side
                • Sep 2017
                • 903

                #22
                Originally posted by waswan
                Wow just read Robbo in The Tackle
                Heeney is 7.7 from 21 shots on Goal
                Even if he’d scored a few points with those other shots we’d be 5:3. Our goal kicking this season has been extraordinary…in the bad sense of the word.


                Gesendet von iPad mit Tapatalk

                Comment

                • Kafka's Ghost
                  Regular in the Side
                  • Sep 2017
                  • 903

                  #23
                  Originally posted by waswan
                  If Buddy is a given to play this year plus a resting ruckmen plus 2 high marking smalls in Heeney and Will, plus a developing young tall in Logan im not sure why Francis is in that fwd line.

                  Our tall defensive stocks are decimated, if he plays back there he releases one of Ollie, Blakey or Campbell.

                  That all seems very obvious to me.
                  Agree. He’s a good mark and reads the ball well, but is a lousy kick for goal. He needs to go back and free up Blakey for a bit more run out of the backline.


                  Gesendet von iPad mit Tapatalk

                  Comment

                  • Nico
                    Veterans List
                    • Jan 2003
                    • 11339

                    #24
                    Originally posted by liz
                    He did take the best two contested marks in our forward line yesterday. And the worse of the two missed conversions was still only the second worst miss of the afternoon (after Ladhams on half-time).
                    Missed by......that much, twice.
                    http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

                    Comment

                    • MarshallG
                      Warming the Bench
                      • Mar 2008
                      • 161

                      #25
                      Originally posted by waswan
                      Wow just read Robbo in The Tackle
                      Heeney is 7.7 from 21 shots on Goal
                      Champion Data had him winning 45% of contested ball last year This year, 12%.

                      Comment

                      • waswan
                        Senior Player
                        • Oct 2015
                        • 2047

                        #26
                        Originally posted by MarshallG
                        Champion Data had him winning 45% of contested ball last year This year, 12%.
                        Sheesh

                        Comment

                        • Dow
                          Regular in the Side
                          • Sep 2022
                          • 840

                          #27
                          I hope Heeney is injured ????, he’s no where near the player he was last year

                          Comment

                          • 707
                            Veterans List
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 6204

                            #28
                            Who knows what it is with Heeney but he's a shadow of last year :-(

                            Comment

                            • Roadrunner
                              Senior Player
                              • Jan 2018
                              • 1480

                              #29
                              Originally posted by 707
                              Who knows what it is with Heeney but he's a shadow of last year :-(
                              Horse is on record saying he plays with pain- he had a persistent ankle injury and this may still be troubling him, though he may be carrying something else as well. He may need an extended rest, unfortunately. Time to introduce HHK now- give him a few games and let’s see. Some players have a high tolerance for pain but we need to manage them for the longer run!

                              Comment

                              • ugg
                                Can you feel it?
                                Site Admin
                                • Jan 2003
                                • 15970

                                #30
                                Originally posted by waswan
                                Wow just read Robbo in The Tackle
                                Heeney is 7.7 from 21 shots on Goal


                                Full list of Swans (min 4 shots)
                                Format is goals.behind (no scores) - percentage%
                                • C.Mills 4.0 (0) - 100.0%
                                • L.McDonald 15.5 (1) - 71.43%
                                • H.McLean 3.2 (0) - 60.00%
                                • D.Stephens 3.1 (1) - 60.00%
                                • P.Ladhams 2.1 (1) - 50.00%
                                • R.Clarke 2.1 (1) - 50.00%
                                • O.Florent 2.0 (2) - 50.00%
                                • T.Papley 17.13 (6) - 47.22%
                                • J.Amartey 6.6 (1) - 46.15%
                                • W.Hayward 10.9 (4) - 43.48%
                                • J.McInerney 2.1 (2) - 40.00%
                                • L.Franklin 7.7 (4) - 38.89%
                                • I.Heeney 7.7 (7) - 33.33%
                                • J.Rowbottom 2.2 (2) - 33.33%
                                • L.Parker 2.2 (3) - 28.57%
                                • Ch.Warner 4.8 (3) - 26.67%
                                • E.Gulden 3.7 (3) - 23.08%
                                • A.Francis 0.3 (1) - 00.00%


                                Time to move Callum to FF.

                                Gulden is surprising given how good a kick he usually is. Last year he kicked 18.6 (3 no scores) at 66.67% so he's definitely a huge drop off. Both Heeney and Franklin (our top 2 goalkickers last year) were 56%, and Hayward who was 3rd had 53%.
                                Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                                Reserves WIKI -
                                Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                                Comment

                                Working...