Rnd 1 - Pre Match Thread - vs Collingwood at MCG, Friday 15 March 2024, 1:40 PM

[BRS328]

Mark
Technically you are correct, but McLean is playing as a forward at times when Grundy is on the ground. If you look at minutes played by each will support this.
There are some suggesting that Ladhams should be included as a replacement for Armartey. That would make us way too top heavy with Grundy and McLean in the side and will not happen.
Armartey does have good mobility and for that reason I think selectors will give him another chance if conditions are more favourable for forwards next Friday night.

[barry]

Collingwood play two rucks. Cameron and Cox. No reason why we wouldn't too.

[707]

Collingwood play two rucks. Cameron and Cox. No reason why we wouldn't too.

That's because they only have limited KPF I reckon. One ruck gives us an advantage at ground level.

Pies will be ferocious this week after their poor showing and subsequent widespread criticism last week

[Auntie.Gerald]

How crazy is it that Brody gets two games in a row to start the season vs his old team mates?? Love it !

Great to see Roberts looking more in the flow.............i dont mind Robbo getting some easy kicks from HBF to settle the nerves and or tag a small forward. Great opportunity while we have Parker, Mills, Patch out........to gain some best 22 experience and still play a required role. I still dont see an obvious spot for Robbo just yet but he aint going to play much mid field this season or next with the stack of inside mids we have and he aint fast enough for the wing. Glad he is making the most of the HBF role for now.

Unless injury is a concern I see our team pretty much as per last round, but I am super curious if the Pies will play short again up front? They seemed to lack height in their forwards and or just couldn keep it locked in their forward 50 like they are usually so good at????

Conversely GWS via Brown, Hogan and Daniels scoring 13 of their 18 goals was an amazing effort from that trio........serious weapons up front !

We had 10 players kick goals to make up only 12 goals.............talk about a hot hand 3 headed snake GWS attack !

The focus by the Pies this week to lock it in will be immense, especially with them fully aware of our love to slingshot a transition from our backline.

[neilfws]

Sheldrick won't be available, broken finger, 3-4 weeks.

Injury Update: Sheldrick sidelined

[Auntie.Gerald]

that fella cant take a trick !!!

any news on our young little no1 pick Konstanty ?

[liz]

Rotten luck for Sheldrick. Even though he didn't get picked for the first match, there was still an opening to fight his way in during the opening month while Parker and Adams were absent. Now that door has slammed shut.

[The Big Cat]

Collingwood play two rucks. Cameron and Cox. No reason why we wouldn't too.

But neither is any good.

[Dow]

But neither is any good.

Good enough to win a flag

[i'm-uninformed2]

But neither is any good.

Cameron’s developed into a solid contributor. Cox is an extremely poor man’s Mike Pyke who got kissed on the arse by a rainbow and has one good game a year.

[mcs]

Cox and Cameron show the ever ongoing conundrum of ruckman. Cox in particular is nothing but a toiler (He is well behind Pyke in the import ruck stakes haha) - but he and Cameron are an effective combination, and Cameron has turned into a pretty decent footballer overall. For every superstar ruckman that has won a premiership, you'll find a combo/ruckman that doesn't immediately jump out as much chop that was part of a successful team. And I think that is part of the mystery of the ruck - there are multiple ways for someone to be an 'effective' ruck in a footy team, even if standalone they aren't at first appearances a good individual ruckman.

[Goal Sneak]

Mills, Parker, Adams and Sheldrick all out yet I'm still confident we have the troops to get the job done, away, against the reigning premiers. Our mid depth is good but it's being heavily tested early.

[i'm-uninformed2]

Cox is played exclusively for structure, not output. He's the (really) tall target that allows the Pies to kick long when they need it, and give their smalls and mids a place to either swoop towards and crumb a goal, but more so to swarm and force a stoppage or corral the play inside the opposition's defensive 50, letting them set up behind the ball.

I mean, good on him, he's got a premiership medal. But he's like the Chief out of the scene in One Flew Over the Cuckoo Nest. "Tall man, stand here." (Main difference being Chief actually had scoring output).

[707]

Unchanged

[troyjones2525]

Happy with an unchanged side. Assume Wicks the sub again unless it's pissing rain.

Sent from my SM-F936B using Tapatalk