Round 10 vs Carlton at SCG, 7:40 PM, Friday 17 May 2024

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Maltopia
    Senior Player
    • Apr 2016
    • 1556

    Team List Round 10 vs Carlton at SCG, 7:40 PM, Friday 17 May 2024

    We are up against the Blues this Friday with four points and percentage lead over 2nd and 3rd on the ladder.

    I think we are on our way to another trade ban, COLA adjustment or Academy neutering, even though our back six and front six are not considered elite (undersized and inexperienced respectively).

    Carlton’s height is challenging, especially with TDK’s marking up front. He kept Lever out of the game vs Melbourne for most of the first half and then there is Curnow and McKay as well.

    Hope McCartin is ok to come back in. Francis was not up to it on Friday, but he was ok in a few games last year, so he probably needs more game time to find form, but probably not against this tall team.

    In the VFL, Hamling kicked four goals, Parker was strong (including booting the winning goal from outside 50) and Campbell had good stats (but don’t know how effective his disposals were).

    Longmire doesn’t like large changes to a winning team so I think only Francis will come out for McCartin.

    Parker could come in as sub possibly for Fox, with Wicks to be sub?
  • Trever
    Suspended by the MRP
    • Mar 2024
    • 73

    #2
    Ins

    Ladhams
    Parker
    Campbell

    Outs

    Francis
    Roberts
    Fox

    Sub-Parker

    I’m bringing in Ladhams to essentially run with Perrotett (Carlton starting ruckman) and starting Grundy in the backline on Tom D-K. When Tom D-K goes into the ruck or rucks in the forward line Grundy follows him. Ladhams takes care of the main Carlton ruckman and gets his chance for substantial minutes in the middle.

    Melican on McKay and Rampe on Curnow. I’m keeping Blakey off a tall opponent so he can help in the air by jumping in from the side. Campbell to play the small defender role that Robert’s was playing and Parker so add injection via the sub.

    Comment

    • Hotpotato
      Senior Player
      • Jun 2014
      • 2267

      #3
      The game is SOLD OUT .
      Perrotett is doubtful , busted up finger.

      Comment

      • liz
        Veteran
        Site Admin
        • Jan 2003
        • 16755

        #4
        No Tommy Mac this week, but no concerns for Blakey.

        Comment

        • Cosmic Wizard
          recruit me pretty please!
          • Sep 2005
          • 620

          #5
          Yes, agree with Robert being left out.

          Has played really well but the last two weeks has really drop off, like any young player.

          Put Campbell in the forward line and give Papley a rest, he is definitely carrying some injury.

          Would keep Francis; he was rusty but on looking at the replay not that bad.

          But Parker has to go in: yes, he is not fast, but he will destroy Carlton singlehandedly!
          doof-doof

          Comment

          • Captain
            Captain of the Side
            • Feb 2004
            • 3602

            #6
            Grundy is one of the best rucks in the comp, not a defender. That is the most random suggestion I have heard.

            Roberts looks like he needs a spell. I would swap him with Campbell.

            Fox to come in for Francis.

            Parker to be sub.

            Melican can take McKay, Rampe on Curnow and either Fox or Blakey on TDK. If he doesn't mark it, they will destroy him when running off.

            Comment

            • Roadrunner
              Senior Player
              • Jan 2018
              • 1464

              #7
              Originally posted by Captain
              Grundy is one of the best rucks in the comp, not a defender. That is the most random suggestion I have heard.

              Roberts looks like he needs a spell. I would swap him with Campbell.

              Fox to come in for Francis. I’m

              Parker to be sub.

              Melican can take McKay, Rampe on Curnow and either Fox or Blakey on TDK. If he doesn't mark it, they will destroy him when running off.
              Roberts was poor but needs a spell so Campbell in for him. I thought Francis was ok and he is a good spoil so he could be on TDK. Parks has to come in.

              Comment

              • Dow
                Regular in the Side
                • Sep 2022
                • 816

                #8
                Originally posted by Trever
                Ins

                Ladhams
                Parker
                Campbell

                Outs

                Francis
                Roberts
                Fox

                Sub-Parker

                I’m bringing in Ladhams to essentially run with Perrotett (Carlton starting ruckman) and starting Grundy in the backline on Tom D-K. When Tom D-K goes into the ruck or rucks in the forward line Grundy follows him. Ladhams takes care of the main Carlton ruckman and gets his chance for substantial minutes in the middle.

                Melican on McKay and Rampe on Curnow. I’m keeping Blakey off a tall opponent so he can help in the air by jumping in from the side. Campbell to play the small defender role that Robert’s was playing and Parker so add injection via the sub.
                Not sure that much or any off that would work ? you go 8/1 and now want to make wholesale changes.

                Comment

                • i'm-uninformed2
                  Reefer Madness
                  • Oct 2003
                  • 4653

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Trever
                  Ins

                  Ladhams
                  Parker
                  Campbell

                  Outs

                  Francis
                  Roberts
                  Fox

                  Sub-Parker

                  I’m bringing in Ladhams to essentially run with Perrotett (Carlton starting ruckman) and starting Grundy in the backline on Tom D-K. When Tom D-K goes into the ruck or rucks in the forward line Grundy follows him. Ladhams takes care of the main Carlton ruckman and gets his chance for substantial minutes in the middle.

                  Melican on McKay and Rampe on Curnow. I’m keeping Blakey off a tall opponent so he can help in the air by jumping in from the side. Campbell to play the small defender role that Robert’s was playing and Parker so add injection via the sub.
                  Grundy to play defence? Ummm, I’ve taken some mind bending drugs in my life but no.
                  'Delicious' is a fun word to say

                  Comment

                  • MattW
                    Veterans List
                    • May 2011
                    • 4208

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Captain
                    Grundy is one of the best rucks in the comp, not a defender. That is the most random suggestion I have heard.

                    Roberts looks like he needs a spell. I would swap him with Campbell.

                    Fox to come in for Francis.

                    Parker to be sub.

                    Melican can take McKay, Rampe on Curnow and either Fox or Blakey on TDK. If he doesn't mark it, they will destroy him when running off.
                    Agree with all of that.

                    Comment

                    • Trever
                      Suspended by the MRP
                      • Mar 2024
                      • 73

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Captain
                      Grundy is one of the best rucks in the comp, not a defender. That is the most random suggestion I have heard.

                      Roberts looks like he needs a spell. I would swap him with Campbell.

                      Fox to come in for Francis.

                      Parker to be sub.

                      Melican can take McKay, Rampe on Curnow and either Fox or Blakey on TDK. If he doesn't mark it, they will destroy him when running off.
                      The most random suggestion you’ve heard. That’s dramatic.

                      I guess if Tom D-K takes 10 marks, kicks 4 goals, destroys Francis in attack and totally outgunnes McLean in the ruck then we may revisit my suggestion.

                      Comment

                      • crackedactor 01
                        Regular in the Side
                        • Jun 2020
                        • 742

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Roadrunner
                        Roberts was poor but needs a spell so Campbell in for him. I thought Francis was ok and he is a good spoil so he could be on TDK. Parks has to come in.
                        Watching the seconds last Saturday and I thought Campbell's second half was outstanding. Interesting dilemma facing selectors on Parker and Campbell.

                        Comment

                        • Auntie.Gerald
                          Veterans List
                          • Oct 2009
                          • 6474

                          #13
                          What a challenge to pick the INS and OUTS this week against a very good team. We have had such good run and we are in form and everyone has been playing well enough.

                          You could mount an argument for all players from last week to stay and or a few to be promoted from Ressies.

                          With match ups in the Blues backline and McCartin still out I sense on the smaller SCG we will need Francis to stay in with Fox the Sub. The spoil and height of Francis will be important early on in the first half when more congested and willing. If the game opens up more then Fox would be a handy sub for the backline.

                          Although I like Robbo on the SCG, he did look tired and off the pace last week in Freeo. He is only young and it has been a big 10 weeks in Snrs. Robbo will be there there about every week from now on anyway, so a week off might be good for him this week to freshen up. Campbell sliced it up in Ressies and his kicking, run and speed off the mark will be very handy this week in my opinion.

                          The next question is “are we a better team right now with Luke Parker in the 23?”

                          I think we are. Yet it is complicated because of the rise and rise of Heeney in 2024 playing somewhat Lukes past role and at an elite level. So for me I would have JJ playing more Sam Wicks role and drop Sam Wicks this week to get Parker back in the team and especially on the smaller SCG.

                          JJ has many strings to his bow vs Sam wicks primarily a pressure small forward only. Sam has been playing ok but JJ much better.

                          JJ has been spending some of the time up front anyway and between Patch, Parker and JJ rotating through the forwards and midfield along with Warner getting a little time one on one up front also…..I think there is less dependency on a one dimensional player like Wicks only playing in the forwards as a pressure role.

                          Isn’t it amazing that we are in a cycle where Parker and Campbell are not automatic INS.

                          Loving this season and look forward to see Parks back on the SCG along with BJ.

                          INS

                          Parker
                          Campbell


                          OUTS

                          Roberts
                          Wicks

                          Sub-Fox
                          "be tough, only when it gets tough"

                          Comment

                          • lwjoyner
                            Regular in the Side
                            • Nov 2004
                            • 949

                            #14
                            like wome what aunties changes, except it would be harry C dropped instead of roberts. Harry is slowing down and his icking is just so so

                            Comment

                            • Markwebbos
                              Veterans List
                              • Jul 2016
                              • 7186

                              #15
                              JJ has been tagging the oppositions most creative half-back with great success. I can’t imagine they’ll change his role to replace Sam Wicks.

                              It is hard to see where Luke Parker would improve the team other than as a replacement for Adams.

                              Campbell surely comes back at some point but the question is where? He’s never really found his niche

                              Comment

                              Working...