If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Wowzers! He’s been one of my favourite guys to watch for years now, here’s hoping it works out for everyone involved (including we poor fans!)!
I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his time
I’m happy
thats what it takes to get a key forward that is potent on the scoreboard but more importantly allows us to shape up in attack and box in if no goal
a Curnow allows us much more control over a game and to stay in the fight in tough games just like Bud and Lockett did for us
Chad
gulden
paps
heeney
campbelll
lizard
roberts
lloyd
wicks
serong
etc will be licking their lips to hit that mark
macca
joel
Mclean
well these guys only have to deal with 2/3/4 defenders
its a great move and worth the give to get
Last edited by Auntie.Gerald; 15 October 2025, 06:57 PM.
The Swans have sent three first-round picks to Carlton (in 2025, 2026 and 2027) and Hayward to the Blues, who have given Sydney picks 31, 42 and a 2027 second-round pick to go with Curnow.
Ok
so
if we come top 4 in 2026 and 2027 our first rounds picks might not be far apart from Carlton who I think will be bottom 4 and especially now they have let Curnow go
carlton are in another rebuild and we are not
We and Geelong have not been that excited with first rounders in 2025,26,27 and the cats are masters of the trade
we obviously feel we are stacked with talent and ready to rock again into a window injuries permitted
we still have currency for value picks like we have achieved many a time with Parker, Reid, Chad, Goodes etc
and let’s be honest those value picks can emerge AFL ready ina few years from now - we don’t need them now or in the next few years to be AFL ready……let them develop over time like many a player needs to when aspiring to AFL level
its a win win
im happy
2025: picks 31, 32, 42, 63. (1036 points).
bring on the draft and develop these picks for 3 to 4 years down the track so they can be up first round picks like we so often do
Last edited by Auntie.Gerald; 15 October 2025, 07:01 PM.
The Swans have sent three first-round picks to Carlton (in 2025, 2026 and 2027) and Hayward to the Blues, who have given Sydney picks 31, 42 and a 2027 second-round pick to go with Curnow.
Ok
so
if we come top 4 in 2026 and 2027 our first rounds picks might not be far apart from Carlton who I think will be bottom 4 and especially now they have let Curnow go
carlton are in another rebuild and we are not
We and Geelong have not been that excited with first rounders in 2025,26,27 and the cats are masters of the trade
we obviously feel we are stacked with talent and ready to rock again into a window injuries permitted
we still have currency for value picks like we have achieved many a time with Parker, Reid, Chad, Goodes etc
and let’s be honest those value picks can emerge AFL ready ina few years from now - we don’t need them now or in the next few years to be AFL ready……let them develop over time like many a player needs to when aspiring to AFL level
its a win win
im happy
2025: picks 31, 32, 42, 63. (1036 points).
bring on the draft and develop these picks for 3 to 4 years down the track so they can be up first round picks like we so often do
perfect balance between immediate gain and nurture talent into AFL ready while balancing the cap and future upgrades of serious players on the list
I’m happy with the deal- taking emotion out of it in losing Ollie and Wilbur, we gained a top forward in Charlie, which enables us to have a more flexible attack. It also means we can swing either Logan or Hayden down back to help out if needed. And of course I’m also happy with Jai Serong, who I think can develop, while sorry to lose Buller.
if we can obtain our Academy kids with our picks as planned and as set out by members above, I think we have done very well!
While I wasn't too excited about pursuing Curnow, now that it's done, I'm pretty happy, as long as he stays fit.
As for the players we lost, let's face it, we were never going to win a flag with Buller or even maybe Ollie and Will, who has gone missing in our last two GF's.
People have complained in the past about Horse having his favourites, implying he was persisting with mediocrity....well, Coxy's got ruthless to bring in an A grade talent. Time will tell if it's the right move but something had to change after the last two GF capitulations.
I for one am happy that it also puts the whole playing group on notice.....'don't get too comfy'.
PS: Hopefully Buller doesn't win a flag with Collingwood or I'll be eating my words!
While I wasn't too excited about pursuing Curnow, now that it's done, I'm pretty happy, as long as he stays fit.
As for the players we lost, let's face it, we were never going to win a flag with Buller or even maybe Ollie and Will, who has gone missing in our last two GF's.
People have complained in the past about Horse having his favourites, implying he was persisting with mediocrity....well, Coxy's got ruthless to bring in an A grade talent. Time will tell if it's the right move but something had to change after the last two GF capitulations.
I for one am happy that it also puts the whole playing group on notice.....'don't get too comfy'.
PS: Hopefully Buller doesn't win a flag with Collingwood or I'll be eating my words!
The Pies won’t be winning a flag any time soon. They’re so heading over a cliff. Name a player other than Woosy Boy under 24 who has real talent?
As an aside, the Swans are pretty peeved with Buller. We will pick you up as a mid season draftee, nurse (and spend a ton of resources) through nine months of a back injury, give you a game and you say hoo roo. Plus apparently like The Rat and his move to Adelaide, he didn’t even have the decency to tell them in his exit interview.
Comment