judd

[NMWBloods]

1. Too injured and getting to be a bit too aged.

I really wonder if you just make things up and have no reference back to reality? Prior to this year Judd had played 111 games out of 115. And he's only just turned 24.

[AnnieH]

I really wonder if you just make things up and have no reference back to reality? Prior to this year Judd had played 111 games out of 115. And he's only just turned 24.

Really??? He looks so much older than that, and it seems like he's been around for ever and ever. I would have thought he was at least 28.

Can you ever disagree with something that someone says without playing the man? Not very moderate behaviour for a moderator.

[NMWBloods]

Really??? He looks so much older than that, and it seems like he's been around for ever and ever. I would have thought he was at least 28.

Can you ever disagree with something that someone says without playing the man? Not very moderate behaviour for a moderator.

I'm commenting on your post - it looks like you just made that up, in the same way as you made up the bit about Hall not playing well in 2006 and 2005. It was a question based on observation.

If you are going to make absolute assertions without any knowledge behind them then prepare to be challenged on them.

Also, when I do disagree with you and state facts you wander all over the place - such as the Hall thread.

[AnnieH]

I'm commenting on your post - it looks like you just made that up, in the same way as you made up the bit about Hall not playing well in 2006 and 2005. It was a question based on observation.

If you are going to make absolute assertions without any knowledge behind them then prepare to be challenged on them.

Also, when I do disagree with you and state facts you wander all over the place - such as the Hall thread.

You can throw as many useless stats around as much as you like (ala the Hall thread) - that's all they are ... useless stats. Do you have a stat that says how many times the ball was kicked in the Blind Barry direction this year and how many times he missed it ... uncontested? Stats really are pretty useless at the end of the day.

Everything I say is based purely on MY observations.

I believe I have the right to observe and comment how I happen to see it, without you being insulting. If you can't say something without being insulting, do not say anything at all. It doesn't make you look big or important, it actually makes you look quite foolish.

I'm not the only person you constantly do this to, and I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one complaining.

You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar Nick.

[Sanecow]

You catch more bees with honey than you do with vinegar Nick.

How do you catch so many flies?

[AnnieH]

How do you catch so many flies?

It is flies Sanecow, you are indeed right. Thank you for pointing it out. Nick being rude threw me. I've corrected it.

[Wardy]

This is about the wildest offseason rumour I've ever heard.

and its not even off season yet!

[Plugger46]

You can throw as many useless stats around as much as you like (ala the Hall thread) - that's all they are ... useless stats. Do you have a stat that says how many times the ball was kicked in the Blind Barry direction this year and how many times he missed it ... uncontested? Stats really are pretty useless at the end of the day.

Stats or no stats, Barry Hall was one of the best players in the competition in 2005 and 2006.

That is inarguable.

[Guzzitza]

Ha ha. Well it truely is mad monday now isn't it. This will never happen.I will eat my keyboard if it does. Besides, as others have said, Roos would have to change the whole game plan to accomodate an attacking player - heaven forbid!

I think if we got Judd, it would show that Roos is the Jose Mourinho of AFL!!

[NMWBloods]

You can throw as many useless stats around as much as you like (ala the Hall thread) - that's all they are ... useless stats. Do you have a stat that says how many times the ball was kicked in the Blind Barry direction this year and how many times he missed it ... uncontested? Stats really are pretty useless at the end of the day.

So how many goals Hall kicked is a useless stat? Better to rely on your observations and recollections?

Everything I say is based purely on MY observations.

Sure, and just as you have a right to express your opinion, I - or anyone else - has a right to comment on that.

I believe I have the right to observe and comment how I happen to see it, without you being insulting. If you can't say something without being insulting, do not say anything at all. It doesn't make you look big or important, it actually makes you look quite foolish.

If you are going to come out with ridiculous comments like "Judd is too old" then it's hardly surprising that you'll cop some flack. To suggest you are making something up is hardly the most insulting thing I'm sure you've heard. In fact, it pales into comparison to some of the things people say on here.

I'm not the only person you constantly do this to, and I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one complaining.

You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar Nick.

It is flies Sanecow, you are indeed right. Thank you for pointing it out. Nick being rude threw me. I've corrected it.

Seems that little things I say - like you are making something up - are considered rude, but so many other rude things are ignored. It's like your recollection of how players perform or how old they are. Not really based on the facts.

[AnnieH]

Judd does look a lot older than 24.
That was the point I was making when I said that the hard life at the criminals was taking it's toll, i.e. his body is going to give up way before he turns 28.

I really wish that someone who knows how to do these things will make me a very special sarcasm smilie.

[goswannie14]

Stats or no stats, Barry Hall was one of the best players in the competition in 2005 and 2006.

That is inarguable.

Its always arguable, these things will always be subjective.

[Plugger46]

Its always arguable, these things will always be subjective.

Most things are.

That one isn't.

[Sanecow]

I really wish that someone who knows how to do these things will make me a very special sarcasm smilie.

[AnnieH]

So how many goals Hall kicked is a useless stat? Better to rely on your observations and recollections?

Sure, and just as you have a right to express your opinion, I - or anyone else - has a right to comment on that.

If you are going to come out with ridiculous comments like "Judd is too old" then it's hardly surprising that you'll cop some flack. To suggest you are making something up is hardly the most insulting thing I'm sure you've heard. In fact, it pales into comparison to some of the things people say on here.





Seems that little things I say - like you are making something up - are considered rude, but so many other rude things are ignored. It's like your recollection of how players perform or how old they are. Not really based on the facts.

Mate, I need to know one thing. Do you have friends IRL?
Judd is old. He body is old and worn after playing two VERY HARD years of football (2005/06). He's been playing on half a tank for the last four months.