What was worse?

[swantastic]

Retaliation such as a forceful shove not a full-blooded punch to the face.

That doesnt work IMO,if some one forcefully pushes you they should just expect to get chinned.

People dont forcefully push you because they like you,they do it to hurt or intimidate you.

[Jewels]

Sam on TFS was going on and on and on about how the tribunal got it wrong with Solomon's penalty as it deserved less than Hall, as Solomon's hit on Ling was reactionary but Hall set himself to hit Staker. WTF
I don't know if, because I am a Swans fan, I am biased, but to say that one was worse than the other or that one was pre-planned and the other not is plain ridiculous.
Even the footage they showed of both incidents, to me anyway, backed Hall far more then Solomon.

[Mr Magoo]

Did anyone see fox footy teams last night.

Cant believe they thought that Solomon only deserved four to six weeks and that Halls was much worse. It seems that if you throw a nice clean punch it is much worse than any other hit ever committed on a football field.

Not a mention by anyone about Buchanans suspension but a basic feeling that kerr was silly etc but no comparison to Halls shot - how is kerrs punch any different, other than being in play - the guy who was punched in the head by kerr had no more expectation of a punch to the head than staker.

To make it worse we the panel then continued to gloat about the struggling interstate teams and how melbourne teams were dominating the comp as if it had been some conspiracy by the interstate teams of the past to keep the victorian teams down. It seems what is really wanted in victorian afl circles is a "truly national comp" where the interstate teams take a damn good flogging each week by the victorian teams.