Facing some home truths
Collapse
X
-
-
Comment
-
Bevo had one goal kicked on him (which according to some has ended our season), had 18 possessions (11 handpasses - he was getting it out) and made two tackles. Craig Bolton was killed by Franklin had 13 possessions (three handpasses - he was receiving) no tackles, inexplicable seeing he was chasing Buddy all day and no contested marks - from a key position backman! Franklin for the record had 17 disposals, kicked 3 goals - should have been 6 and took 6 contested marks. Malceski's performance was abysmal (as predicted) - had 7 possessions, no tackles, Moore had 6 possessions (50% were effective) and Crouch, our premier small defender according to some had 5 possessions, no contested marks (and dropped an absolute sitter) and made all of one tackle, attempted to trip an opponent for which he should be before the Tribunal, before an aging body gave up on him. Tremendous from a tagger. Honestly how on earth can you single out a kid for a bagging, who played pretty well, compared to some of the garbage that was played by Malceski and Crouch for example.Bevo bandwagon driverComment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
Bevo had one goal kicked on him (which according to some has ended our season), had 18 possessions (11 handpasses - he was getting it out) and made two tackles. Craig Bolton was killed by Franklin had 13 possessions (three handpasses - he was receiving) no tackles, inexplicable seeing he was chasing Buddy all day and no contested marks - from a key position backman! Franklin for the record had 17 disposals, kicked 3 goals - should have been 6 and took 6 contested marks. Malceski's performance was abysmal (as predicted) - had 7 possessions, no tackles, Moore had 6 possessions (50% were effective) and Crouch, our premier small defender according to some had 5 possessions, no contested marks (and dropped an absolute sitter) and made all of one tackle, attempted to trip an opponent for which he should be before the Tribunal, before an aging body gave up on him. Tremendous from a tagger. Honestly how on earth can you single out a kid for a bagging, who played pretty well, compared to some of the garbage that was played by Malceski and Crouch for example.
As for the other players, Malceski, Moore and Crouch are definitely struggling, as are a number of players. Doesn't mean that Bevan can do no wrong though, which you tediously say each week.Comment
-
Any key defender who takes no contested marks and makes not one tackle while his opponent kicks three goals and has 17 possessions has been carved up. His game compared to anyone's was a shockerBevo bandwagon driverComment
-
According to some of your recent analysis, our AA CHB, one of the best defenders in the competition, has put in shockers, while your love child can do no wrong.Comment
-
Sorry. My mistake. Can't get my head around this finishing outside the 8 business and I substituted "10th" for "8th" by mistake. You are correct - a 10th place finish will probably get us pick 8.Comment
-
Bevo bandwagon driverComment
-
Why is it in recent weeks, when anyone says that Bevan let us down, you start to say that Bolton was worse?
In defending Bevan you are doing exactly the thing that you are allegedly trying to defend Bevan from, that is, unfairly criticising another Swans player.Does God believe in Atheists?Comment
-
Certainly blokes like Malceski, Buchanan, Ablett and to a lesser extent Bevan, LRT and Crouch (only by injury) but in all honesty who are their replacements at present?
Laidlaw looks like he might finally be close, Smith was close until he had the stuffing knocked out of him a couple of weeks ago, Vez is on his way back, Merideth has now broken his arm, Murphy is not back on the park and Pyke has been in the country less times than I have had hot dinners.
That really only leaves Thornton who has had a taste and not much esle. DOK seems to be coming good!
We have had a shocking run of injuries over the last 2 to 3 years with our younger players, some of them look like reasonable footballers but without consistent football, they are not ready to play senior football.
Saying all that, I hope we see Laidlaw and Smith get games this week for Malceski and Buchanon.
DST"Looking forward to a rebuilt, new, fast and exciting Swans model in 2010"
Comment
-
We have had a shocking run of injuries over the last 2 to 3 years with our younger players, some of them look like reasonable footballers but without consistent football, they are not ready to play senior football.
DST[/QUOTE]
perhaps it is karma. our two years on top were recognised as being almost injury free (although willo and lrt in yr 2 did rather give the lie to thatComment
-
Could be, but it must be frustrating to the coaching staff to know they have some decent footballers but are unable to give them an extended run of football in the seniors due to constant stop start injuries.
DST"Looking forward to a rebuilt, new, fast and exciting Swans model in 2010"
Comment
Comment