Game Thread Sydney v Collingwood

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Nico
    Veterans List
    • Jan 2003
    • 11329

    Originally posted by dimelb
    How I saw it too. Just like Hawthorn the momentum shifted.

    I saw it differently. To me it was a free or play on. Davis played for it a bit but did he ever take possession. Regardless the umpire blew the whistle and didn't call play on, so Richards officially blew it.
    http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

    Comment

    • Doctor J.
      Senior Player
      • Feb 2003
      • 1310

      Originally posted by anniswan
      Boy Dr J you seem angry, just hold your breath and breath slowly, I heard a helicopter over Sunbury tonight, it wasn't over your house was it.
      You betch I'm angry. Second game in a row where our game plan has been exposed for the crap that it actually is, and against a couple of vey ordinary teams. We make mistakes that not even Melbourne make. We can have 15 consecutive possessions to go no where, and the opposition have 5 and score a goal. At the end of the game the coaching staff look at the stats and say "gee he did good 15 kicks and 17 handballs" never mind that 30 of the possessions did nothing to produce a goal.

      When was the last time we saw Sydney go "coast to coast" from a kick in.
      Been ages, and why? Because its not in the game plan. Better to have a multitude of possessions around the half back line than move the ball forward by running, handpassing, and kicking to position. Honestly watching Geelong and watching Sydney, you would think Sydney are playing with a different rule book. (yeah I know the scumps hate us but not even the scumps are to blame for our lack of basic footy skills)

      Comment

      • kangle4
        Warming the Bench
        • May 2003
        • 200

        jolly won nearly every hitout with most going to a swans player because the pies players just stood back waiting for us to fumble it which is what we did more often than not.

        Comment

        • ROK Lobster
          RWO Life Member
          • Aug 2004
          • 8658

          Originally posted by Pace To Burn
          Id rather have someone who dominates the clearances giving first use of the footy like that tonight everyday of the week rather than some poof who runs on their own and hits a target everytime, they dont win you games the blokes doing the hard stuff do, have a look at Barlow tonight did he give us the opp to win, dont think so
          Kirk did not win us the game tonight - and has not done so for a while now. He had a great game but he is no longer a star (if he every really was).

          Comment

          • ROK Lobster
            RWO Life Member
            • Aug 2004
            • 8658

            Originally posted by Doctor J.
            (yeah I know the scumps hate us but not even the scumps are to blame for our lack of basic footy skills)
            With a couple of spectacular exceptions we went pretty well with the umpires tonight.

            Comment

            • Q...
              On the Rookie List
              • Jun 2005
              • 237

              I came on here to have a whinge. But then I read a few posts and decided that you have it covered for me.

              I find it a little sad that you are mostly having a go at the Swans, but I suppose we all send our anger in different places.

              I was more interested in the fact that:

              Half a quarter to go, the Swans are down but outplaying their opposition, they should be able to do get home, but...

              A free kick is payed; a fifty metre is given (or 3); a goal is scored and the momentum swings.

              I know, I know. We can only control what we do, but I don't think for a second that any one of our players or coaches is trying to do anything other than what they can to win a game.

              I don't think I can blame the umpires either; I don't think they are doing anything other than their job, but...

              It shouldn't have been a free kick to Davis and having another look at all of those 50s against Barry last week, none of them should've been payed.

              The Swans need to improve, but so does the officiation of our game.

              At three quarter time, my biggest worry was that the Swans wouldn't be credited with a win. That the talk in footy over the coming week would be about the need for substitutions and that's what robbed the pies of the match. Now, I'm sure substitutions won't be mentioned, the pies will be lauded for their ability to win a couple of players down and worst, no one will mention the manner in which undeserving goals are handed out willy-nilly.

              Rant over.

              Comment

              • Donners
                On the Rookie List
                • Jan 2003
                • 1061

                I love Kirk's work ethic, but I didn't think this was one of his better games. The possessions look good on paper, but the reality is that barely half of them found a teammate and several went straight to the opposition. It's no good getting the first touch out of a contest if the opposition wind up putting it back over your head.

                Comment

                • Cardinal
                  Regular in the Side
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 932

                  Oh how I hate the Pies.

                  What I took out of tonight's performance is reinforcement of how frustrating it is to follow the Swans - when we lose it's so often because of factors we have control.

                  Going to be an interesting season. I'm sure after a few bottles of South Australian wine I'll be optimistic again and ready to take on the Crow's crowd

                  Comment

                  • Pace To Burn
                    On the Rookie List
                    • Jul 2007
                    • 748

                    Originally posted by ROK Lobster
                    Kirk did not win us the game tonight - and has not done so for a while now. He had a great game but he is no longer a star (if he every really was).
                    He was the one who gave us a chance, ask every other coach in the Afl if they would love him in there side and they have all said how much they admire him. A def star
                    The edge is not the limit, It's just the starting point...

                    Comment

                    • ep2006
                      Schammer-time!
                      • Mar 2008
                      • 297

                      Neon Leon tore us apart in the last quarter too.

                      Comment

                      • Midfield
                        On the Rookie List
                        • Apr 2009
                        • 196

                        I think we need to settle down. The pies are 4th and I thought we were unlucky, more than anything, not to beat them. It happens sometimes, thats why its such a good game. Sure at certain stages we make the wrong decisions or skill errors, but i'll cop that. The effort from the boys was there tonight and if its maintained we'll make the finals. 100% improvement from a couple of weeks ago. Ed must be shown the door but the rest, as always, are goers. I'll back us to win a few in a row from here.

                        Comment

                        • Q...
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Jun 2005
                          • 237

                          Originally posted by Nico
                          I saw it differently. To me it was a free or play on. Davis played for it a bit but did he ever take possession. Regardless the umpire blew the whistle and didn't call play on, so Richards officially blew it.
                          Is there a reason why only the Swans can do wrong in your eyes?

                          Comment

                          • possumfeatures
                            On the Rookie List
                            • Sep 2005
                            • 44

                            Originally posted by Donners
                            I love Kirk's work ethic, but I didn't think this was one of his better games. The possessions look good on paper, but the reality is that barely half of them found a teammate and several went straight to the opposition. It's no good getting the first touch out of a contest if the opposition wind up putting it back over your head.
                            Reluctanctly agree Donners

                            it just seems that we have no friggin plan...we all go for the hard ball...so no question about courage just intelligence...
                            oh well, maybe next time......

                            Comment

                            • ShockOfHair
                              One Man Out
                              • Dec 2007
                              • 3668

                              Poor skills, poor options: the story of this side.

                              I know footy's a confidence game, and the confidence of a lot of players is down, but at this level there's no excuse for turnovers, poor kicking, and bad handballs. With our skill level, we have no other option but the defensive game plan.

                              Melcho had a good one in the seconds. Maybe this time he can bring it back to the As and let Crouchie play out his days in the capital. Vespa is on the verge - that's something to look forward to.

                              Jack and Barlow need to learn to take their chances, though Hall also missed gettable shots. As for poor old MOL -- 300 looks a long way away.

                              Thornton showed again he's got class, and Smith did a little bit. This time let's keep playing them - there's no upside in putting them back to the twos after three games.

                              The only positives today were how we fought back, and that we had eight players with 40 games or less, and four who'd played less than 20.

                              Next week, the Crows at AAMI. Dear me.
                              The man who laughs has not yet heard the terrible news

                              Comment

                              • Doctor J.
                                Senior Player
                                • Feb 2003
                                • 1310

                                Originally posted by Midfield
                                The effort from the boys was there tonight and if its maintained we'll make the finals.
                                You my friend are on more drugs than Ben Cousins ever took!!!

                                Comment

                                Working...