Psd
Collapse
X
-
Goose is a hack. He is as loose as granny's teeth and he walks around like a lost soul saying, "where'd he go, where'd he go. For a backman his size he is just knocked off the ball too easily in a one on one contest.Comment
-
What we need still is a biggish natural defender to assist Craig Bolton and a dynamic i.e. quick, crumbing forward.
We also need an in form Malceski, or say O'Dwyer or Meredith to take up the wide/ball carrying role.
McGlynn and Kennedy are both in and under so we still need the run/carry types.Sports do not build character. They reveal it....Heywood Broun
I always turn to the sports pages first, which record people's accomplishments. The front page has nothing but man's failures......Earl WarrenComment
-
Reggi, we have one.
....... 'never recruit a private school boy'.
He is quick on the lead, as strong an overhead mark as anybody in the club (ROK included) and can kick goals from outside 50 as well.
....... He had his usual hamstring problems earlier in the year but appeared to overcome them (admittedly, overcome them yet again) and was playing footy to a level which would have him knocking on the door for senior selection. He then hurt his bloody ankle in a marking contest ........
As I said, if DOK is retained and Laidlaw delisted, I will be extremely disappointed and I doubt any regular watcher of the ressies would see it any different.
I did look at the potential draftees for us on You Tube yesterday, and thought you would be happy with Cunnington, Martin or Gary Rohan who looks that sort. But who knows
I reckon DOK will survive, off the back of injuries
That said you hope the clubs is looking into why so many young guys are struggling with injury?You don't ban those who supported your opponent, you make them wallow in their loserdom by covering your victory! You sit them in the front row. You give them a hat! Toby ZieglerComment
-
For what it's worth, definately not, whilst Rioli has a good big game reputation, history says come preliminary finals these types are useless. All you had to do was listen to C/wood fans booing Leon Davis, Milne in the GF
Whilst I think these are handy H & A and many supporters love eye candy footballers, come Prelim and GRand finals you would prefer the Jared Moore's and Amon Buchanan's. When there's heat, they won't get out of the kitchen
Tony Evan's was another classic of this type
Stick with the strong bodied ones. I don't want to turn into the Fremantle Dockers
Would be happy with a Dynamic half forwardYou don't ban those who supported your opponent, you make them wallow in their loserdom by covering your victory! You sit them in the front row. You give them a hat! Toby ZieglerComment
-
If Matt Spangher is available I'd snaffle him up happily enough, I'm not sure he'll be a superstar but I do think he can be serviceable fringe 22 player next year in a position we need and I could see him securing a regular spot over the next couple of seasons. He was a well respected junior as well, worth the gamble in my opinion (although I do fear where he went to school may upset Reggi!).
His age helps a lot too because it fits in with our trading strategy of the week. If we had signed Fev or Lake I'd say "great, go hard for Ball" but the reality is we didn't. I think Ball is the pick talent wise of the crop, but the midfield's pretty covered.
The only outside is that I thought he wanted to go home to Victoria, would Sydney be close enough?
'Err. Cause Goodes is a midfielder. Cause Seaby's a ruckman. Cause Johnstons 18 and hasn't even played much reserves. Cause Curries never played seniors.Comment
-
I very much agree with all you said there. If he does indeed leave the Coast we should reunite him with Seebs.
'Err. Cause Goodes is a midfielder. Cause Seaby's a ruckman. Cause Johnstons 18 and hasn't even played much reserves. Cause Curries never played seniors."As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk
Comment
-
I am so glad we agree. I thought I knew nothing about football.Comment
-
Don't want any of them. We have a full list. Time to bring in the kids. We'll need them more in a cple of years. We have two 1st rd picks, let's use them on some future talent.
If we had to, I'd go Tuck or Coughlan (Not on list but should be available) for 4th rd pick.Comment
-
Just knocked up a quick list of where team lists are at, just to keep myself amused.
Looking at how high up teams draft picks are and how many changes they have already made to their list (there is a minimum 4 required by the AFL), by my reckoning there will be further delistings of this order
Melb two
North two
Port one
Essendon three
Carton three
Adelaide four
WB four
Geelong four
Brisane four
Collingwood three
St.Kilda three
Have a look at the current team lists and it makes you wonder who will get the chop from some of the stronger teamsComment
-
Don't want any of them. We have a full list. Time to bring in the kids. We'll need them more in a cple of years. We have two 1st rd picks, let's use them on some future talent.
If we had to, I'd go Tuck or Coughlan (Not on list but should be available) for 4th rd pick.
If anything our forward line looks a bit inexperienced with the departure of Hally and MOL. Part of me thinks offering Russell Robertson an incentive based contract for a year or two could be beneficial from an instructive perspective, but it really seems that we have a pretty exciting list at the moment that should already provide fierce competition for spots.It's very hard to live in a studio apartment in San Jose with a man who's learning to play violin. That's what she told the police when she handed them the empty revolver.
The Scarlatti Tilt - Richard BrautiganComment
-
The last pre season draft pick we used was Craig Bolton in 2002 so going by recent history it's unlikely we'll be using it this year."As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk
Comment
-
No coincidence that it was 2002 we picked up Bolton in the PSD - the last time we missed the finals.
The PSD is for bottom 8 teams - no point participating when there are 8+ teams ahead of you competing for perhaps 1-5 decent players available.Comment
Comment