Bradshaw v Hall???

[Go Swannies]

Going alright Barry.

Amazing what a wake up call getting sacked can be

isn't it Shneiderman?

[Wardy]

good accurate delivery of the ball makes a hell of a difference too - Barry is loving it. I couldnt believe how fast the Dogs Blues game was - amazing - the way footy should be played.

[caj23]

Going alright Barry.

Lets see if he can do it against a quality team before getting too excited

[Plugger46]

Lets see if he can do it against a quality team before getting too excited

The man's kicked 600+ goals and played a number of great finals, I don't think he's got much to prove.

[msb]

Well, you would have to say hall at this stage, although when braddy has been in he has been very good for us and boy we need him back after the forward setup yesterday!

[Go Swannies]

The man's kicked 600+ goals and played a number of great finals, I don't think he's got much to prove.

After his attitude over the past couple of years, yes he does. Thug-player-thug isn't a good career summary.

[caj23]

The man's kicked 600+ goals and played a number of great finals, I don't think he's got much to prove.

We're talking 2010 form here, he's been pretty good for the Dogs but they have a similar issue to what we had in that their forward line is now very Barry-centric.

That works fine against a team like Carlton but if he can't do it against a Geelong, St Kilda or Collingwood then it doesn't mean much

[Plugger46]

We're talking 2010 form here, he's been pretty good for the Dogs but they have a similar issue to what we had in that their forward line is now very Barry-centric.

That works fine against a team like Carlton but if he can't do it against a Geelong, St Kilda or Collingwood then it doesn't mean much

Might be more of a reflection on their game plan and their other forwards not going as well as last year, rather than on Hall. Aker, Johnson, Higgins, Gia, Hill etc haven't been at the level they were last year as a group for a variety of reasons.

Played every game, kicked 54 goals and sits second on the Coleman. Pretty decent return for a 33yo.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Any chance we could compare them when they're both playing? Bradshaw was matching Hall quite easily when he wasn't injured.

[Industrial Fan]

Barry is having a good season and good luck to him.

I believe we are still better off this year without him, even if he wins the Coleman.

[Plugger46]

Any chance we could compare them when they're both playing? Bradshaw was matching Hall quite easily when he wasn't injured.

I know that, just thought I'd bring this up for all those who said he was finished.

[swansrule100]

hall should still be in the red and white. Im glad he is doing well he deserves success been a bloody great player. Look at where he was in about 2000 and look at what he turned himself into hes been awesome

[caj23]

Barry is having a good season and good luck to him.

I believe we are still better off this year without him, even if he wins the Coleman.

This

[Jewels]

barry is having a good season and good luck to him.

I believe we are still better off this year without him, even if he wins the coleman.

this

x 2

[swansrule100]

i think we would be a better side if we still had hall