Teams V Pies

[Bas]

I hadn't been on here all day then heard the news story. I hadn't heard 3AW before this news story so it may have been on much earlier.

[Nich]

Wouldn't surprise me if Jetta comes in for Bradshaw. I know Roosy said Vez and Rohan were stiff for not getting a game, so you would expect Vez is next in line but I'm not so sure.

[Bas]

It would have to be Jetta, we could have three Bradshaw's playing tomorrow but unless the midfield are hard at it, there is no chance the forwards will kick goals.

[Melbourne_Blood]

Wouldn't be playing Jetta for his hardness. His pace and the foot skills he displayed in his first five games would be very handy though.

[Bas]

I 'm wondering what Malthouse is up to just playing Jolly against Mummy and Pyke. He'll have to use another player as a ruckmen against Pyke. H. Shaw being out won't be much bonus for us as he hasn't been playing that well.

[liz]

H. Shaw being out won't be much bonus for us as he hasn't been playing that well.

Maybe. maybe not. Shaw can be very creative and even destructive on his day but, a bit like Kennelly, he is susceptible to being taken out of the play if an opponent sits on him throughout a game. He doesn't seen to be able to break a tag. The fact he has been in modest form recently reflects him getting a fair amount of attention from the opposition. So if he is out, it frees up McGlynn or Rohan or whoever else might be given the job of keeping him quiet. Whoever comes in for him is unlikely to have the ability to set the Pies up coming forward as well as Shaw can when allowed to run free.

[Melbourne_Blood]

I'd say Leigh Brown would be the one doing back up ruck duties. Pyke should be tear him apart in the tap outs.

[Captain]

So is H Shaw out? Is Bradshaw out?

[swansrob]

I'd say Leigh Brown would be the one doing back up ruck duties. Pyke should be tear him apart in the tap outs.

I hope this happens. I'm not a Leigh Brown fan.

[swansrob]

So is H Shaw out? Is Bradshaw out?

AFL website still has both in.

[ernie koala]

Teddy for Braddy seems a bit odd if Braddy is really out. Playfair would have seemed more likely though I hope he's being having wet footy kicking practice.

This nightmare just keeps rearing it's ugly head.....NO THANKYOU !

[msb]

AFL website still has both in.

They will be named right up until the last minute I assume

[Bas]

Roos was on 2GB and didn't hint on any other outs.