Swans vs Carlton Game thread.

[sfan]

3 am here so before I go to bed....once again, I hate McAvaney....he makes every loss soooooo much worse....

top effort staying up late

[annew]

Players who had a crack today: Bird, Johnson, Smith.

That is all.

Thought Bird wasn't much,Johnson & Smith great, Hannebery pretty good and Tadgh a discgrace.

[Swans500]

top effort staying up late

TY mate....for me it is either 5 am or midnight to see the games live....couldn't exist without it though....never missed attending a Swans game in the 19 years I was in Sydney!....

[Legs Akimbo]

I've just come back from holiday overseas and this is the first game I have watched for nearly two months. Horrible horrible horrible.

How bad is Kennelly? No forward line to speak of. Midfield just a rabble. Never seen so many basic disposal errors. We look anything but a top 4 team.

[Nich]

Yep against a classier side we got shown up. LRT looked magic against a guy with a fractured back a few weeks ago but he is not the answer. No pressure if we turn it over. Jesse has to come back. Problem is we back our Seniors so much they won't leave them out so we'll lose someone else just to keep lrt in there somewhere.

[Dan]

The team I would have next week, assuming Mumford is out suspended
FF: TDL White McGlynn
HF: Okeefe Reid Goodes
C: Shaw Kennedy Bird
HB: Johnson Grundy Malceski
FB: Smith Richards Mattner
Foll: Seaby Jack Hannebery
Int: Johnston Heath Pyke?
Sub: Jetta

EDIT: Forgot Bolton and McVeigh. Swap them with Heath, and move someone, not sure who, to sub

[Donners]

It looks like Seaby and Mummy just can't play together in the same side.

[Triple B]

Doubtful they'll play in the same side next week.

Mummy in a bit of strife,as silly as the rule is...

[Cheer_Cheer]

Doubtful they'll play in the same side next week.

Mummy in a bit of strife,as silly as the rule is...

He looked to be grabbing his hammy in the last qtr anyway.. A couple of weeks off wont do him any harm.. Where is Pyke at ?

[nomae]

Thought Bird wasn't much,Johnson & Smith great, Hannebery pretty good and Tadgh a discgrace.

To be fair Bird kept Judd quiet for the whole of the first half, plus he (Judd) didn't have much of an impact in the second half, he just let the other 21 blokes run rings around us. And yeah, Tadgh was shocking.

The team I would have next week, assuming Mumford is out suspended
FF: TDL White McGlynn
HF: Okeefe Reid Goodes
C: Shaw Kennedy Bird
HB: Johnson Grundy Malceski
FB: Smith Richards Mattner
Foll: Seaby Jack Hannebery
Int: Johnston Heath Pyke?
Sub: Jetta

You forgot Bolton.

Agree with the consensus that either TDL or LJ needs to come in. Preferably TDL. Drop LRT.

When was the Mumford incident?

[longmile]

We should look to sell Seaby at the end of this year. Preferably for a good forward.
We have enough good ruckmen with Mumford and Pyke and all the additional stand ins like White, Goodes and LRT

[mpr104]

When was the Mumford incident?

Just saw it on Ch 7, was at the start of last quarter. He is in trouble me thinks, according to the trend of this year in respects to the sling tackle.

[Nich]

And Currie.

[Dan]

You forgot Bolton.

Agree with the consensus that either TDL or LJ needs to come in. Preferably TDL. Drop LRT.

When was the Mumford incident?

Yeah I noticed that, I also forgot McVeigh. I think Bolton to swap with Heath (although I would like him to get a crack, I think he will be a really good player) and don't know how to fit McVeigh in (if he deserves to be).

Mumford incident was in the 4th? Tackled Ellard, pinged his arms back and Ellards head slammed on the ground as Mumford slung him. He had to come off as he was to groggy to take the kick, not sure if he came back on.

[Cheer Squad]

Where were we for 2 and 1/2 quarters? I never thought we'd win this game, but to lose in this manner is pathetic. What a bunch of headcases.