2016 Team

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bungwahl
    Warming the Bench
    • May 2009
    • 173

    Originally posted by Nico
    Jones and Towers stay in. Towers seems to be improving all the time. Reid is a difficult one. Does he make the forward line a bit unbalanced. He and Rohan have not had much pre season so I would expect they are a fair way off. Simply, barring injuries, it is going to be a fight for spots as the season progresses. Like others I think Harry is the vulnerable one, but if he continues to kick 2 goals a game it will be hard to displace him.
    I guess we'll have injuries throughout the year so players will naturally make their way in to the side, then it's just up to them to perform. I'd love to see Reid playing on the wing as he's a superb 1 on 1 mark, and a decent field kick (grrr set shots..). If we leave a forward structure in place then Reid could become a nice pivot.

    Comment

    • Ludwig
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2007
      • 9359

      Reid and Rohan, fully fit, should be in our best 22. I won't suggest who they could replace in Flying South's side because there are many variations as both can play either forward or back. I can see a backline that has Reg, Laidler, Rampe and either Reid or Rohan as our 4 tallest defenders. I can also see a side that had Reid playing forward-ruck in place of Sinclair with Tippett doing the bulk of the ruck work. The best solution would be for one of our tall prospects like Talia (who will hopefully return to full fitness this season), XR, Aliir or Abe Davis get to a level to hold down a KPP role. I thought Talia was well on his way and I have a lot of confidence that Abe Davis will be a very good player, but not sure when.

      Comment

      • Mug Punter
        On the Rookie List
        • Nov 2009
        • 3325

        I know I am bad for looking at early trade bait but I could see a straight swap of Reid for a gun CHB as being a trade option for us at the end of the year, he's on a big money deal and I'm actually not quite sure he is earning it but he would attract massive interest at the trade table.

        Comment

        • Ludwig
          Veterans List
          • Apr 2007
          • 9359

          Originally posted by Mug Punter
          I know I am bad for looking at early trade bait but I could see a straight swap of Reid for a gun CHB as being a trade option for us at the end of the year, he's on a big money deal and I'm actually not quite sure he is earning it but he would attract massive interest at the trade table.
          I doubt very much that we could find a better CHB than Sam Reid, so why would we trade him. The only problem is his soft tissue injuries. He's only 24, which is just around the time he should come into his own. Shame about his slow start to the season. I hope it doesn't affect him too much. I think it's a great asset to have a tall utility that can play back, forward or in the midfield and take on some of the ruck work if needed.

          Comment

          • Mug Punter
            On the Rookie List
            • Nov 2009
            • 3325

            Originally posted by Ludwig
            I doubt very much that we could find a better CHB than Sam Reid, so why would we trade him. The only problem is his soft tissue injuries. He's only 24, which is just around the time he should come into his own. Shame about his slow start to the season. I hope it doesn't affect him too much. I think it's a great asset to have a tall utility that can play back, forward or in the midfield and take on some of the ruck work if needed.
            I guess you are right that turning Reid into a specialist CHB may well be part of the solution to our defensive issues at season end.

            Comment

            • troyjones2525
              Swans Fanatic!
              • Mar 2008
              • 2908

              Originally posted by Flying South
              I mostly agree troy. My ideal squad would be

              B. Smith, T. Richards, Laidler.
              HB. Jones, Grundy, Mills.
              C. K Jack, Parker, Hannebery.
              HF. McVeigh, Franklin, Heeney.
              F. Papley, Tippett, Towers.
              Foll. Sinclair, Kennedy, Mitchell.

              Int. Rampe, Cunningham, Lloyd, Hewett.

              Emerg. Talia, Rohan, Reid, Naismith, McGlynn

              We saw on Saturday what a well balanced forward line can do. The forward line is too tall with Reid up there. For me he sits outside the 22 as coverage.

              IMO Rohan plays his best football in the forward half were he can use his speed to apply forward defensive pressure. He is a good mark and reasonable kick. He and Towers are fighting for the same spot and I'd be happy to rotate the two.

              Jones takes that HB spot.

              Assuming Papley can maintain his debut form he takes the small forward role. With a fit McGlynn ready to step in if his form slumps.
              We could very well see your line-up soon as the only change from the likely round 2 side is McVeigh in for Robinson. While i agree about what you say about forward balance being important, I still feel Reid and probably Rohan are too talented not to be in the side if fit and both have the speed to apply forward pressure if used up there.

              Comment

              • neilfws
                Senior Player
                • Aug 2009
                • 1834

                A little off-topic but: thinking about consistency, I was just looking at the current players with the most consecutive games. There's a Swans player in the top 10, any guesses? You might be surprised.

                Comment

                • Mug Punter
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Nov 2009
                  • 3325

                  Originally posted by neilfws
                  A little off-topic but: thinking about consistency, I was just looking at the current players with the most consecutive games. There's a Swans player in the top 10, any guesses? You might be surprised.
                  I say this without looking at all, but Rampe?

                  Comment

                  • neilfws
                    Senior Player
                    • Aug 2009
                    • 1834

                    Originally posted by Mug Punter
                    I say this without looking at all, but Rampe?
                    Correct! Currently 7th with 72 games. Not sure why I was surprised, now I think about it, he's been more fortunate with injury than most.

                    AFL Tables - Consecutive Games

                    Comment

                    • Mug Punter
                      On the Rookie List
                      • Nov 2009
                      • 3325

                      Originally posted by neilfws
                      Correct! Currently 7th with 72 games. Not sure why I was surprised, now I think about it, he's been more fortunate with injury than most.

                      AFL Tables - Consecutive Games
                      He's pretty durable, it's a great story how he made it to AFL

                      Comment

                      • Meg
                        Go Swannies!
                        Site Admin
                        • Aug 2011
                        • 4828

                        Originally posted by Mug Punter
                        He's pretty durable, it's a great story how he made it to AFL
                        Particularly as he cant see where he's running ........

                        Comment

                        • cherub
                          Warming the Bench
                          • May 2010
                          • 239

                          Hm. Am I reading that table incorrectly? Ryan Crowley is coming back from being rubbed out for 18 months. Tom Liberatore is coming back from an ACL. I don't think that table is accurate.

                          Comment

                          • neilfws
                            Senior Player
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 1834

                            Originally posted by cherub
                            Hm. Am I reading that table incorrectly? Ryan Crowley is coming back from being rubbed out for 18 months. Tom Liberatore is coming back from an ACL. I don't think that table is accurate.
                            Yes, that had me confused too. Looks like their calculation fails to account for when an entire season was missed (2015 in those cases).

                            Comment

                            • neilfws
                              Senior Player
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 1834

                              In other news: Lloyd is the new Jetta, sort of.

                              Comment

                              • dimelb
                                pr. dim-melb; m not f
                                • Jun 2003
                                • 6889

                                Originally posted by neilfws
                                In other news: Lloyd is the new Jetta, sort of.

                                http://m.theage.com.au/afl/sydney-sw...01-gnvxjz.html
                                Thanks neil, didn't get The Age today, a really interesting article on Jake's role and how he fits into it.
                                He reminds him of the guys, close-set, slow, and never rattled, who were play-makers on the team. (John Updike, seeing Josh Kennedy in a crystal ball)

                                Comment

                                Working...