1st Qualifying Final Sydney Swans v GWS Giants at ANZ Stadium
Collapse
X
-
MCS, you are hyper-senstive to this issue. My numbers were based on the historical record.
ANZ Members: Its an event, big turnout.
GWS Members: A fair proportion of the their 15,000 members at this stage, bouyed by the thrill of first final, and the location suiting their existing travel arrangements.
Swans Members: Based on ratio that turned up to #lolnorf final, extrapolated with data from here of the increased hatred of ANZ since that time, and general declining numbers to ANZ in general for swans games, and the fact that their is guaranteed an SCG coming up 1 or 2 weeks later.
Fact based opinions. Not emotional twaddle.Plus you seem to have a fair understanding of 'emotional twaddle', if the 'grand old lady' is anything to go by....
You didn't address my original point that your figures don't even add up - but obviously that doesn't matter because its 'facts'.
I'd love to see the fact based 'historical record' your talking about - in particular the data that splits attendance at games at ANZ down by type. I won't wait with any bated breath however.... unless neilfws can help you out. Surely if its all fact based, you've got the numbers right there, ready to show the world."You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his timeComment
-
Fact Based Opinions....... sums you up to a tee BarryPlus you seem to have a fair understanding of 'emotional twaddle', if the 'grand old lady' is anything to go by....
You didn't address my original point that your figures don't even add up - but obviously that doesn't matter because its 'facts'.
I'd love to see the fact based 'historical record' your talking about - in particular the data that splits attendance at games at ANZ down by type. I won't wait with any bated breath however.... unless neilfws can help you out. Surely if its all fact based, you've got the numbers right there, ready to show the world.
Are you suggesting they are trajecting up?
Sent from my GT-N7105 using TapatalkComment
-
Please point me to the part where I suggested anything about the trajectory of crowd figures at ANZ?
I said nothing about trends in crowd numbers, or any suggestion as to what might be going on - I simply asked you to provide the facts behind your 'fact based opinion' as to the split of fans in attendance at ANZ. Your 'rough guess' or 'opinion' doesn't actually constitute evidence at all - despite your worldly knowledge about everything related to the 'grand old lady'. Show me some evidence, and if it supports your assertion, then I'm more than happy to accept it - aggregate crowd numbers show nothing to support your original assertions around what the split of ticket sales may be - let alone the missing several thousand people in your original calculation."You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
If 60% of the Sydney based Swans members (that's about 27,000), 70% of the Sydney based Giants members as ANZ is in their backyard (that's about 8,000), 4,000 ANZ members and another 5,000 theatre goers went then the crowd would get to 44,000. If it really was at 34,000 on Wednesday night, then 44,000 might be the number. It'd be great if the crowd was more than that though. They just need to start selling $20 tickets to the casual footy fan / theatre goer market. This game is unlikely to happen again in a hurry.Comment
-
1st Qualifying Final Sydney Swans v GWS Giants at ANZ Stadium
Do I get counted twice?
(Which is a way of saying this argument is getting to be really silly.)Comment
-
It would be nice for possibly our last game at ANZ if management could stop treating the general public as idiots and possibly serve up FULL strength beer.
Im not aware of any law against this and the SCG doesn't seem to have a problem with this concept.
Does anyone know why we are forced to drink crap beer specifically at this stadium or is this just part of a wider plan by management at that ground to get us to hate it even moreComment
-
Comment
-
I took the AFL crowd figures for finals games at ANZ, and put a linear trend line against it. This predicts a 2016 figure of 34,000.
With Giants members (15,000) added, and Other opponent removed (say 5,000), that points to a final 44,000 figure too.Comment
-
The bye round brings a whole 'nother level of unpredictability to whats going to happen.
But I would go so far as to say, that I think the Bye helps the Giants more than us. Giants have some old warriors (Mummy, Stevie J, Shaw) who take any chance for a rest, and some young kids who may have tired from a long season who need a rest.
Saying that, we have a heap of young kids also.
Who knows!Comment
-
I think the young kids will love the bye
We have a stack of them and they will come back refreshed
Either way it is a team that is difficult to predict given the youth and the coaches will be picking apart how they can nullify the youth of the swans and over awe them
Just pumped cats are playing the Hawks !!!!"be tough, only when it gets tough"
Comment
Comment