Changes for Round 4 - West Coast

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cosmic Wizard
    recruit me pretty please!
    • Sep 2005
    • 620

    Changes for Round 4 - West Coast

    So many, so little time!

    1. Smith. Has become the new Benny McGlynn, passion there but has lost five meters of pace; this has be coming for a year and half now

    2. Foote. Wasn't tackling meant to be his strong suit?? Seriously bad, what do the coach see in him?

    3. Marsh. Has had plenty of games, but from a set shot kicks it out on the full

    4. Sinclair. Who lost the Jetta/Sinclair trade, both teams. If you are the ruck man and you can't mark, you can't play

    5. Parker. Is he carrying a injury??? He looks totally out of place, missing tackles, bad kicking: give him rest

    6. Naismith. We kept him and Sinclair and Tippert and let Nankervis go??? Not doing enough around the ground

    Other general thoughts, that was one of the worst skill games i have watched; players not being able to kick to players on the lead, hand balling to players who are marked, and worst of all, our entire defense couldn't read the play and were five meters behind their man. Truly woefully!
    Time for some seriously changes.
    doof-doof
  • mcs
    Travelling Swannie!!
    • Jul 2007
    • 8161

    #2
    You can't drop players if there are not the troops available to come in - who do you want to replace these guys with?

    We need to persevere and hope the Swans spirit can lift us from the doldrums.

    That isn't to say we shouldn't make changes. But for me it would be limited to Foote and Sinclair. I just don't think Foote is good enough, and you've summed up Sinclair well. If Teflon Tippo is not fit and Cameron does ok tomorrow, then Cameron for Sinclair is a must. Maybe Edwards for Foote - unless any of the injured guys are ready to return, then whoever that is.
    "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

    Comment

    • Bexl
      Regular in the Side
      • Jan 2003
      • 817

      #3
      Originally posted by Cosmic Wizard


      3. Marsh. Has had plenty of games, but from a set shot kicks it out on the full

      .
      I wouldn't call 10 games plenty. 16 disposals today at an efficiency of 75%. equal 4th best for us today. I think he will be a good player.

      Comment

      • aardvark
        Veterans List
        • Mar 2010
        • 5685

        #4
        Out. Sinclair (forever) Foote Dawson
        In. Tippett Papley and ????? maybe give Dawson one more?
        Last edited by aardvark; 8 April 2017, 12:29 AM.

        Comment

        • annew
          Senior Player
          • Mar 2006
          • 2164

          #5
          Give them a break - it was a one point loss with so many players with so little experience, big jump from the NEAFL and don't forget being in finals every year means no high draft picks. This team of newbies has lost by 38, 23 and 1 point, personally I believe that to be quite an achievment. At least we are competitive.

          Comment

          • Bexl
            Regular in the Side
            • Jan 2003
            • 817

            #6
            Originally posted by annew
            Give them a break - it was a one point loss with so many players with so little experience, big jump from the NEAFL and don't forget being in finals every year means no high draft picks. This team of newbies has lost by 38, 23 and 1 point, personally I believe that to be quite an achievment. At least we are competitive.
            I still have hope. we will see how the rest of the year goes.

            Comment

            • annew
              Senior Player
              • Mar 2006
              • 2164

              #7
              Originally posted by Bexl
              I still have hope. we will see how the rest of the year goes.
              Me too

              Comment

              • Bloody Hell
                Senior Player
                • Oct 2006
                • 3085

                #8
                Originally posted by Cosmic Wizard
                So many, so little time!

                1. Smith. Has become the new Benny McGlynn, passion there but has lost five meters of pace; this has be coming for a year and half now

                2. Foote. Wasn't tackling meant to be his strong suit?? Seriously bad, what do the coach see in him?

                3. Marsh. Has had plenty of games, but from a set shot kicks it out on the full

                4. Sinclair. Who lost the Jetta/Sinclair trade, both teams. If you are the ruck man and you can't mark, you can't play

                5. Parker. Is he carrying a injury??? He looks totally out of place, missing tackles, bad kicking: give him rest

                6. Naismith. We kept him and Sinclair and Tippert and let Nankervis go??? Not doing enough around the ground

                Other general thoughts, that was one of the worst skill games i have watched; players not being able to kick to players on the lead, hand balling to players who are marked, and worst of all, our entire defense couldn't read the play and were five meters behind their man. Truly woefully!
                Time for some seriously changes.
                Horrendous post. Absolutely terrible.

                Fortunately you have numbered your ideas which makes it somewhat easier to respond:

                1.Smith..Smith...SMITH - I don't have a response to this, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Smith is the most underrated player in the comp.
                2. Foote was unimpressive, but there isn't much in the shop.
                3.Marsh was in the best.
                4. Sinclair did what was required.. I'd like to see Cameron, but Sinclair did what was expected.
                5.Parker???, seriously...?
                6. Naismith??? Not on board with any of your opinions (aside from Foote)

                The unfortunate thing of posting on a website such as this is your opinions are held in perpetuity. As Areatha said - Think...

                - - - Updated - - -
                Last edited by RogueSwan; 10 April 2017, 12:16 PM. Reason: Some things need not be said
                The eternal connundrum "what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" was finally solved when David Hasselhoff punched himself in the face.

                Comment

                • Bloody Hell
                  Senior Player
                  • Oct 2006
                  • 3085

                  #9
                  I like Dawson.
                  The eternal connundrum "what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" was finally solved when David Hasselhoff punched himself in the face.

                  Comment

                  • Bloody Hell
                    Senior Player
                    • Oct 2006
                    • 3085

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Cosmic Wizard
                    So many, so little time!

                    1. Smith. Has become the new Benny McGlynn, passion there but has lost five meters of pace; this has be coming for a year and half now

                    2. Foote. Wasn't tackling meant to be his strong suit?? Seriously bad, what do the coach see in him?

                    3. Marsh. Has had plenty of games, but from a set shot kicks it out on the full

                    4. Sinclair. Who lost the Jetta/Sinclair trade, both teams. If you are the ruck man and you can't mark, you can't play

                    5. Parker. Is he carrying a injury??? He looks totally out of place, missing tackles, bad kicking: give him rest

                    6. Naismith. We kept him and Sinclair and Tippert and let Nankervis go??? Not doing enough around the ground

                    Other general thoughts, that was one of the worst skill games i have watched; players not being able to kick to players on the lead, hand balling to players who are marked, and worst of all, our entire defense couldn't read the play and were five meters behind their man. Truly woefully!
                    Time for some seriously changes.
                    And if you're such a gangster, why don't you start a thread about Kieran Jack?
                    The eternal connundrum "what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" was finally solved when David Hasselhoff punched himself in the face.

                    Comment

                    • barry
                      Veterans List
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 8499

                      #11
                      I too worry about Smith. But i cant see any changes for WC game.

                      We are odds on to go 0-5, and from there top 4 is out of the question. Gets some games in the youth.

                      Comment

                      • Dosser
                        Just wild about Harry
                        • Mar 2011
                        • 1833

                        #12
                        A bag??!

                        Comment

                        • Foreign Legion
                          Senior Player
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 3354

                          #13
                          I think Dawson is worth sticking with - at least until Heeney comes back and that he'd have at least one week in the NEAFL I'd think. Dawson does have elite level kicking skills - something we are not overly blessed with.

                          Chambers should be our last roll of the dice for ruckmen. He drops marks he should take and never imposes himself on the game. Bring in Cameron for a run in his home state. We miss Papley SO MUCH!!!

                          Comment

                          • aguy
                            Senior Player
                            • Mar 2014
                            • 1324

                            #14
                            As sad as it is it will now be a struggle to make the top 8. Our only hope is that we win a few of the 50/50 games like last night along the way. Basically we need to win 12 of the next 19 games to have a chance of finals.

                            Having said that it is encouraging to see the young guys competing so well.

                            My changes:
                            OUT: Sinclair, Dawson
                            IN: Tippett, Cameron


                            I say we keep the debutants coming. Cameron has shown he is a decent contested mark and Sinclair doesn't provide that.

                            I know some may say that's a bit tall but the young smalls are doing well. If one of them is a bit sore then I would consider Papley to replace them if he is fit.

                            I think heeney will still be another week away and he will come in for foote.

                            Comment

                            • Blue Sun
                              Senior Player
                              • May 2010
                              • 1439

                              #15
                              Unless we get close to a full side back, it is going to be a nasty one-sided affair next week. WC by at least 6 goals based on last nights performance. I hope Horse focuses on winning the footy this week during training.

                              Comment

                              Working...