Changes for Rnd 18 V St Kilda
Collapse
X
-
Comment
-
It would explain a lot. If that is the case. I think he has enough credits and is performing well enough that they will let him try and play through it as long as he thinks he can. Personally, I would prefer to see him "managed" for this game to see if he can get himself right for some of the very tough games coming up against Hawthorn, Adelaide and Geelong. (That's not to say I think we should expect victory against the Saints, but sometimes you have to take a chance to win big).
Of I'm not a doctor and don't know anything about OP, or if resting him would even help. Fortunately, this is the internet, so knowing nothing is no obstacle to having an opinion!
- - - Updated - - -
It would explain a lot. If that is the case. I think he has enough credits and is performing well enough that they will let him try and play through it as long as he thinks he can. Personally, I would prefer to see him "managed" for this game to see if he can get himself right for some of the very tough games coming up against Hawthorn, Adelaide and Geelong. (That's not to say I think we should expect victory against the Saints, but sometimes you have to take a chance to win big).
Of I'm not a doctor and don't know anything about OP, or if resting him would even help. Fortunately, this is the internet, so knowing nothing is no obstacle to having an opinion!Comment
-
Sadly they just seem to hand those things out these days ...
IMG_2250.JPG
Unfortunately the pubic symphysis in one of the integral structures that (among other functions including allowing pelvic distortion during childbirth) provide some shock absorbing capacity to the pelvic ring during gait, running and kicking activities. However, once inflamed, it is very difficult to rest the pubic symphysis, as it's stressed even during normal gait (and compounded by higher impact activities). Moreover, true osteitis pubis is ideally treated early (analgesics, anti-inflams and managing physical workloads - the latter is particularly non-conducive for elite athletes) - the longer it is neglected the harder it is to treat.
If there is to be a positive, it might be that vague central pelvic symptoms were often diagnosed as OP when it was a particularly fashionable diagnosis, and there was a high spate of them. I suspect that many were perhaps not. However, over recent years, there have been fewer incidents of OP (which I believe is potentially attributable to more accurate diagnosis - with imaging and symptom interpretation).
Suffice to say a poorly manage OP can be career ending. Even a well managed case of OP can take months to recover (depending on severity, acuteness and effectiveness of rehab of course). But OP management of elite athletes has certainly improved IMO (for what that's worth).
Hopefully, if it is OP, they have got onto it early for a better outcome.Last edited by goswannies; 20 July 2017, 01:15 AM.Comment
-
Don't knock philosophy! I don't have a PhD (in philosophy or any other discipline), but I did study quite a few subjects at uni. You have to read heaps to avoid blathering nonsense or just repeating stuff that has already been said better elsewhere....ok, so maybe it did prepare me well for the internet.
Thanks for the info. Very interesting!Comment
-
Comment
-
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
[QUOTE=goswannies;732620]Technically a PhD is in philosophy regardless of the discipline in which it is obtained (except the type that Eddie was gifted ... that's an "honorary" one)[/QUOTE
I was hoping the McGuire pic was photoshopped.
Imagine how the PhD's who actually earned the honorific feel about that!Comment
-
Comment
-
[QUOTE=royboy42;732630]Technically a PhD is in philosophy regardless of the discipline in which it is obtained (except the type that Eddie was gifted ... that's an "honorary" one)[/QUOTE
I was hoping the McGuire pic was photoshopped.
Imagine how the PhD's who actually earned the honorific feel about that!
Back on topicComment
-
Comment
-
Either no changes or Dawson in for someone.Comment
-
Reid does so many jobs for the Swans: including rucking and dropping back into defence for last 5 mins, he'll be difficult to replace.
I really hope Sinkers doesn't reappear. Maybe Towers can do all the pinch hitting in the ruck?
I really would like to see Dawson this week if Reid or Gaz are injured.Comment
Comment