Match Day Thread Rnd 21 Sydney V Fremantle. SCG. 13.45 pm.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Markwebbos
    Veterans List
    • Jul 2016
    • 7186

    Originally posted by Bloody Hell
    I thought Sinclair stood out in the 1st, but Tippo was the better of the two across the rest of the game.

    The noticeable thing between the two is Tippett is absolutely horrendous below his knees, but is significantly more physical and more of a presence.

    In both games (last 2) I was surprised that Tippo played predominately forward and Sinclair predominately ruck. On form I would have it the other way, unless the decision on Naismith has already been made and it's Sinclair out - Naismith in.
    That's what's going to happen this week - Sinkers out, Naismith in

    Comment

    • MattW
      Veterans List
      • May 2011
      • 4218

      Originally posted by Bloody Hell
      I thought Sinclair stood out in the 1st, but Tippo was the better of the two across the rest of the game.

      The noticeable thing between the two is Tippett is absolutely horrendous below his knees, but is significantly more physical and more of a presence.

      In both games (last 2) I was surprised that Tippo played predominately forward and Sinclair predominately ruck. On form I would have it the other way, unless the decision on Naismith has already been made and it's Sinclair out - Naismith in.
      Perhaps they thought Sinclair would be more mobile around the ground. He topped our inside 50s against Geelong. Also, makes sense to ease Kurt back in.

      Comment

      • Cosmic Wizard
        recruit me pretty please!
        • Sep 2005
        • 620

        Originally posted by Markwebbos
        That's what's going to happen this week - Sinkers out, Naismith in

        Sinclair did some great tap work, one to Hanna which resulted in a goal was really brilliant!

        He is getting close to Naismith in rucking but is far better around the ground.

        He should be keep!
        doof-doof

        Comment

        • AnnieH
          RWOs Black Sheep
          • Aug 2006
          • 11332

          Well, that was very exciting.
          No passengers AND four quarters of ruthless.
          Loved the Sydney chant once we topped triple figures. Very appropriate.

          See what happens when you don't kick so many behinds?
          I'm lamenting all behinds kicked this season... our percentage "should" be much higher.
          Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
          Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.

          Comment

          • Kumarangk
            Warming the Bench
            • May 2015
            • 151

            Originally posted by MattW
            Perhaps they thought Sinclair would be more mobile around the ground. He topped our inside 50s against Geelong. Also, makes sense to ease Kurt back in.
            Sinclair's rise in form and versatility is a bonus for us. Couple this with the young kids coming along faster than we expected makes me think we are in a better position than last year.

            Comment

            • aardvark
              Veterans List
              • Mar 2010
              • 5685

              Sinclair and Tippett works for me. They both ruck nearly as well as Naismith but offer far more around the ground. Apologies to Ludwig but I reckon our structure works better with the 2 Ruckmen in.

              Comment

              • dimelb
                pr. dim-melb; m not f
                • Jun 2003
                • 6889

                Originally posted by aardvark
                Sinclair and Tippett works for me. They both ruck nearly as well as Naismith but offer far more around the ground. Apologies to Ludwig but I reckon our structure works better with the 2 Ruckmen in.
                We refer to them as the two ruckmen, and they obviously are, but each of them, especially Sinkers, has been working on their forward 50 play. Tippett's work there has always been decent, often good, but Sinkers has stepped up big time in that role. To watch him rise and seize the ball against good opposition is thrilling stuff, and he is often close enough to make goal kicking easier. Considerable improvement there.
                He reminds him of the guys, close-set, slow, and never rattled, who were play-makers on the team. (John Updike, seeing Josh Kennedy in a crystal ball)

                Comment

                • Ludwig
                  Veterans List
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 9359

                  Originally posted by aardvark
                  Sinclair and Tippett works for me. They both ruck nearly as well as Naismith but offer far more around the ground. Apologies to Ludwig but I reckon our structure works better with the 2 Ruckmen in.
                  Yes, they did alright against Baby Huey, but let's see how they go against a real ruckman on Friday.

                  Comment

                  • Mel
                    Regular in the Side
                    • Jul 2005
                    • 883

                    What a cracking day! We got to the ground even earlier than usual due to the members' recognition event, got the VW free parking and then ran into Buddy on his way to the ground. I thought I was past my whole Swans fangirl thing now that some of the players are old enough to be my kids, but no. I was totally star struck and could barely squeak out "Good luck!". The kids refused to come with me to ask for a photo and I felt a bit awkard asking myself so I missed out Quite surprised by how svelte Lance is up close. He looks a lot burlier in his guernsey and on tele.

                    The Member's event was quite good. Teddy and Mike Pyke were interviewed (LRT was supposed to be there but was running late) and Teddy was good value as always. Unfortunately they weren't there for long as they had to get ready for the legends match. A couple of the younger lads were interviewed too; Darcy Cameron and I didn't catch the other player's name as I was on my way to the ladies. After the event we headed down past the cricket nets and noticed all the players for the legends match warming up. We hung about to hear the pep talk given by Roosy (made some quip about having Heath James on his list for 18 years and only playing two games in that time ) and by Micky O and Teddy warning everybody to beware of Bazza's elbows, even if he was actually on their team.

                    Headed up to our seats and enjoyed a lovely, stress free game. We braved the field after the match for kick to kick. The kids managed a few goals and amazingly managed to keep their footballs. We all got away without copping a footy to the back of the head and managed not to lose the kids (it's happened before). We were a cheery little group on the drive home. One of the most enjoyable days of football I've had in a long while
                    Life's not a spectator sport

                    Comment

                    • Go Swannies
                      Veterans List
                      • Sep 2003
                      • 5697

                      It was a very relaxed day in the sunshine on Saturday.

                      Two things I took from the game: the team are playing with a confident fluidity that I haven't seen for a few years. I remember thinking the same in 2005 and later hearing Roos say that there was a practice session when they lifted to another level and knew they could go the whole way.

                      The other thought was just how well Towers and Sinclair are playing. Sure they make mistakes but they do a lot right, too. Towers took a couple of great grabs on Saturday and Sinclair's second efforts were great. There was one point down the Ranwick end when the ball was in dispute and Sinclair got the ball out of the ground and along the ground to a Swans payer in the clear.

                      I think the team are really coming to believe in each other and that's why Joey wasn't as missed as I thought he'd be. If you told me a month ago that we'd go to Geelong with Joey out and Towers in and come away with a convincing win I'd not believe you.

                      Roll on Friday.

                      Of course, for the media the Crows beat the Dons and it shows their superiority but we thrash Freo and it shows how woeful Freo is. I wonder how it'll be reported if we manage to win in Adelaide: "Crows night off?"

                      Comment

                      • aardvark
                        Veterans List
                        • Mar 2010
                        • 5685

                        Originally posted by dimelb
                        We refer to them as the two ruckmen, and they obviously are, but each of them, especially Sinkers, has been working on their forward 50 play. Tippett's work there has always been decent, often good, but Sinkers has stepped up big time in that role. To watch him rise and seize the ball against good opposition is thrilling stuff, and he is often close enough to make goal kicking easier. Considerable improvement there.
                        Sinkers last 2-3 months have been good. His effort levels, attitude and skills improvement have been significant. Although there are probably others more skillful he deserves to be rewarded for his efforts in my opinion. I had no time for him early in the season but he is fast becoming one of my faves.

                        Comment

                        • mcs
                          Travelling Swannie!!
                          • Jul 2007
                          • 8166

                          Originally posted by aardvark
                          Sinkers last 2-3 months have been good. His effort levels, attitude and skills improvement have been significant. Although there are probably others more skillful he deserves to be rewarded for his efforts in my opinion. I had no time for him early in the season but he is fast becoming one of my faves.
                          I agree on all but one point aardvark - which is attitude/efforts His effort and attitude have always been very good - irrespective of his broader form or where he might be in the pecking order, he always has a real dig and gives 110%.

                          He is a really good clubman, and he always busts a gut, no matter where he may be at - great to see him have a sustained period of good form to go with it. The ruck question is going to be a tough one heading into finals if Naismith is fit again soon.
                          "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

                          Comment

                          • Mel_C
                            Veterans List
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 4470

                            Originally posted by Go Swannies

                            Roll on Friday.

                            Of course, for the media the Crows beat the Dons and it shows their superiority but we thrash Freo and it shows how woeful Freo is. I wonder how it'll be reported if we manage to win in Adelaide: "Crows night off?"
                            I'm sure they will say that Sloane and Walker weren't fit.

                            I know we like to stay under the radar but it would be nice if we were spoken about and not just the whole 0-6 narrative.

                            Comment

                            • Markwebbos
                              Veterans List
                              • Jul 2016
                              • 7186

                              Originally posted by Mel_C
                              I'm sure they will say that Sloane and Walker weren't fit.

                              I know we like to stay under the radar but it would be nice if we were spoken about and not just the whole 0-6 narrative.
                              Happy to be ignored until we win the Premiership

                              Comment

                              • jono2707
                                Goes up to 11
                                • Oct 2007
                                • 3326

                                Originally posted by Markwebbos
                                Happy to be ignored until we win the Premiership
                                Except pretty much every finals analysis of the last month or two has included a 'the Swans are coming - be very afraid' type narrative.

                                Comment

                                Working...