2019 trading, drafting and list management: players and personnel

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Go Swannies
    Veterans List
    • Sep 2003
    • 5697

    Question. With so many retirements this year we are going to be cashed up. Does the mean we have to spend it all on current and some new players or can we stockpile some for when a catch like Buddy (Tippett?) next appears?

    Comment

    • Ludwig
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2007
      • 9359

      We have a lot of players, quite a few recently drafted, who can play small/medium forward or defender, flankers and the like. But many are crying out for more depth in the midfield.

      Heeney is great tackler, besides his many other elite attributes. But his kicking can be inconsistent, especially for goal. Put him in the midfield.

      Need a big bodied midfielder? Why not Dawson. Can't decide where his best position lies? Play him in the midfield. He was a great inside mid in the reserves. Covers a lot of ground and racks us plenty of tackles as well.

      Make as sweetheart deal for Richmond's Mabior Chol. Rotate Chol and Aliir through the ruck and key defence. The dynamic Sudanese duo will be pure excitement and a real crowd draw. We can also trade off all our other ruckmen, creating plenty of list and cap space. Maybe keep 1, in case of injury.

      Comment

      • Auntie.Gerald
        Veterans List
        • Oct 2009
        • 6474

        For me re Dawson :

        It is his capacity to influence the game by foot that is his greatest attribute.....he is brilliant short and long kicking

        Let’s be honest when you play with a guy like hike you get on your bike no matter what and lead hard

        That type of kicking ability makes you want to to a mark and put in the massive yards to run

        I like his swing ability at HBF and HFF for now as it contributes most effectively to our team performance
        "be tough, only when it gets tough"

        Comment

        • bloodspirit
          Clubman
          • Apr 2015
          • 4448

          Originally posted by liz
          I've often wondered to myself (and sometimes out loud to friends) which current Swan you would clone if you had the choice of just one.

          Buddy? So that you can always have one on the ground while the other recovers from ailments? (And imagine if they were both fit at the same time!)

          Heeney? To eliminate the question of whether his best position is in the midfield or up forward. I want him in both places.

          Aliir? Against some kinds of ruckman he's proved himself to be a very effective roving type ruckman, and with limited experience in that role. Imagine how good he could become with more practice. But that robs him from his pivotal role in defence. What if he could have two?

          Or, as you say, Dawson, who seems equipped to play almost every role on the ground (and he has even pinch hit in the ruck at times). He has the instincts of a crumbing small forward but can also roost them from outside 50. He has the height to become a Yeo style midfielder. But he also offers plenty rebounding from defence, with his strong overhead ability and pinpoint long kicking skills.

          Not an easy choice.
          Don't forget Blakey! So versatile and that versatility should improve as he gets stronger.
          All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)

          Comment

          • rojo
            Opti-pessi-misti
            • Mar 2009
            • 1102

            Just heard Matthew Lloyd say: ,'When Carlton get Coniglio and Papley ....'.(AFL.com). I won't believe that until I see it! That would be up there with us losing Mummy and Mitchell!

            Comment

            • Ralph Dawg
              Senior Player
              • Apr 2018
              • 1729

              Originally posted by rojo
              Just heard Matthew Lloyd say: ,'When Carlton get Coniglio and Papley ....'.(AFL.com). I won't believe that until I see it! That would be up there with us losing Mummy and Mitchell!
              Nothing less a first round pick otherwise the Blues can get stuffed. As stated by many here, you have to pay oversto get a player who's in contract.

              - - - Updated - - -

              And club should not cave if he says he's homesick. He can see out his contract like Tim Kelly if Carlton don't give us a first rounder. Happy for him to do that in the NEAFL if he has a dummy spit.

              Comment

              • waswan
                Senior Player
                • Oct 2015
                • 2047

                2 1st Rounders for Paps or see out your contract then we can still play hard ball or he enters the PS draft

                We need to keep him and Jones, 2 young guys hitting the right amount of games and age

                Comment

                • bloodspirit
                  Clubman
                  • Apr 2015
                  • 4448

                  Originally posted by Ralph Dawg
                  Nothing less a first round pick otherwise the Blues can get stuffed. As stated by many here, you have to pay oversto get a player who's in contract.

                  - - - Updated - - -

                  And club should not cave if he says he's homesick. He can see out his contract like Tim Kelly if Carlton don't give us a first rounder. Happy for him to do that in the NEAFL if he has a dummy spit.
                  I agree but with a caveat depending on his reasons. Say, for example, some important, close family member has a terminal illness and he wants to be close to them then I would still want fair compensation but not that we play overly hardball.
                  All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)

                  Comment

                  • Industrial Fan
                    Goodesgoodesgoodesgoodes!
                    • Aug 2006
                    • 3317

                    All these Papley rumours sound like total and complete nonsense to me
                    He ate more cheese, than time allowed

                    Comment

                    • longmile
                      Crumber
                      • Apr 2011
                      • 3362

                      Originally posted by Industrial Fan
                      All these Papley rumours sound like total and complete nonsense to me
                      I hope so, he's probably my favourite player atm and I'd be devastated if he left. I think the rumours are big enough now to warrant him coming forward and quashing them.

                      Say it aint so Tom!

                      Comment

                      • dejavoodoo44
                        Veterans List
                        • Apr 2015
                        • 8515

                        Originally posted by rojo
                        Just heard Matthew Lloyd say: ,'When Carlton get Coniglio and Papley ....'.(AFL.com). I won't believe that until I see it! That would be up there with us losing Mummy and Mitchell!
                        I tend to have the same opinion of media statements by Lloyd, as I had of his appeals for free kicks.

                        Comment

                        • Melbourne_Blood
                          Senior Player
                          • May 2010
                          • 3312

                          Originally posted by rojo
                          Just heard Matthew Lloyd say: ,'When Carlton get Coniglio and Papley ....'.(AFL.com). I won't believe that until I see it! That would be up there with us losing Mummy and Mitchell!
                          I just watched it , he said “ if they can land Coniglio and Papley” . Little bit different. It’s not news the Blues are into both of them.


                          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                          Comment

                          • Nico
                            Veterans List
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 11332

                            Originally posted by Melbourne_Blood
                            I just watched it , he said “ if they can land Coniglio and Papley” . Little bit different. It’s not news the Blues are into both of them.


                            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                            Both clubs would want a first round pick. How do Carlton conjure up that. If things follow the off season form guide Coniglio goes to Hawthorn.
                            http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

                            Comment

                            • rojo
                              Opti-pessi-misti
                              • Mar 2009
                              • 1102

                              Thanks for the correction MB. I didn't intend to overstate what M Lloyd said, I either misheard or remembered mistakenly. It did sound ominous when I heard it though as it seemed to give weight to the recent chatter.

                              Comment

                              • ugg
                                Can you feel it?
                                Site Admin
                                • Jan 2003
                                • 15963

                                Originally posted by Nico
                                Both clubs would want a first round pick. How do Carlton conjure up that. If things follow the off season form guide Coniglio goes to Hawthorn.
                                Coniglio is a restricted free agent so the Carlton (or the Hawks) could sign him to a big enough contract that the Giants can't afford to match and it won't cost them a thing in terms of players or picks.
                                Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                                Reserves WIKI -
                                Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                                Comment

                                Working...