2019 trading, drafting and list management: players and personnel

[Thunder Shaker]

Not sure I’d have Dahlhaus and S. Selwood in the same sentence as Danger ...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Perhaps not, but the general point remains the same - only the Swans have ever been penalised for trading.

[longmile]

Word on the streets is that Cameron will likely request a trade to the Pies.

Wonder what the Pies will do with the big Cox?

[MattW]

Good news, I think: we won't trade pick 4 for Daniher. What will Swans give up for Joe? It won't be pick No.4 - What will Swans give up for Joe? It won't be pick No.4 - AFL.com.au

So, the question for the Bombers is whether they think they'll get more free agency compensation next year than what we would offer in a trade this year.

[Thunder Shaker]

Word on the streets is that Cameron will likely request a trade to the Pies.

Wonder what the Pies will do with the big Cox?

Suppose he does. What would Collingwood offer? They have picks 35, 53, 64 and 71. I expect we may make a token trade (perhaps pick 53) to allow Cameron to move to Collingwood for more opportunities. He's only played one game so don't expect more than that.

[Markwebbos]

Good news, I think: we won't trade pick 4 for Daniher. What will Swans give up for Joe? It won't be pick No.4 - What will Swans give up for Joe? It won't be pick No.4 - AFL.com.au

So, the question for the Bombers is whether they think they'll get more free agency compensation next year than what we would offer in a trade this year.

They’d probably get an end of first rounder for him, so we’d have to offer more. I suggested a while back that the pick that’s been discussed for Papley (7 or 8) might get the deal done, with another lower pick thrown in.

[Captain]

If he stays at the Bombers next year then I can't see him ever leaving.

They will make up, his groin will improve and he will enjoy playing footy again.

It's now or never for us and Joey.

[Melbourne_Blood]

They’d probably get an end of first rounder for him, so we’d have to offer more. I suggested a while back that the pick that’s been discussed for Papley (7 or 8) might get the deal done, with another lower pick thrown in.

Perhaps what pick ( late first round should be the requirement ) we get for Jones ( pending saints creativity ) , our pick 23 and maybe Darcy Cameron , or the pick we get for him ? They are in the market for a ruckman , forget the pies . We Keep Papley and our first pick .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[longmile]

Under no circumstances would I trade Papley. Even if he wanted to leave I'd hold him to his contract. Good small forwards are invaluable. Not only that but he seems to be the future heart and soul of bloods culture. Might sound wanky but he plays in a way that shows he's passionate about the club and comadery. I can't see him wanting to leave either but all this chat has made me nervous.

Daniher is overrated. Good player but so was Tippett. Tippett was okay and did some good things but in the end wasn't worth what we paid and daniher feels exactly the same

[troyjones2525]

Jones to saints
Stevens to cats
Constable to us

?

Would love this to happen. I reckon Constable could turn into JPK Mk2 if given oppourtunity.

Sent from my SM-G977B using Tapatalk

[waswan]

Dont want to trade Paps but if we have 2 smalls next year and maybe Serong this year, that is a very short portion of the 22.

Say it aint so but unfortunately starting to appear there is something in it

[S.S. Bleeder]

Pick 4 for for Hopper at GWS
Salary squeeze

Worth a shot. He's worth it.

[S.S. Bleeder]

A Swans supporter as well. Wonder if he'll still be there at pick 5/6?

Picks shaping up to be 1,2 GC Rowell & Anderson, 3 Dees a player with speed, 4 Crows a player with speed, 5 GWS Green, 6 swans

I think he will. GCS will obviously take Rowell and Anderson. I can see Demons and the Crows taking Young and Ash. I'd be tempted to take Kemp ahead of Serong but his knee is a concern. A year off the field could mean that he might not play seniors until 2022 once he finds his form again.

[S.S. Bleeder]

Word on the streets is that Cameron will likely request a trade to the Pies.

Wonder what the Pies will do with the big Cox?

I thought he nominated Collingwood a week ago?

We don't need Big Cox, we already have Horse.

[sharp9]

We have bigger (well, fatter) Cox already!

[S.S. Bleeder]

Suppose he does. What would Collingwood offer? They have picks 35, 53, 64 and 71. I expect we may make a token trade (perhaps pick 53) to allow Cameron to move to Collingwood for more opportunities. He's only played one game so don't expect more than that.

Try to get Sier involved. Cameron and a 2nd rounder for Sier.