But it must come to a point where recycling "senior" coaches comes to a tipping point. Examples are Walls and Pagan where they produced nothing in the end. I think Teague has a better chance of success, as I see it North has a fair bit of rebuilding to do. To me Melbourne is the club that is in all sorts of strife. Their expressionless coach doesn't inspire no matter how much of a good bloke he is. Once the Roos factor ebbed away their demise was swift.
#AFL Round 22 Weekly Discussion Thread
Collapse
X
-
-
Dees drop down has been dramatic. Surely they’ll go better next year. You wonder if our 2017 season could have gone the same way?Comment
-
Teague to be officially appointed senior coach of Carlton. The 'training wheels' are off!
From caretaker to full-time: Teague to be named Blues coach - AFL.com.auComment
-
2018 End of H&A.. Melb 5th, Sydney 6th
2019 20 rounds: Melbourne 17th (-12). Sydney 15th (-9)Comment
-
Nah. We limped into finals and were blown away in the first week after an abject showing and were widely tipped to fall out of the 8 this year. Melbourne stormed to a prelim before being shown the door and were regarded as being a flag contender this year and coming into their prime. The numbers you've selected don't tell the whole story.All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
Heard Jarry Roughead's retirement press conference this morning & glad he is getting a farewell game this weekend. He mentioned his favourite footy moment which gave him the most pleasure, was the bone crunching tackle he laid on Daniel Hannebery at the start of the 2014 GF, which signalled their intent to revenge their 2012 GF loss to us. Hawks supporters then ringing up saying it was a memorable moment they haven't forgotten. Hanners was definitely a targeted man by the Hawks.
He hung back and waited until the player who actually went and got the ball was totally unprotected and he then crunched a player who couldn't defend himself. Such a hero.Comment
-
All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
I think Teague and Shaw could be fools gold.
What this Saga has told me is that having a coach fighting for his job ( like Bolton and Scott) is the worst sort of coach, as they are defensive, conservative and it rubs off on the players.
Any coach is better, so the caretakers look good. But are they the best available?Comment
-
Nah. We limped into finals and were blown away in the first week after an abject showing and were widely tipped to fall out of the 8 this year. Melbourne stormed to a prelim before being shown the door and were regarded as being a flag contender this year and coming into their prime. The numbers you've selected don't tell the whole story.
Melbourne 2019 is what you expect from Melbourne (2018 is the only outlier)
Sydney 2018 is what you expect from Sydney (2019 is the only outlier)
- - - Updated - - -
My point is, a caretaker coach is chosen from a list of 2 or 3 candidates (usually assistant coaches at the same club)
A senior coaching appointment is taken from all possible candidates.
If you take a look at this site: http://sportandhistory.com/research/...ercoaches.html You wont see many caretakers who went on to be house-hold names (bare a few rare exceptions).Comment
-
To be honest, I think your sentences sound like vic-centric media beat up. Vic-club=good. Northern-club=bad. The numbers dont lie.
Melbourne 2019 is what you expect from Melbourne (2018 is the only outlier)
Sydney 2018 is what you expect from Sydney (2019 is the only outlier)
- - - Updated - - -
Punch on, barry.All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
Looks like the biggest crowd the Lions have had for quite a while. Usually the upper deck on the right of the screen is closed. Today there's plenty of people up there. Hopefully they'll enjoy a Lions win.Comment
Comment