Rule changes don’t count / are wrong if they negatively impact big Melbourne clubs. I’m just glad we don’t have to listen to the former Pies president anymore.
Match thread: Prelim final; Swans v Magpies.
Collapse
X
-
-
Looked at the replay for a second time. Pies supporters can't complain about the umpires. Jack Crisp got caught 5 times and wasn't pinged once. In the last minute he ran across the back of the square, got tackled and threw the ball away one handed. Yet JR got pinged when he had the ball for a nano second. Still can't see why Jmac had that mark taken off him. By the way he found form in a big way.
Also loved the way Braeden Campbell had a red hot go.
Also on SEN today they said we shut up shop in the last quarter. I don't agree. We had our chances to seal it and looked to always move the ball forward. May be the last couple of minutes we did. A couple of crucial errors let them in. Gulden's hooked kick to Quaynor and Heeney's brain fade after he took a mark. He didn't need to play on quickly and slipped over.Comment
-
(But some of the fault was with Bud calling for the ball rather than directing Campbell to kick it long, or even have a shot on goal. )Comment
-
I imagine there's an entire unit in the Longmire curriculum on when to ignore Buddy's calls for the ball.Comment
-
All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
He did seem a bit off the pace, but it will be invaluable experience for him if he is the medical sub this weekend, and in his future career.Comment
-
FWIW, I thought it was no coincidence that McInerney's best game for a while coincided with that the re-emergence of the hint of a mullet tail. May it sprout greatly this week.'Delicious' is a fun word to sayComment
-
- - - Updated - - -
[QUOTE=dejavoodoo44;857737]Coaches votes for the game.
8 Jack Crisp (COLL)
8 Callum Mills (SYD)
5 Luke Parker (SYD)
3 Tom Papley (SYD)
3 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Darcy Moore (COLL)
1 Lance Franklin (SYD)
Bit surprised that Errol didn't get a few votes, since Channel 7 gave him their MVP award. Then again, despite his excellent last quarter, I was a bit surprised that they did that.
[COLOR="silver"]- - - Updated - - -[/
Totally agree about Crisp. He smashed us. Very surprised that Hickey did not rate.Thought he was terrific..again.Comment
-
Did you see what’s happened to Mitch Robinson after they cut off his rat tail?Comment
-
Heeney being tackled from behind when going for a mark 20m in front of goal was one of the poorer non-decisions. Last qtr I think.Comment
-
2nd quarter. No replays during coverage. Forgotten incident amongst all the garbage about poor umpiring decisions. There were 10 hands in the back by the Pies - not one paid (& that was just in the 1st quarter).
Heeney being tackled from behind when going for a mark 20m in front of goal was one of the poorer non-decisions. Last qtr I think.Comment
-
Was it just me, or was Cox falling in the back of Mills (leading directly to Elliot’s 1st goal) a more blatant free kick? That was a “great play” according to commentary.Comment
-
I'm sure if we wind back further there were plenty of other non or close calls either way. The focus on the Papley one is just Melbourne media mafia being Melbourne media mafia.'Delicious' is a fun word to sayComment
-
In regards to the free against McInerney: you more or less have to slow the vision down to see it, but his hand tralis along the Collingwood player's shoulder and makes glancing contact to the neck. So I assume that it was for high contact. Absolutely minimal force, and nothing like the unpunished mauling that Buddy copped pretty well every time he went near the ball. The blocking, the grabbing, the front on contact and the genuine whacks to the head.Comment
Comment