From Adelaide (lived in Sydney since 1968), however happy for gutsy Giants, not easy to win there .
Round 18: the other games. You just keep me hanging on.
Collapse
X
-
-
Haven't seen any of the game, but I suspect that Hawthorn kicking 3-13 during the first half, indoors at Marvel, will be driving their fans insane.Comment
-
Since typing that, Hawthorn have kicked 9-3. So I guess that means that North are even more crap than I thought they were?Comment
-
Rosebury umpired his 500th game this weekend, becoming only the second field umpire to umpire 500 games.
Buddy's 13, drawn GF, Demolition Derby: Top ump's wild ride to 500"Unbelievable!" -- Nick Davis leaves his mark on the 2005 semi finalComment
-
Rosebury umpired his 500th game this weekend, becoming only the second field umpire to umpire 500 games.
Buddy's 13, drawn GF, Demolition Derby: Top ump's wild ride to 500"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
Comment
-
24 years as a field umpire is a long time. Some current players had not been born when Rosebury started umpiring. Paul Kelly was still playing, and Plugger had just retired for the first time. The 21st century was still in the future. Remarkable."Unbelievable!" -- Nick Davis leaves his mark on the 2005 semi finalComment
-
Tend to agree although he was one of the umpires in the 2012 GF where it is sometimes forgotten that we got hosed in terms of the free kick count IIRC. Winning erases all blame!Comment
-
That's true, though unlike 2016, I never felt the umpires were stacked against us that day. They probably missed one or two, but you don't have the dark memory hole of specific and blatant instances like the bad one called against Rampe or the non-call on that dog Easton Wood for what he did to Hanners, or the McLean-Jack incident that should have gone our way and was instead given to them with a 50 thrown on top.'Delicious' is a fun word to sayComment
-
In 2012, the Dirty Nappies received 21 free kicks and the brave, magnificent Bloods only got 10!
Comment
-
Pure free kick counts are meaningless.
In 2016 we were totally screwed - actual errors from the umpires and at crucial times that changed the momentum of the entire match on multiple occasions. Cost us the game.
In 2012, the umpiring was pretty good. Yes the Hawks won more free kicks but that doesn't mean they were wrong. It was a cracking game and if we lost, it wouldn't have been the umpires fault.Comment
-
Pure free kick counts are meaningless.
In 2016 we were totally screwed - actual errors from the umpires and at crucial times that changed the momentum of the entire match on multiple occasions. Cost us the game.
In 2012, the umpiring was pretty good. Yes the Hawks won more free kicks but that doesn't mean they were wrong. It was a cracking game and if we lost, it wouldn't have been the umpires fault.Comment
Comment