Midaro's List Analysis (1-20)

[TheMase]

Originally posted by Nico

He was recruited as a midfielder and there is no reason why he could not develop into a quality midfielder, and if you watch him he is spending more time in the midfield, then pushing into the forward line. Leaving space for Hall, Davis, Micky but chiming in with goals from receives.

I am glad someone else noticed this! I think he'd make an EXCELLENT midfielder!

[BAM_BAM]

Originally posted by TheMase
I am glad someone else noticed this! I think he'd make an EXCELLENT midfielder!

yep and maybe someone will take notice of what I've been saying for the past 2 years ...... oh but wait. I'm the groupie who only notices his looks so any imput I have regarding him is discredited and ignored.

oh well that's my 15 seconds on the soap box

[Ruda Wakening]

Originally posted by BAM_BAM
yep and maybe someone will take notice of what I've been saying for the past 2 years ...... oh but wait. I'm the groupie who only notices his looks so any imput I have regarding him is discredited and ignored.

Nevermind Bam Bam. I remember a time not that long ago when there was hardly anyone else in the "weak one, soft one, he who doesn't apply himself" fan club

[Scottee]

I think all the analysis has been great on this thread but personally I think the trade oppotunities might be limited to McVeigh.

The approach that would be taken in my opinion is to increase the turnover of players who havn't shown enough to date. I think that the turnover would come from the following candidates:

Sunny-(not convinced he's got the goods)

James- as someone said, can't work below the knees.He would be playing in the seniors now if he was good enough.

MJ-dificult one, but likely if Ball plays for another year. Has not from reports shone in the ressies.

Fixter-seems to have real injury proneness. Medicos need to advise on his chances.

Hunt -will go

Warfe-will go.

I would only consider any of these players and a draft pick for McVeigh. Good luck to anyone who takes them. Young talent is still the answer.

That's 6 off the list. Enough to work in some talented youngsters and keep valuable players like O'Keefe and Matthews. We need players with a bit of BMI, it would be crazy to trade either IMHO.

[swansrule100]

Originally posted by BAM_BAM
yep and maybe someone will take notice of what I've been saying for the past 2 years ...... oh but wait. I'm the groupie who only notices his looks so any imput I have regarding him is discredited and ignored.

oh well that's my 15 seconds on the soap box

lol
i think ur opinions are pretty spot on week after week

[Bleed Red Blood]

Originally posted by Scottee
I think all the analysis has been great on this thread but personally I think the trade oppotunities might be limited to McVeigh.

The approach that would be taken in my opinion is to increase the turnover of players who havn't shown enough to date. I think that the turnover would come from the following candidates:

Sunny-(not convinced he's got the goods)

James- as someone said, can't work below the knees.He would be playing in the seniors now if he was good enough.

MJ-dificult one, but likely if Ball plays for another year. Has not from reports shone in the ressies.

Fixter-seems to have real injury proneness. Medicos need to advise on his chances.

Hunt -will go

Warfe-will go.

I would only consider any of these players and a draft pick for McVeigh. Good luck to anyone who takes them. Young talent is still the answer.

That's 6 off the list. Enough to work in some talented youngsters and keep valuable players like O'Keefe and Matthews. We need players with a bit of BMI, it would be crazy to trade either IMHO.

I agree with all this, except for James, he obviously has something, and played well earlier in the year.

[swansrule100]

Originally posted by Bleed Red Blood
I agree with all this, except for James, he obviously has something, and played well earlier in the year.

yeh he has something...but he has the worst body in the world!

[punter257]

i would hate to b the one making a decision on his future

[midaro]

Originally posted by punter257
i would hate to b the one making a decision on his future

Agree. It's one of the reasons I'm torn about trading.
IMO the key to longterm success is to build from within (just keep to the minimum 3 draft picks - limited trading).
But this year, we may end up delisting some considerable talent for no gain due to the list limits.
If we can trade 2/3 good-average players + draft picks, for one exceptional player, this would be the year to do it.

[Nico]

McVeigh shows enormous talent and smarts. Will be a quality midfielder very soon. No way he would be traded. Falls into the future leadership group with O"Keefe.

[BAM_BAM]

Originally posted by swansrule100
lol
i think ur opinions are pretty spot on week after week

thanks "Babe"