Our Best 5 players (Past)

[Wazza]

The best swans players I have seen play.

G. Williams
T. Lockett
B. Mitchell
P. Kelly
P. Roos
Carter/Dunkley

The best AFL players I have seen play Not including Swans

W. Carey
G. Ablett
J. Platten
T. Lockett
M. Riccutio / T. Watson

[Ajn]

Five Best Swans Players of All Time

1. Bob Skilton
2. Paul Kelly
3. Bob Pratt
4. Laurie Nash
5. Greg Williams

Best Five Swans players in my time (1988 onwards)

1. Paul Kelly
2. Greg Williams
3. Gerard Healy
4. Tony Lockett
5. Andrew Dunkley (backbone to our success in this period)

Best Five VFL/AFL Players in my time (1988 Onwards)

1. Gary Ablett
2. Wayne Carey
3. Paul Kelly
4. Tony Lockett
5. Jason Dunstall

[bigdaz]

My top 5 Swans in my time as a serious Supporter(1996 - )

1) P Kelly
2) T Lockett
3) A Dunkley
4) P Roos
5) A Goodes/M O'Loughlin (Too hard to split them)

Hounorable Mentions.

D Kickett, J Bolton, D Creswell, B Hall.

Top 5 Opposition Players in my time

1) W Carey (Ouch that hurts! )
2) J Dunstall
3) G Ablett
4) J Hird
5) M Lloyd (Double Ouch! )

[Rob-bloods]

Originally posted by cressakel
How could I forget Bayes' front teeth being knocked out in his earlier days playing a Reserves game at The Lake Oval on a Sunday and also that dog Craig Kelly ripping Bayes' shoulder from the socket at Vic Park in front of the Feral Toothless Members....

Bayes beating Kernahan on a regular basis also springs from this selective mind....

Craig Kelly knocked Bayes's teeth out, I thought, are you mixing it up or me?

[BayesysLeftBoot]

Mid 80's onward:

1) Paul Kelly
2) Tony Lockett
3) Greg Williams
4) Mark Bayes
5) Paul Roos or Barry Round

Oposition:
1) Carey
2) Ablett
3) Hird
4) Dunstall
5) Brereton

[swan_song]

Originally posted by robbieando
Five Best Swans Players of All Time

1. Bob Skilton
2. Laurie Nash
3. Bob Pratt
4. John Rantall
5. Paul Kelly

Best Five Swans players in my time (1988 onwards)

1. Paul Kelly
2. Tony Lockett
3. Mark Bayes
4. Greg Williams
5. Barry Mitchell

Best Five VFL/AFL Players in my time (1988 Onwards)

1. Gary Ablett
2. Robert Harvey
3. Paul Kelly
4. Tony Lockett
5. Jason Dunstall

My five Best Swannies in my time in Sydney (1987 onwards)
1 Greg WIlliams
2 Gerard Healy
3 Tony Lockett
4 Paul Kelly
5 Warwick Capper (just kidding) Daryn Cresswell



My best Swannies of all time
1 Bob Skilton
2 Laurie Nash
3 Tony Lockett
4 Paul Kelly
5 Daryn Cresswell


Best AFL/VFL players I've seen "live"
1 Tony Lockett
2 Gary Ablett
3 Greg Williams
4 Wayne Carey
5 Michael Voss

[Big Al]

Best Sydney Swans players in my time 1982 onwards

1. Tony Lockett - unstoppable at his best
2. Paul Kelly - most couragous player ever
3. Greg Williams - Best hands
4. Gerard Healy - skillful and tough
5. Barry Round - imposing presence

Honourable mention to Steve Wright who always did the hard stuff