Chambers, Matthews, Richards dumped

[ScottH]

Originally posted by goswannie14
Funny thing is I thought Torture had just played his best game for the Swans so far on Saturday night, not that that is saying much.

Precisely, his best is not that great.

[stellation]

It'll be hard to find enough time for Doyle/Chambers/Shaw to get a chance to impress rucking in the magoos (kind of lucky Ericksen is out).

[Ruck'n'Roll]

E. Shaw

[ScottH]

Originally posted by Ruck'n'Roll
E. Shaw

I think RnR just had a triple O!

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by ScottH
I think RnR just had a triple O!

ROFLMAO

[dendol]

"For Ted and Paul, it is get back, play some really good footy and get some continuity of game time."

Since its impossible for these two to play even half decent footy, can we reasonably assume we wont see them back this year?

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by dendol
Since its impossible for these two to play even half decent footy, can we reasonably assume we wont see them back this year?

That's a bit harsh, would you want to take one of them on in a footy match?

[dread and might]

Originally posted by goswannie14
That's a bit harsh, would you want to take one of them on in a footy match?

Wrong reasoning. We are not AFL players. They are not performing at the level required.

Goodes into the ruck??

[Plugger46]

Originally posted by liz
One might think that after you repeatedly declared Schneider to be a soft and complete dud, only to retract your conclusion not so long ago, you might hold off for a while and actually watch to see how Bevan has developed before completely writing him off.

Good call.

Bevo was a bit disappointing last season, but I'm not prepared to write him off yet. He was pretty good in his debut year.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by Plugger46
Good call.

Bevo was a bit disappointing last season, but I'm not prepared to write him off yet. He was pretty good in his debut year.

How many people wanted to give him the #14 jumper a couple of years ago, and delist him last year?


On the w/e the paper had a list of players on their last legs at each club.

Ours were

Doyle
Spriggs
Vogels.

The first two I agree with but I hope Vogels can take his oppotunity and prove he is worth keeping.

[liz]

Originally posted by ScottH
How many people wanted to give him the #14 jumper a couple of years ago, and delist him last year?


On the w/e the paper had a list of players on their last legs at each club.

Ours were

Doyle
Spriggs
Vogels.

The first two I agree with but I hope Vogels can take his oppotunity and prove he is worth keeping.

There are probably a dozen players (including some of the current rookies and some yet-to-debuts) that I would prefer to see leave before Vogels. As far as KPP depth goes, he is pretty much "it" at the moment.

I wonder if Spriggs (and also Willoughby) have already been told they won't be here next year and that they won't be considered for senior selection. On form alone, both deserve to be at least mentioned in dispatches of those pressing for selection yet their names have been curiously absent.

[stellation]

Originally posted by ScottH
How many people wanted to give him the #14 jumper a couple of years ago, and delist him last year?


On the w/e the paper had a list of players on their last legs at each club.

Ours were

Doyle
Spriggs
Vogels.

The first two I agree with but I hope Vogels can take his oppotunity and prove he is worth keeping.

I'm pretty sure that article was more suggesting Vogels may have to look for opportunities elsewhere as he should be a first team player.

[floppinab]

Originally posted by Benevolent Ert
In: Bell, Longmuir, Polak, Webster, Murphy, Hayden, Drum
Out: Sandilands (inj), McPharlin (ankle), Duffield (inj), Haddrill (knee), Walker, Medhurst, Schammer
New: Drum

7 changes!!!!!! It's going to be an interesting Sat. night.

And lay off Bevo, he's a local product, something we need more of and deserves at least a handful of senior games to find his feet again. By all means lay in if after that he hasn't performed but at least give him a chance........ all of you!!!!

[dread and might]

Who is going to ruck along with Longmuir. Johnson?

[Jeffers1984]

Originally posted by dread and might
Who is going to ruck along with Longmuir. Johnson?

Polhack.