22 to start Rnd 1

[swantastic]

Barry Playfair Richards
B2 Kennelly B1
Malceski Kirk Mattner
O'Keefe Hall Schmidt
O'Loughlin White Davis

Jolly Buchanan Goodes

Everitt Mathews Bird Grundy

If we start with this team, i'd be VERY happy!

Why it wont happen,for 1 thing Playfair is a forward and give me Laidlaw over Grundy.Tiger at CHB no way and B1 HBF no again.Wheres Schmidt and Cheese?

[The Big Cat]

Matthews, Barry, Richards
Malceski, B2, Kennelly
Ablett, Kirk, Crouch
ROK, MOL, B1
Davis, Hall, McVeigh

Jolly, Fosdike, Buchanan

Int: Everett, LRT, Bevan, Vogals

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Why it wont happen,for 1 thing Playfair is a forward and give me Laidlaw over Grundy.Tiger at CHB no way and B1 HBF no again.Wheres Schmidt and Cheese?

Schmidt is there! and i forgot the Cheese, Gromit.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I edited mine slightly, thoughts now?

[Wazza]

I think Grundy may be tried in defence and I would have Fosdike in before Scmidt for the ealy rounds. Ablett has to be in the starting 18 probably one of our most under rated players IMHO. I was tossing up between Bevan and Brennan. I dont think you can play J Bolton Mathews and Ablett in the same team but Im tempted to squeeze Mathews onto the bench for his defensive role.

C Bolton Grundy Brennan
Kennelly LRT Barry
Malceski Kirk Mattner
Davis Hall O'Keefe
O'loughlin Playfair Buchanan

Everrit Goodes Ablett

Jolly Richards Barlow Fosdike / Mathews Scmidt Bevan Laidlaw White Jack


Cheers

Waz

[NMWBloods]

Why it wont happen,for 1 thing Playfair is a forward

Roos said that in passing, but all the Cats supporters say that he is a backman not a forward.

[connolly]

Bevan is less than 2" shorter than Jack and 7 kg lighter, and Jack is more than 2" taller and 7 kg heavier than Crouch, so Jack would have no problems in the back pocket.

Jack is 90 kilos?

[NMWBloods]

89kg.

[Triple B]

Jack is 90 kilos?

89kg.

Whilst I don't doubt that Jack may be 89kg, he is a very, very solid lad, basing arguments on data supplied by the heights and weights quoted on AFL.com is fraught with danger ie. they are often wildly inaccurate.

[ernie koala]

Matthews, Barry, Richards
Malceski, B2, Kennelly
Ablett, Kirk, Crouch
ROK, MOL, B1
Davis, Hall, McVeigh

Jolly, Fosdike, Buchanan

Int: Everett, LRT, Bevan, Vogals

Yeah right.....With the famous 4 included...Mathews, McVeigh,Bevan,Crouch..
No Goodes , no Mattner , no speed or skill on the wings............
NO CIGAR !!

[reigning premier]

Matthews, Barry, Richards
Malceski, B2, Kennelly
Ablett, Kirk, Crouch
ROK, MOL, B1
Davis, Hall, McVeigh

Jolly, Fosdike, Buchanan

Int: Everett, LRT, Bevan, Vogals

If that's a serious post....

Your credibility = Shot

[reigning premier]

F: McVeigh, MO'L, Sampi
HF: ROK, Hall, Davis
C: Mattner, Buchanan, Malceski
HB: LRT, Kenelly, Barry
FB: Bevan, Whitnall, Bolton

R: Goodes, Kirk, Jolly

Inter: Schmidt, Fosdike, Everitt, Barlow

Emerg: Richards, Jack, Brennan, Playfair

[Sanecow]

BS. Whitnall will be at FF.

[NMWBloods]

I think we'd get more value from finding a big forward to take marks deep in the forward line.

[reigning premier]

I think we'd get more value from finding a big forward to take marks deep in the forward line.

We do need one of them....

One that can kick as well might be handy.