Barry Hall to Bulldogs rumour

[goswannie14]

I think our forward line should be structured around Playfair at CHF, ROK out of the square, and possibly a tall (such as White or resting ruckman) in the square. I think also Grundy and Barlow should be tried - the former as FF and the latter as CHF. We also have other forward options without Hall - MOL is still useful in a pocket and if Davis comes back he would be another option a la Williams of Hawthorn. We have some useful crumbers too and Bevan would make a useful forward pocket to apply defensive pressure. We do need to stop putting J Bolton in the forward line.

I prefer Bevan up forward to down back.

[Wardy]

Didn't think showing passion was considered such a bad trait. But hey he is nothing but

Funny i feel the same way about Nick Davis, except Nick Davis is a serious waste of both time and talent and should have been slipping sherbies with the bra boys at "the surrey bra" and the other maggots who live at the shire, but alas he is being paid to do nothing and is taking up a spot on the list.

.

On behalf of all people from the Shire who are part of RWO - we feel the same way about you!!!

[swanage]

I wish i could somehow delete his image from my 2005 Premiership dvd collection. If only it was someone else and not him. god i can't stand at all, both as a person and a footballer. Zero respect and if i were too see him wasted slumped on a street i would nod my head and keep moving.

Wow you sound like a real charmer. Have you even met the bloke? Did he run off with your missus or something?

Thinking the guy is overrated is one thing, wishing him physical harm is another. What a rubbish post.

[Lakeside]

You could if you wanted to wait more than 72 years for a flag.

Again absurd notion that Davis should take the kudos for the 05 flag. Again if Ball hadn't contested the ball up..would his deft little tap found Nick Davis?

What about the other variables that contribute to that game?

Again the 05 flag was won by 22 guys not one, as much as the usual suspects would like to just credit Nick Davis for the win.

[Lakeside]

Wow you sound like a real charmer. Have you even met the bloke? Did he run off with your missus or something?

Thinking the guy is overrated is one thing, wishing him physical harm is another. What a rubbish post.

Did i say i wished physical harm on him? I didn't think "nod my head and keep walking" is considered as wishing physical harm on someone. Stop making up something that you wish i said.

And yes he is so overrated it makes me sick.

[Frog]

Again absurd notion that Davis should take the kudos for the 05 flag. Again if Ball hadn't contested the ball up..would his deft little tap found Nick Davis?

What about the other variables that contribute to that game?

Again the 05 flag was won by 22 guys not one, as much as the usual suspects would like to just credit Nick Davis for the win.

OK, so you are one-eyed, you are aiming all your vitriol in a single direction. How is this : The entire team, including Nick Davis, managed what, 4 or 5 goals to 3 quarter time? A spray from Kirk in the direction of Davis when the man Davis was minding kicked a goal, seemed to do the trick. All of a sudden we had a dangerous forward loose all over their paddock. He was hit 4 times, he scored 4 times, for 4 goals, as much as the whole team managed in 3 quarters. Davis deserves to be talked about and held in regard for giving us a shot at the flag that year - A shot that the team converted to our first in 72 years.

If not for Davis, what variables from the team do you think could have given us four goals in the quarter if that was all they could collectively manage for 3?

[573v30]

Back on topic... anyone going to boo Hall if he becomes a Bulldog?

[swanage]

if i were too see him wasted slumped on a street i would nod my head and keep moving.

Did i say i wished physical harm on him? I didn't think "nod my head and keep walking" is considered as wishing physical harm on someone. Stop making up something that you wish i said.

And yes he is so overrated it makes me sick.

A post in which you envisage someone in physical distress where you state you'd nod (presumably in approval) and do nothing to help.

Close enough.

Is an in depth discussion on semantics really what you enjoy doing?

[swanage]

Back on topic... anyone going to boo Hall if he becomes a Bulldog?

No. Well assuming he didn't punch one of our players that is

[goswannie14]

Again absurd notion that Davis should take the kudos for the 05 flag. Again if Ball hadn't contested the ball up..would his deft little tap found Nick Davis?

What about the other variables that contribute to that game?

Again the 05 flag was won by 22 guys not one, as much as the usual suspects would like to just credit Nick Davis for the win.

What is your problem? No sense of humour? Or no sense of reality?

BTW the other variables are that Davis kicked 4 out of 7 goals for the Swans, he also played what is felt by many to be the best ever qrtr of football in a final by an individual.

To me he is just another player, but that one qrtr of football will live on in my memory for ever, as will his feats of that night.

Again, you need to read posts before you respond. I never said it was all Nick Davis, just that without him we wouldn't have got further than the SF, so we would have waited more than 72 years for a flag.

[NMWBloods]

Again absurd notion that Davis should take the kudos for the 05 flag. Again if Ball hadn't contested the ball up..would his deft little tap found Nick Davis?

What about the other variables that contribute to that game?

Again the 05 flag was won by 22 guys not one, as much as the usual suspects would like to just credit Nick Davis for the win.

You don't seem to get it. Yes, every player is necessary for the win, but not sufficient. Without Davis' last quarter effort we quite simply would not have won.

[Industrial Fan]

I think our forward line should be structured around Playfair at CHF, ROK out of the square, and possibly a tall (such as White or resting ruckman) in the square. I think also Grundy and Barlow should be tried - the former as FF and the latter as CHF. We also have other forward options without Hall - MOL is still useful in a pocket and if Davis comes back he would be another option a la Williams of Hawthorn. We have some useful crumbers too and Bevan would make a useful forward pocket to apply defensive pressure. We do need to stop putting J Bolton in the forward line.

Nothing about Barlow says CHF to me. He doesn't have the presence, agro or a certain je ne se quai if you ask me.

I find it strange that he is constantly mentioned as a potential CHF.

[NMWBloods]

Nothing about Barlow says CHF to me. He doesn't have the presence, agro or a certain je ne se quai if you ask me.

I find it strange that he is constantly mentioned as a potential CHF.

I think he has the size and mobility. He's also a very good kick. Not sure about his marking yet. The presence aspect may (or may not) come with a little experience.

[NMWBloods]

Back on topic... anyone going to boo Hall if he becomes a Bulldog?

No. I don't boo players. But it will be interesting to see some responses if he does and he hits someone!!

[Lakeside]

A post in which you envisage someone in physical distress where you state you'd nod (presumably in approval) and do nothing to help.

Close enough.

now you are just nit picking. I walk past a lot of homeless people and sometimes i just nod and sometimes i just keep walking , should i be charged with physical abuse?