Brennan, Beckmans delisted

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mcs
    Travelling Swannie!!
    • Jul 2007
    • 8166

    #46
    totally agree Barlow, its bizarre though with Brennan. He has a decent enough kicking style and should be a big booming boot but more often then not he is a terrible kick.
    "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

    Comment

    • Robbo
      On the Rookie List
      • May 2007
      • 2946

      #47
      Originally posted by barlow
      People who can't kick have no place in senior AFL footy. Should've been obvious from the start. There's a couple of others in the same boat.
      Brett Kirk is one of the worst kicks of the footy I've seen.

      Do remember guys like Troy Cook and Shaun McManus?

      Comment

      • chalbilto
        Senior Player
        • Oct 2007
        • 1139

        #48
        [QUOTE=ROK Lobster;419885]
        I liked Brennan and like others would have liked to have seen him given more opportunities. Good luck to him.[
        /QUOTE]

        Originally posted by swansrule100
        why?

        because i dont agree with you.

        Bevan was just one example, and for the record i would of delisted brennan, but i would of delisted bevan about two years ago, they would be easily on par for talent, bevan is a poor kick, average handball, reasonable mark. But because he was given opportunities he has developed into a handy role player in the side.

        All im saying is given the same chances over the last two years brennan would probably of become the same sort of story, a handy player who once he knew his spot was safe could contribute to the side, he never got that.
        I know a lot of posters have bagged Brennan on this board but really he wasn't given a lot of chances. What seems odd is the fact that he was named as an emergency so many times??

        Comment

        • Bloods05
          Senior Player
          • Oct 2008
          • 1641

          #49
          Originally posted by Robbo
          Brett Kirk is one of the worst kicks of the footy I've seen.

          Do remember guys like Troy Cook and Shaun McManus?
          Kirk hits targets more often than not, and often kicks goals on the run. He is not a long kick, but he is a pretty reliable set shot from 45 metres or less. He's not stylish, but he is not a poor kick.

          Comment

          • Bear
            Best and Fairest
            • Feb 2003
            • 1022

            #50
            Originally posted by connolly
            Actually Keiran Jack is the son of a rugby league legend.
            Jack provides good PR for the Swans AND he's a good AFL footballer
            "As a player he simply should not have been able to do the things he did. Leo was a 185cm, 88kg full-back and played on some of the biggest, fastest and best full-forwards of all time, and constantly beat them." Roos.
            Leo Barry? you star! We'll miss ya, ''Leapin''.

            Comment

            • connolly
              Registered User
              • Aug 2005
              • 2461

              #51
              Originally posted by swansrule100
              why?

              because i dont agree with you.

              Bevan was just one example, and for the record i would of delisted brennan, but i would of delisted bevan about two years ago, they would be easily on par for talent, bevan is a poor kick, average handball, reasonable mark. But because he was given opportunities he has developed into a handy role player in the side.

              All im saying is given the same chances over the last two years brennan would probably of become the same sort of story, a handy player who once he knew his spot was safe could contribute to the side, he never got that.
              As a defender Brennan was at times looser than Paris Hilton's undies. But with perseverence he could have been a Leo Barry type in the backline. Disappointing we didn't keep him.
              Bevo bandwagon driver

              Comment

              • connolly
                Registered User
                • Aug 2005
                • 2461

                #52
                Originally posted by Bas
                He was talking about Bevan.
                i'll be blowed. In that case grizzles was totally wrong. The Bevanator is the grand - nephew of the Warrington Wizard.
                Bevo bandwagon driver

                Comment

                • mcs
                  Travelling Swannie!!
                  • Jul 2007
                  • 8166

                  #53
                  Kirk doesnt play in a role where he needs to be kicking accurately all the time either. As said in this thread he kicks goal often on the snap and usually can hit a target. He is not playing in a position where he either kicks a lot or has to hit the target (ie most of his kicks come either up forward or in the forward half). Whereas brennan (Except for the few times he was seen up forward) is down back and where a bad kick often will cost you a goal.
                  "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

                  Comment

                  • swansrule100
                    The quarterback
                    • May 2004
                    • 4538

                    #54
                    Originally posted by CureTheSane
                    Beven <<<<<<<<<<< swansrule 100
                    whos beven
                    Theres not much left to say

                    Comment

                    • CureTheSane
                      Carpe Noctem
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 5032

                      #55
                      Originally posted by swansrule100
                      whos beven
                      I have no idea

                      Dude, that's some of the worst selective quoting I've ever seen

                      It makes me sad
                      The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                      Comment

                      • 573v30
                        On the bandwagon...
                        • Sep 2005
                        • 5017

                        #56
                        What's this thread about again?
                        I only support one team: The SYDNEY SWANS!!!!! :adore

                        Comment

                        • CureTheSane
                          Carpe Noctem
                          • Jan 2003
                          • 5032

                          #57
                          Originally posted by 573v30
                          What's this thread about again?
                          Nick Davis
                          The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                          Comment

                          • 573v30
                            On the bandwagon...
                            • Sep 2005
                            • 5017

                            #58
                            Originally posted by CureTheSane
                            Nick Davis
                            He's definitely the centre of attention, even when he's delisted.
                            I only support one team: The SYDNEY SWANS!!!!! :adore

                            Comment

                            • giant
                              Veterans List
                              • Mar 2005
                              • 4731

                              #59
                              Originally posted by SimonH
                              The real news of the announcement is that neither O'Dwyer nor Smith have been upgraded. (Nor Murphy.) The secondary surprise (for me at least) is that Grundy and all 3 of the class of 2005 have survived. I don't think it's Sydney's way to announce delistings in two or three different phases, and so this is likely to be it.

                              The minimalist delisting struck me as a real left-field decision, but on reflection it's the Swans' own modest version of talent stockpiling in advance of the much-hyped 'compromised drafts'.

                              The sad arithmetical fact of the matter is that at least 2 of the following list of young players are unlikely to make sufficient headway next year to justify their retention on the senior list in 2010: Grundy, Thornton, Brabazon, Laidlaw, Schmidt, White, Barlow, Faulks, DOK.

                              So this decision means that if the 2009 draft is shaping up like a spud and O'Dwyer, Smith and Murphy have continued to develop as expected, we have some quality back-ups on the rookie list who can be slotted straight in to the senior list to replace those who get the boot, rather than having to punt on developing a chancy 18yo from scratch.

                              Even if the 2009 draft isn't shaping up as badly as expected, the fact that we are likely to lose Kennelly, BBBH, MOL, Crouch and Barry all in one hit at the end of the year, means we'll have a sudden player deficit. One that we don't want to have to try to fill by taking 7 players in the 2009 ND; and we already know that we can't trust trade week to bring us much of consequence any more.

                              It's basically a vote of confidence in the quality of the youth now on our list. Now they have to go out and prove the club right.
                              Nice summary Simon - all seems eminently possible to me and highlights the need to be thinking at least one draft ahead.

                              Comment

                              • The Big Cat
                                On the veteran's list
                                • Apr 2006
                                • 2356

                                #60
                                Still haven't seen anything official to confirm these delistings. Nothing on the Swans website, nor on the official AFL lists at its website.
                                Those who have the greatest power to hurt us are those we love.

                                Comment

                                Working...