Trading talk thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • hammo
    Veterans List
    • Jul 2003
    • 5554

    #91
    Originally posted by BSA5
    We should definitely look at Pearce. Not for too much though. I'd throw a 5th round pick at Westhoff.
    Despite his inconsistency, Port would rightly demand a first round pick for Pearce so it will be a short discussion at trade week.

    I'd like us to somehow get another second round pick so we have 3 picks inside the top 30. Buchanan may be an option and he has the hardness which could make him attractive to a club like Port and a few others.
    "As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk

    Comment

    • stellation
      scott names the planets
      • Sep 2003
      • 9721

      #92
      Originally posted by BSA5
      We should definitely look at Pearce. Not for too much though. I'd throw a 5th round pick at Westhoff.
      Would they fall for Schmidt + our last pick for Westhoff?

      We should look at Pearce, but I agree they'd want too much. I'd be happy to give up a 2nd round draft pick for him, and it'd still be relatively high at that, but certainly not our first pick.... would they fall for Schmidt + our 2nd pick for him?

      FWIW, I like Tim- just token South Australian to throw into the trade!
      I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
      We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his time

      Comment

      • BSA5
        Senior Player
        • Feb 2008
        • 2522

        #93
        Originally posted by stellation
        Would they fall for Schmidt + our last pick for Westhoff?

        We should look at Pearce, but I agree they'd want too much. I'd be happy to give up a 2nd round draft pick for him, and it'd still be relatively high at that, but certainly not our first pick.... would they fall for Schmidt + our 2nd pick for him?

        FWIW, I like Tim- just token South Australian to throw into the trade!
        I'd rather keep Schmidt than get Westhoff. I rate Westhoff as a potentially decent third tall, but he simply doesn't have the frame, regardless of how much meat he's got hanging off it, to be a power forward. Schmidt has shown great ability at AFL level, and only injuries have kept him out. While it's a long-shot whether he'll come good again, I don't think I could bear to see him go to another club and suddenly realise his potential. I'd be happy for him, but sad at the same time, because I really like him as a player.
        Officially on the Reid and Sumner bandwagon!

        Comment

        • Plugger46
          Senior Player
          • Apr 2003
          • 3674

          #94
          Originally posted by BSA5
          I'd rather keep Schmidt than get Westhoff. I rate Westhoff as a potentially decent third tall, but he simply doesn't have the frame, regardless of how much meat he's got hanging off it, to be a power forward. Schmidt has shown great ability at AFL level, and only injuries have kept him out. While it's a long-shot whether he'll come good again, I don't think I could bear to see him go to another club and suddenly realise his potential. I'd be happy for him, but sad at the same time, because I really like him as a player.
          Yeah, me too - huge fan of Schmidt, just wish he could get on the park for an extended period.
          Bloods

          "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

          Comment

          • i'm-uninformed2
            Reefer Madness
            • Oct 2003
            • 4653

            #95
            Dont rate Pearce. Terrific when on, but is purely a frontrunner. Never seen him stand out when Port are having an off day as a bloke trying to turn the tide.

            Works only one way, and submits to heavy tags by giving up.

            Pass.
            'Delicious' is a fun word to say

            Comment

            • Mr Magoo
              Senior Player
              • May 2008
              • 1255

              #96
              Originally posted by i'm-uninformed2
              Dont rate Pearce. Terrific when on, but is purely a frontrunner. Never seen him stand out when Port are having an off day as a bloke trying to turn the tide.

              Works only one way, and submits to heavy tags by giving up.

              Pass.
              Sounds like he will be perfect at Carlton.

              Comment

              • Ludwig
                Veterans List
                • Apr 2007
                • 9359

                #97
                Raines looking to leave Richmond

                Now here's a player that seems to fit rather well with the Swans philosophy of taking out of favour players and making them stars.



                Personally, I would think he would make a great fit into the Swans backline, teaming up with Smith, allowing both Shaw and Mattner to run in the midfield. Adds a lot more pace to the Swans attack than he brings himself.

                Also allows us to take someone other than Rohan in the draft and go for a inside ball winning skilled midfielder, like Lucas, Martin or Cunnington. I think Roos has suggested this would be his preference anyway, but adding Raines, or if Kennelly returns, it would make that decision that much easier.

                Comment

                • Armchair Coach
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 95

                  #98
                  I quite like him. Rough Diamond. His Dad was awesome.

                  Comment

                  • bigswan
                    On the Rookie List
                    • Oct 2003
                    • 174

                    #99
                    Raines wants to go home to Queensland.

                    Comment

                    • AnnieH
                      RWOs Black Sheep
                      • Aug 2006
                      • 11332

                      Originally posted by Plugger46
                      Not necessarily. He's not contracted so he could just walk to the PSD if a trade can't be done.
                      .... thereby giving us nothing.
                      That happens too much at the Swans.
                      Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
                      Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.

                      Comment

                      • Plugger46
                        Senior Player
                        • Apr 2003
                        • 3674

                        Originally posted by i'm-uninformed2
                        Dont rate Pearce. Terrific when on, but is purely a frontrunner. Never seen him stand out when Port are having an off day as a bloke trying to turn the tide.

                        Works only one way, and submits to heavy tags by giving up.

                        Pass.
                        Yeah, agree on Pearce.

                        I'd take him because he has talent but he's not worth what they'll ask for IMO.
                        Bloods

                        "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                        Comment

                        • caj23
                          Senior Player
                          • Aug 2003
                          • 2462

                          Would like to keep our first 2 picks so that obviously limits our options.

                          If we trade Hall to the Dogs, perhaps we could swap for Mal Lynch. Bit of a nothing trade but he would be a handy type if he came good.

                          The other one I wouldn't mind is Staker (ducks head!). I know he is soft but he has real talent and a bit of x factor about him. If we could do a Rhys Shaw type deal then it would be worth the risk.

                          I like Pearce but there'll be plenty of other teams interested and they won't let him go for less than a first rounder

                          Also don't understand the "trade Buchanan" mob. He's been down this year but when he is up and firing he adds alot to the team. Can break lines and adds some x factor.

                          Wouldn't mind seeing him trialled as a permanent forward pocket as he is good off the packs, chases hard and is canny around goals. Kicked 10 in a TAC preliminary final which is no mean feat

                          Comment

                          • hammo
                            Veterans List
                            • Jul 2003
                            • 5554

                            Originally posted by Will Sangster
                            Also don't understand the "trade Buchanan" mob. He's been down this year but when he is up and firing he adds alot to the team. Can break lines and adds some x factor.
                            The same things have been every off season since 2007. We're still waiting.

                            At 26 I don't see where he fits into our next premiership but as trade value, he may be exactly what some other teams are looking for.
                            "As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk

                            Comment

                            • Plugger46
                              Senior Player
                              • Apr 2003
                              • 3674

                              Originally posted by hammo
                              The same things have been every off season since 2007. We're still waiting.

                              At 26 I don't see where he fits into our next premiership but as trade value, he may be exactly what some other teams are looking for.
                              Tend to agree. I've been a big fan but he has struggled for 3 seasons and his best footy may be behind him.

                              If a trade can't be done, I'd prefer to keep him, rather than de-list him though.
                              Bloods

                              "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                              Comment

                              • Captain
                                Captain of the Side
                                • Feb 2004
                                • 3602

                                Buchanan should be played as a small forward, full stop. If it works great, if not then delist him.

                                I too reckon Staker could be a good option. Would like to see him as a 3rd defensive tall.

                                Comment

                                Working...