Gilbee was running directly away from me, so that is the first time I have seen the actual contact. Seriously, that is not suspension worthy in the least...
Teddy gets offerred a week for rough conduct - CLEARED
Collapse
X
-
If I was Ted's legal rep I would argue
Ted peeled off his man to attack the loose ball
He expected Gilbee to take possession but whe Gilbee knocked the ball on, Ted slowed up and all he did was brace for contact given the momentum of both players.
If he wanted to really hurt Gilbee, he wouldn't have slowed down and could have really done some damageComment
-
Yes it's the inconsistency that is incredibly annoying. Last year Dawson knocked Kennelly into the middle of next week, probably deliberately given his recent exploits, but at least negligently, and nothing happened to him.Comment
-
I remember the bump. The commentators at the time said there was nothing in it. My recollection is that it wasn't even deemed worthy of a free kick. To get a week for that would be an absolute joke. Not only was the contact unavoidable, but it makes the umpire look like a goose for not giving a free when he was, in fact, correct all along.
We'll probably accept the week but we should fight it. There was absolutely nothing wrong with what Richards did IMO.
DST"Looking forward to a rebuilt, new, fast and exciting Swans model in 2010"
Comment
-
Trengove offered two weeks - AFL.com.au
About 61 seconds in.
No free kick was paid, you can see the controlling umpire Meredith right in the centre of the picture and he doesn't make a signal.Comment
-
Just to up the outrage - the MRP assessed this as worthy of a *two* week suspension. Ridiculous. Ted gets it down to 1 with early plea/good record.Comment
-
The deadline was 11am. News should filter through soon.Comment
-
I accept the injustice of the MRP's decision. However, there is also the risk of Ted being out for two weeks and missing the game against Hawthorn and thereafter lacking match fitness.
No disrepect to Port Adelaide, but is it worth the risk? (Actually there is disrepect to Port)Comment
-
We are contesting!Comment
-
I think we can count on Ted to do everything possible to maintain match fitness should he get stuck with the ban.
I'm torn between knowing it should be contested due to being a ridiculous decision and not trusting the MRP to make a good decision.
We can manage against Port but I think we will need Ted against the HawksChillin' with the strange QuarksComment
-
Seriously the only option, it's just such an unjust penalty.
Given we must lodge an amount (10K?) to appeal which is withheld if the appeal is deemed frivolous, the tribunal should fine the MRP for wasting their time with a frivolous suspension.Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09Comment
-
Ted has an outstanding record for courage and fair play.
This is a shocking decision by the MRP to even lay a charge when both players were aware, ball within the play, Gilbee stands rather than be tackled with the ball and the hit was a side bump to the shoulder of the oncoming player !
All we ask is give Ted a fair go !!Comment
Comment